The Iris Weinshall Renaissance

weinshall.jpgDOT Commissioner Iris Weinshall’s speech was, for many long-time Livable Streets advocates, the single most remarkable aspect of yesterday’s Manhattan Transportation Policy Conference. As Jon Orcutt at TSTC noted, Weinshall’s speech "laid out an array of measures to improve New York’s pedestrian and bicycling environments, soften the quality of life impacts of heavy traffic, and begin to reclaim the sheer urban acreage given over to automobiles." Added up, these measures appear to represent the beginnings of an altogether new set of transportation, land use, and public space policies for New York City and, as Orcutt writes, "a significant departure" from past priorities.

To my ear, the most significant departure from previous policy was Weinshall’s saying, simply, that New York City needs "to reduce auto use." It may not sound like firebrand rhetoric, yet this language represents a radical shift in thinking for New York City.

For decades, New York City’s business and political decision-makers have operated under the assumption that reducing automobile traffic would hurt New York City’s economy. Only a couple of months ago Mayor Bloomberg, speaking off-the-cuff, joked, "We like traffic, it means economic activity, it means people coming here." Yet, Weinshall concluded her speech yesterday by saying the Mayor’s new Long-Term Planning Office is "carefully considering a wide range of strategies to shift travel away from the automobile and onto transit." As far as I know Weinshall has never said anything like that in public and neither has the mayor. This is not insignificant.

Now that those words have been said, DOT can start to work to make it happen. Towards that end, Weinshall said the agency has begun or completed the following initiatives:

Bus Rapid Transit: "Very shortly, we will be announcing five corridors to pilot bus rapid transit and are developing more detailed plans for these rapid routes." Weinshall said that she expects two of the corridors to be up and running by fall of 2007. New York City’s BRT system will not be given physically-separated right-of-way like Paris’s successful Mobilien but it will include "colored bus lanes, improved bus lane enforcement, signal prioritization, wider bus stop spacing, next bus information, and quicker fare collection." Making New York City’s buses work better is a major priority and it’s great to see the City taking responsibility for this rather than leaving it to the MTA.

Bicycling: The 200 miles of new bicycle lanes and route markings announced last month. We’ve written about that plenty.

Parking: The City has the opportunity to vastly improve transportation and public space through parking policy. Weinshall talked about DOT’s efforts to implement "creative curb space pricing" to encourage "truckers to rotate out of legal parking spots quickly, giving others an opportunity to load and unload." In Lower Manhattan DOT is undertaking a comprehensive curb space study including "a block-by-block survey of curb activity that will tell us where people are parking, where they’re coming from, and how long they’re parking for." Let’s hope a crackdown on government employee parking comes out of that. Sounds like the Park(ing) Squats are working.

Safe Routes to Schools: Weinshall announced that DOT has finally, after years of delay, broken through the bureaucracy and begun implementing recommendations for improving pedestrian safety around city schools. At the end of November, DOT expects "to have plans for over 750 new neckdowns and 70 pedestrian medians." And they have already "installed 69 speed reducers around other schools over the past four months."

Pedestrian and Public Space Improvements: In addition to announcing the closing of Times Square’s "bow-tie," Weinshall touted the new Willoughby Street pedestrian plaza in Downtown Brooklyn and said that next month, DOT "will create a similar space in front of Stuyvesant Town on 1st Avenue, Astor Place and Louise Nevelson Plaza" (where is that?!). But check out this language: "We at DOT are thinking of public spaces as neither parks or streets. In the years to come, DOT, working with communities and other city agencies, plans to reallocate street space in neighborhoods in all five boroughs to create many more of these public plazas. We hope to develop a framework to create neighborhood plazas in every community in the City." Again: This is significant. This is Jan Gehl language. This is the kind of thinking that has brought great public spaces, better mobility and an increasing quality of life to cities like London, Paris and Copenhagen.

With the New York City Streets Renaissance becoming the Iris Weinshall Renaissance and the Department of Transportation becoming something more akin to a Department of Streets and Public Spaces, Livable Streets advocates appear to have a whole new set of allies within city government. This is great news, yet it also means that a new set of challenges are emerging. Three that come to mind most immediately:

Devil’s in the Design (and enforcement) Details: One man’s Bus Rapid Transit lane or Bike Route may be another man’s parking lot. Bike lanes, BRT and pedestrian plazas are great, but to work they have to be designed and managed properly. It’s going to take a lot of communication and experimentation to learn what works and what does not in New York City. This is going to be a challenge.

The Multi-Agency Bureacracy: To make these changes work, governmental agencies are going to have to work together closely. It’s not just about DOT. It’s also about the MTA, Design & Construction, Parks, Education, the Mayor’s various offices, Community Boards, and probably quite a few others, not to mention the private contractors who pour most of the concrete. If, for example, the guys at DDC don’t know how to design and mass produce traffic calming measures for schools, Safe Routes for Schools isn’t going to work. The Mayor needs to convene a multi-agency meeting and make sure that everyone understands that Livable Streets are a new priority and that everyone is working together.

About Those Community Boards: New York City’s antiquated Community Board structure may very well be the 800 lb gorilla in the room. Community Boards often seem to exist in this world to say, "No" and make sure nothing ever changes in neighborhoods. Community Boards often consist of lifetime appointees who are still fighting the local battles of twenty years ago. Unfortunately, it may be the case that to get its new Livable Streets agenda done DOT is going to have to figure out how to work with — or work around — the City’s Community Board system, which is badly in need of reform.

  • JK

    “With the New York City Streets Renaissance becoming the Iris Weinshall Renaissance and the Department of Transportation becoming something more akin to a Department of Streets and Public Spaces” — Is this sarcasm? If not, it is absolutely delusional. Did Weinshall announce that DOT was keeping the full median on W. Houston, instead of installing turning bays? Did she announce car-free Central and Prospect Parks? Car-free 42nd Street? How about implementation of Downtown Bklyn Traffic Calming?

    In 1993,DOT organized a two day traffic calming seminar at NYU which drew 500 people. DOT senior planners and engineers were required to attend, and listen to the top German traffic calmers who were flown over to lead it.

    There are reasons to be skeptical.

  • crzwdjk

    Weinshall seems to be finally talking the talk, but will this talk get followed up with real action? That is the question. The DOT has made many promises over the years, the real proof will be when they start implementing things. A good start would be expanding the sidewalks in Times Square to the notional sidewalk “edges” currently painted on the street, presumably as a temporary measure.

  • I agree with the above comment that moving from talk to action is the real proof and not just token projects that are announced without much discussion. A better way would be to really think big on this stuff and involve the community stakeholders now to find win-win situations and share some of the credit. I especially loved the idea of creating new public spaces in every community. They will need to talk to community representatives to make sure they choose the right places.

    I guess the two biggest changes were an admission that too many cars are the problem and a new willingness to experiment some of the alternative proposals that have been sitting on the shelf for years, if not decades.

    Kudos to DOT though for starting to make those changes.

  • Well, it was just a speech. But I would not have written what I did without having noticed that streetsbloggers are seeing new bike lanes going in within a few weeks of the bikeway announcement and the commissioner announcing the speed-up of at least some of the BRT projects. Implementation with urgency says something is happening. Let’s watch what occurs from here and keep pushing. There is the rest of eternity to judge whether 2006 is some kind of watershed for NYC or not.

  • Daniel Millstone

    As I see it, the issue is not the DOT Commissioner (who serves at the pleasure of the Mayor). Mayor Bloomberg sends the signals; the Commissioners implement the policy selected at City Hall. When Commissioner Weinshall makes a good speech, as here, she’s to be congratulated. When she announces good new policies, it’s the Mayor who deserves the credit (As he deserves the blame for the bad policies). Don’t let us be fooled by the wizards who keep saying “don’t look behind the curtain.”

  • JK

    Who are these wizards?

    Can one arrange to speak with one? I think magical realism has big potential for solving NYC transpo woes.

  • Daniel Millstone

    As I was using the term wizard, I was referring to Mayor Bloomberg who sets Transportation Policy and sends his Commissioners out to sell it.

    When critics attack Weinshall, they sometimes forget that the policies she promotes are those of her principal.

    You can email or snail-mail the Mayor directly or just call 311.

  • Remarkable? HAHAHA. ok. So they finally are putting in some bike lanes, but barely any are padded. And all the class 3 might as well not exist. They are taking out the cross over at Times Square – big fat deal. Its the sidewalks at the edges of 7th and Broadway that are the problem where insane numbers of people are forced into walking in the Avenues anyway every day. Not to mention same problem also now exists at 8th Ave in the 40s too. So whats the plan there? Crickets. And BRT “test” lanes will go in in 2007 – what’s the matter, all the paint brush stores closed for 2004, 2005, and 2006? And JK already mentioned the cars in the parks problem.

    I’d like to talk to the wizards too, but I checked the phone call has a billion dollar surcharge.

  • We’re all prone to the occasional bout of wild-eyed optimism. So Aaron gets a pass for his Weinshall swoon. But was it a doozie!

    Iris said that NYC needs “to reduce auto use”? So did every DOT Commissioner since the Lindsay era. Without pro-active policies to de-privilege driving, it ain’t gonna happen. The inducements (subsidies) to drive are too seductive.

    DOT has started a 6-month “curb space study” to survey parking supply and demand in lower Manhattan? Wowie zowie. I smell a ploy to quell the Chinatown-led uprising against the NYPD’s I-get-to-park-free scam.

    How will we know when Iris has truly “gotten it”? How about when she announces half or more of the following:

    • I’m ordering cars out of Central and Prospect Parks.
    • I’m now bike-commuting between Prospect Park West and 40 Worth St. Y’all join me.
    • I’ve told Police Commissioner Kelly: Hands off Critical Mass.
    • Congestion pricing — it could be bridge tolls, it could be CBD cordon charging — starts in three months.
    • Existing bike lanes are being re-engineered for true traffic separation.
    • Bike lane mileage is being doubled over the next 12 months.
    • Bus Rapid Transit trials begin next month, one in each borough.
    • All pedestrian and bicycle fatalities get full, public fact- and fault-finding.
    • Illegal private parking by public employees will be shown in real time on new DOT web-cams.

    This is just a quick list. Hell, I’m sure any regular Streetsblog reader can do better.

  • JK


    You probably know this, but some may not, Iris Weinshall doesnt have the power to implement congestion pricing — nor does the mayor. It will take the governor and state legislature. Judging from her remarks on the subject and the number of visits to London she and her team have taken over the last six years, it’s a good guess she would like to announce pricing too. I’m sure she’d also love to tell Ray Kelly what to do — about anything.


New Law Encourages DOT to Set Traffic Reduction Targets

Yesterday, Mayor Bloomberg signed into law Intro 199, a bill requiring New York City’s Department of Transportation to collect and monitor data specifically aimed at helping the city "to reduce automobile traffic and encourage more sustainable means of transportation vital to combating congestion, pollution and improving the City’s long term economic health." The new law […]

The Iris Weinshall Legacy: Queens Boulevard

"What became clear to me in this discussion was that the engineers were thinking from the motorists’ viewpoint."  — Iris Weinshall, New York Newsday, April 29, 2001   A long walk across Queens Blvd. at Grand Ave., Elmhurst, circa March 2001. Photo: Jeff Saltzman Departing Department of Transportation Commissioner Iris Weinshall often cites the pedestrian […]

Weinshall Upheld a “Cars-First Status Quo,” T.A. Says

Transportation Alternatives has come out with its statement on the resignation of DOT Commissioner Iris Weinshall along with a brief to-do list for the next commissioner. Executive Director Paul White isn’t pulling punches. From T.A.: Iris Weinshall upheld the cars-first status quo at a time when New York City streets desperately needed innovation and change. […]

Envisioning a New York Where Cycling Isn’t Just for Cyclists

At a panel sponsored by the American Institute of Architects last night, two of the city’s top transportation planners joined one of its hardest-working bike advocates to discuss how to make cycling a mainstream mode in New York. The director of the Department of City Planning’s Transportation Division, Jack Schmidt, DOT Senior Policy Advisor Jon […]

Meet the New Boss

  Multiple sources say that Mayor Bloomberg has chosen Urbitran Chairman and CEO Michael Horodniceanu as New York City’s next transportation commissioner. Iris Weinshall’s last day on the job will be Friday, April 13. No word yet on when the official announcement will be.