Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Bicycling

DOT Unveils ‘Concepts’ For Deadly Ninth Street, But Advocates Want Something Bolder 

The crash site on Ninth Street, where Sarah Schick (inset) was killed by a truck driver. Photo: Henry Beers Shenk (main photo has been slightly altered)

The Department of Transportation will finally add a protected bike lane to a dangerous strip of Ninth Street in Park Slope that it had left out of a previous redesign despite its well-known danger — a decision that some believe led to the death of Citi Bike rider Sarah Schick in January.

DOT's initial concept, unveiled on Wednesday night, would remove parking on the block between Second and Third avenues to make room for a five-foot buffer-protected bike lane in each direction. The protected bike lanes would continue west of Second Avenue to Smith Street — where today the strip has green-painted bike lanes without any protection or separation from traffic, officials said during an in-person "community visioning session."

Meeting attendees cheered the proposed removal of an entire block of parking spots, which DOT explained was necessary to make room for safe cycling.

“It’s only 35 feet wide, so choices have to be made about what's going to fit into this space," said Preston Johnson, DOT’s project manager for the corridor. "What we want to do is be able to put protected bike lanes on both sections, and that of course requires removing some parking between Second and Third avenues."

The city's plans to redesign Ninth Street between Smith Street and Third Avenue. Photo: Julianne Cuba
The city's plans to put protected bike lanes on Ninth Street between Smith Street and Third Avenue. Image: DOT
The city's plans to redesign Ninth Street between Smith Street and Third Avenue. Source: NYC DOT

DOT also wants to remove 10-foot left turn lanes from the intersection to make room for the protected bike lanes — which, Johnson said, may eventually lead to DOT banning left turns along the corridor if the lack of turning lanes causes too much congestion.

“We might have to consider turn bans if our traffic modeling suggests that it's not going to work just by allowing vehicles to turn without a turn lane,” he told attendees.

DOT's proposal would eliminate turn bays at intersections along the strip. Image: DOT
DOT's proposal would eliminate turn bays at intersections along the strip. Image: DOT
DOT's proposal would eliminate turn bays at intersections along the strip. Image: DOT

The design presented on Wednesday was preliminary, with the actual plan for the strip to be presented to Brooklyn Community Board 6 next month.

Schick died Jan. 10 when a truck driver struck her as she biked east on Ninth Street — the sixth person to die on Ninth Street in 18 years.

In 2004, 11-year-old Victor Flores and 10-year-old Juan Angel Estrada were struck and killed by a trucker on Ninth Street at Third Avenue, while walking home from school. Fourteen years later, Dorothy Bruns hit and killed 1-year-old Joshua Lew and 4-year-old Abigail Blumenstein. Blumenstein’s mother, actress Ruthie Ann Miles, who was injured in the crash, also later lost her unborn child.

That crash led to the installation of a protected bike lane between Prospect Park West and Third Avenue despite calls for two more blocks of protection. Schick’s family members and their attorney have said her death could have been prevented if DOT had followed through on redesigning the entirety of Ninth Street in 2019.

“They knew and did nothing,” Schick’s widowed husband Maxime Le Munier said in February as he announced a $100 million lawsuit against the city for the crash. “They have a responsibility in Sarah’s death and the previous deaths as well, and it needs to change.”

Local bike and safety advocates still believe the street is in need of a radical redesign. On Wednesday, they floated more robust changes to the thoroughfare, such as converting Ninth Street into a one-way corridor. DOT put the kibosh on that idea, for now — saying it’s too complicated because the roadway is both a truck and bus route for the B61. Pols and advocates are currently calling on the city to re-evaluate the city's designated truck routes, DOT Brooklyn Borough Commissioner Keith Bray said.

“That’s something actually to consider and follow up on, but that's not a 2023 possibility,” Bray said.

The city needs to think more boldly, said Transportation Alternatives Brooklyn Organizer Kathy Park Price.

“In 2018, I'll just note that I felt that we were not doing enough …we should have gone further as a neighborhood," she said. "We did the bare minimum. And while the protected bike lane on Ninth Street in Park Slope has improved safety, we should have looked at the whole corridor. I also tonight feel like we can and should do more."

The council member who represents the area agreed that the protected bike lane is a good, urgent first step — but said the city can’t stop there.

"We heard suggestions to study this corridor and the trends around trucking, so there's work that the DOT will need to do to actually deliver, but having a protected bike lane between Second and Third is imperative," Council Member Shahana Hanif (D-Gowanus) told Streetsblog on Thursday.

"They gave us an unfinished bike lane the first time around so I would say getting this bike lane done protected bike lane done is the first step towards a more serious look at this corridor."

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Wednesday’s Headlines: Citi Bike By the Numbers Edition

Haters of Citi Bike are really going to detest the new website. Plus other news.

July 17, 2024

Once Again, There is More Evidence that Safer Streets Help Local Business

...and there's more insight into why people simply don't believe it.

July 17, 2024

Bedford Ave. Protected Bike Lane Would Benefit Residents, Businesses: Data

A new report debunks the common myth that street safety projects aren't built for the benefit of people who live in a given neighborhood.

July 16, 2024

Tuesday’s Headlines: Rajkumar’s Citywide Bid Edition

The potential candidate for city comptroller cares more about "quality of life" than transportation, she says. Plus more news.

July 16, 2024

Report: The 3 Deadliest Districts for Pedestrians are Represented by Republicans

According to Smart Growth America, Suffolk County and the southwestern part of Nassau County are the worst places to be a pedestrian in the state.

July 16, 2024
See all posts