Plan B: Reallocating Street Space To Buses, Bikes & Peds

outside_mag.jpg

In a piece from the March issue of Outside Magazine that seems especially relevant today, Tim Sohn writes about public space reform in New York City. His article is accompanied by an illustration of what the future of our city could look like: complete streets with dedicated bus and bike lanes, traffic calming gardens, and sidewalks wide enough to accommodate window shoppers without slowing pedestrian traffic — none of which would depend on Albany for approval.

Recently, a New Yorker (let’s call him Tim) was forced off a sidewalk by a double-wide stroller, a large dog, and an elderly pedestrian all traveling abreast. So he shimmied between parked cars, nearly collided with a bike messenger going the wrong way up a one-way street, and walked through the exhaust-choked margin of the avenue while fantasizing about a future in which New York City’s clogged streets are reconfigured in favor of pedestrians and cyclists. A pipe dream? Nope, and you can thank advocacy/watchdog group Transportation Alternatives. New York is a walker’s city, but its streets, which represent 85 percent of its public space, are monopolized by the fume-spewing, driving minority.

"For so many years, the streets have just been for cars, like NASCAR speedways," says Paul Steely White, TA’s executive director. "We’re trying to reclaim the city for the people." How? Well, thanks in part to TA’s dogged pursuit of transportation reform, the city recently took a major step forward by retaining the services of the godfather of anti-automobile urbanism: Copenhagen-based urban designer Jan Gehl, whose Gehl Architects has helped draft plans for Stockholm, Melbourne, and, most famously, London. Gehl is now in the midst of an American invasion, having signed on to consult not only for New York but for Seattle and, possibly, San Francisco. The first step, he says, is getting people to think anew about urban life. "We can talk about it in terms of ingrown habits," he says. "Many people don’t ask for changes because they don’t know that changes are possible. "But NYC’s hiring of Gehl’s team is indicative of a general upsurge in both awareness of the need for change and the city’s willingness to take action."

In April 2007, Mayor Michael Bloomberg unveiled PlaNYC 2030, an ambitious 127-point strategy for the greening of the city, including ample transportation and public-space reforms. Already, pilot projects have been implemented all over New York to show people what the near future might look like: new painted, protected bike lanes on Ninth Avenue; dedicated bus lanes in Midtown; countdown signals at crosswalks; HOV/bus lanes on the Manhattan Bridge; landscaped pedestrian islands in Brooklyn’s Grand Army Plaza; a lot more bike racks. And even Bloomberg’s controversial proposal for a London-style congestion charge ($8 to drive into Manhattan) has its supporters. According to White, "A year ago, congestion pricing was impossible, all this other stuff was impossible, but now it’s a very fluid situation, and that’s exciting." Gehl sees progress, too. "In New York, they are beginning to ask the right questions," he says. "What do we have cities for? Is it for getting from A to B or is it for developing the culture?" In his estimation, New Yorkers already know the answer: "The 21st-century lifestyle has arrived in New York, but, apart from the great parks, the spaces have not been developed to accommodate it. Yet."

A PDF (4.8 MB) of the illustration can be downloaded here

  • Charlie D.
  • Jones

    Hmm… that illustration looks a tad familiar. Looks like T.A.’s complete street blueprint is generating some buzz:
    http://www.transalt.org/files/newsroom/magazine/2007/fall/10-13.pdf

    (see pages 12 and 13)

  • Larry Littlefield

    Thanks to the bike and ped advocates for being in favor of Plan A, which seemed like a good idea to me. In the past I haven’t been in favor of regulation congestion by congestion due to the needs of deliveries and emergency access but…

    I am now in favor of Plan B.

    Post collapse, we’ll need room for bikes and private vans to get around. Those too far out can telecommute, or work near where they live, at whatever wages are available there.

    The middle class, those with parking placards, can squeeze into the remaining lane.

  • Max

    Plan B is great. Make it absolutely miserable to drive and absolutely a joy to walk, bike, or take the bus. Double the size of sidewalks. Add plants and cafe space. Take a lane or two more of traffic for buses and bikes. Allocate some of the leftover parking for commercial deliveries. What beautiful avenues we would have!

  • momos

    I’m all for Plan B. But will we see ANY changes before JSK and the enlightened DOT are swept out by a new mayor?

    The problem: Community Boards. They and their hearings are filled with neurotic, narrow-minded, self-interested property owners.

  • momos

    …[property owners, as I was saying] who resist all efforts at pedestrianizing streets and pricing parking according to demand

  • Louis

    This is the Dutch/Northern Europe/Parisian system. After spending the last year in all three of those places, I can say that yes it works, and it is beautiful. And interesting to look at and experience.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The New York of 2016 Needs the Wide, Generous Sidewalks of 1906

|
The Times ran a feature on the pedestrian crush in New York City today, and as good as the photos are, they don’t do the situation justice. To get a sense of just how inadequate the sidewalks are in Midtown, you need to go there — or failing that, watch this Streetfilm from 2009 with narration by Streetsblog publisher Mark […]

The State of Livable Streets in Boston

|
The Boston Globe serves up a smorgasbord of livable streets storylines in this gripping read, "The Future of Crossing the Street." An overview of Boston’s evolving transportation scene, the piece starts with a look at the "shared space" philosophy of Hans Monderman, the pioneering Dutch traffic engineer who designed intersections with minimal controls, signals and […]

Bigger Sidewalks But No Protected Bike Lane for Houston Street

|
A photosim of the East Houston Street plan; existing condition shown inset. Image: DCP. The reconstruction of East Houston Street will include wider medians, bigger sidewalks, fewer traffic lanes, and a new bike lane. But instead of installing a physically protected path for cyclists, the city plans to paint a buffered, Class 2 lane. The […]

There Is No War On Cars

|
“The city’s war on automobiles has just gone aerial,” screamed the New York Post in a recent story about speed cameras. A Daily News op-ed in support of safety improvements proclaimed “the battle against cars has saved lives.” The Times matter-of-factly declared last month that “New York City has gone out of its way in […]