Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Streetsblog

Will This Be the Year When DOT Finally Legalizes Key Pro-Cycling Rules?

Could it become a reality in New York City? Photo: Jonathan Maus with the Streetsblog Photoshop Desk

Try, try again.

The city Department of Transportation is once again claiming it will tweak its rules to promote cycling and make it safer by allowing bike riders to glide through stop signs or through red lights at certain intersections — a failed effort that goes back many, many years.

According to a notice in the City Record last week, the DOT is again working on two rule changes that cyclists have long sought:

    • Allow cyclists to keep going through red lights and stop signs at so-called "Top of the T" intersections — so long as they yield to pedestrians if present. This is a version of the so-called Idaho stop, which allows cyclists to treat stop signs as yield signs and red lights as stop signs, albeit limited to intersections with no cross traffic.
    • Allow cyclists to make a right turn on a red light, again after yielding.

The agency says both changes will be implemented in the second quarter of fiscal year 2024, or sometime between October and December 2023.

Don't get your hopes up, though. In early 2021, the agency said it would make both rule changes between April and June 2021. The agency included the rule changes in its fiscal year 2022 agenda, too, and still said implementation would be between April and June 2021.

But those changes never happened. DOT spokesman Vin Barone said that delays in regulations are fairly common, but that "DOT still intends to pursue these rule changes and will follow up as we move our street safety program forward."

Meanwhile, the City Council is also getting in on the act, with Council Member Lincoln Restler (D-Williamsburg) putting up a resolution calling for the state to pass its "Idaho stop" law (S.2643/A.3986). Problem 1? Restler's reso has all of six sponsors. Seven if you include him. Problem 2? The state bills are stuck in committee, where they have been ... for years.

Restler did not return several calls, but his resolution points out many of the known benefits of allowing cyclists more flexibility on the roads. For one thing, giving cyclists a jump on a light helps "keep them out of the way of heavy automobile traffic."

And a much-cited 2010 University of California study showed double-digit percentage decreases in cyclist injuries after the implementation of the Idaho stop in Idaho.

As much as cyclists bemoan police enforcement of red lights, the NYPD doesn't write very many tickets against cyclists for running reds or stop signs. According to the NYPD, last year, cops wrote 8,869 total tickets for running reds or stop signs, or about 24 per day.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Appellate Court Allows Eric Adams To Rip Up Part of the Bedford Ave. Bike Lane

Mayor Adams can go ahead and remove three blocks of the Bedford Avenue protected bike lane, a court ruled.

July 28, 2025

Six Inane Arguments Mayor Adams Is Using To Defend Ripping Up The Bedford Ave. Bike Lane

City bureaucrats are undermining years of data-driven work to make streets safer in service of that mayor's bid to remove the protected bike lane.

July 28, 2025

Analysis: How to Leverage ‘City of Yes’ Zoning to Create More Housing Near Subways

Streetsblog analyses existing zoning, population and travel times to determine the best places for increasing housing density ... now!

July 28, 2025

Monday’s Headlines: Strung Out Edition

We're still shook about a series of string-related incidents on the Marine Parkway Bridge. Plus more news.

July 28, 2025

No Accident: Red Hook Pool Closure Saga Stems from Adams Administration ‘Underinvestment’

An Olympic-size pool in Red Hook has sat empty since the summer’s start, leaving residents in the area out to dry and pissed off in blistering, record high heat.

July 25, 2025

The Perfect Beast: Even Google’s AI Thinks Streets Are for Cars

Artificial intelligence is completely naturally addicted to promoting cars.

July 25, 2025
See all posts