Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In

Cops Collar Driver Who Killed Heroic Nanny — But the Charge is Merely ‘Failure to Yield’

The charges don't match the outrage that the crash provoked.

Here’s the shitshow intersection where Arielle Muschamp was killed in 2021.

|Photo: Google

Police say they've charged the driver who ran over and killed a Brooklyn nanny who pushed her young charge to safety in the nick of time — but the charges don't match the outrage that the crash provoked.

Arcellie Muschamp

Mamadou Bathily, 70, was charged with failure to yield and failure to exercise due care in the Dec. 20, 2021 crash on Fifth Avenue and Union Street in Park Slope, where cops say the Dodge Ram pickup truck driver struck Arcellie Muschamp as she crossed in a crosswalk. Witnesses said that the driver was speeding, and Muschamp, sensing that he was not going to stop, pushed from harm's way the stroller carrying 1-year-old Rowan Duhaime.

Muschamp, 52, was struck and died several days later. The driver remained at the scene. It took nearly two years for the NYPD to make the arrest, which it did on Wednesday afternoon, cops said.

Police declined to provide any other details.

Failure to yield and failure to exercise due care rarely lead to any jail time. The state Department of Motor Vehicles, which can suspend or revoke a driver's license after any fatal crash, has not held a hearing yet on the Bathily case. The agency sometimes waits until criminal proceedings are completed, though the agency sometimes does not take any action against killer drivers.

The sole improvement.Photo: Google

After the death of Muschamp, the Department of Transportation did not make any substantial safety improvements at the dangerous intersection except to add a small plastic bump to encourage drivers to make wider turns.

In just the first 11 months of this year, there have been 123 reported crashes on just the one-and-a-half miles of Fifth Avenue between Flatbush Avenue and the Prospect Expressway, according to city statistics. Those crashes injured 28 cyclists, 11 pedestrians and 24 motorists. Since January 2021, there have been 402 reported crashes, injuring a stunning 173 people, including 68 cyclists and 41 pedestrians.

This story will be updated.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Gov. Hochul Is Playing With Toys — And The Facts — In Latest ‘Propaganda’ Video on Car Insurance: Lawyers

The governor is still fighting to make it cheaper to drive with a reform that would reduce compensation to some crash victims.

February 23, 2026

Monday’s Headlines: Whiteout Conditions Edition

Lyft promised to have more crews shoveling out Citi Bikes this week than it did after January's storm. Plus more news.

February 23, 2026

STATE OF EMERGENCY UPDATE: Road Travel Ban Continues, Trains in Trouble

No travel on roads after 9 p.m., though Streetsblog's Emergency Weather Desk is now predicting 12 to 14 inches as of 1:30 p.m. on Sunday. Check back for updates.

February 22, 2026

Gov. Hochul Just Says ‘Way-No’ to Driverless Cabs Across NYS

The governor made the shocking choice to reverse her budget proposal that allowed companies like Waymo to expand throughout the state.

February 20, 2026

Friday Video: How Many ‘Better Billion’ Plans Are There?

Apparently, there are lots of better ways to spend $1 billion.

February 20, 2026

Friday’s Headlines: You’ve Gov To See It For Yourself Edition

South Bronx anti-highway advocates want Gov. Hochul to come see the site of her proposed Cross Bronx widening for herself. Plus more news.

February 20, 2026
See all posts