Eyes on the Street: The Plant-Based Solution to Bike Lane Blockage

One fix for placard corruption: Put a heavy, gorgeous flower pot in the street to keep placard holders out.

The Downtown Brooklyn Partnership now has 56 planters maintaining the integrity of the Jay Street bike lane, up from 12 in early 2017. Photo: Downtown Brooklyn Partnership
The Downtown Brooklyn Partnership now has 56 planters maintaining the integrity of the Jay Street bike lane, up from 12 in early 2017. Photo: Downtown Brooklyn Partnership

The Downtown Brooklyn Partnership has sent in reinforcements to keep the Jay Street bike lanes clear of parked cars. Big, heavy, beautiful reinforcements full of foliage.

Running through the hotbed of placard corruption that is the downtown Brooklyn court complex, the Jay Street protected bike lanes require even more ceaseless vigilance than most bike lanes. Soon after the protected lanes were installed at the end of 2016, the city began using large planters to keep the bikeway clear and preserve lines of sight for pedestrians.

But some scofflaw parkers kept at it and moved the planters so they could steal street space for their cars — spoiling the redesigned Jay Street for walking and biking. When the Partnership finds out — often from posts on social media — they send crews to put the planters back in place. “It’s a bit of cat-and-mouse out there,” said Belinda Cape, chief of staff for the Partnership.

This summer, the Partnership ramped up its plant-based initiative to “impede illegal parking and improve safety for cyclists and pedestrians” on Jay Street, said Director of Operations Ryan Grew.

The Partnership has an arrangement with DOT to acquire planters that the city retires from other sites, like when a temporary plaza is upgraded with permanent materials and the heavy planters are no longer needed to demarcate space. The organization now has 56 planters deployed on Jay Street, up from 12 in the spring of 2017, according to Grew.

In addition to more planters protecting the bike lane from traffic, the Partnership has set some up next to the curb on the west side of the street south of Fulton (where Jay becomes Smith Street). The planters there deter for-hire drivers from obstructing the bike lane, which used to be common…

Image: Google Maps via Shmuli Evers
Image: Google Maps via Shmuli Evers

As of this week, the block has more planter power (Shmuli Evers, who took this photo, says these pots have been planted since he snapped this shot):

Photo copyright Shmuli Evers, used with permission.

As construction on the New York City Transit building at 130 Livingston Street wraps up, the Partnership expects to work with DOT next year on upgrading the two-block stretch of southbound bike lane on Smith Street between Fulton and Schermerhorn, Grew said.

The ultimate goal is to build out the Jay Street redesign with permanent materials, so it works the way it’s supposed to without constant vigilance. “The longer-term strategy is to show that the community really wants capital improvements and a better Jay Street,” said Grew. The planters “begin to show people what a better Jay Street can look like.”

Photo: JarekFA/Twitter
Photo: JarekFA/Twitter
  • kevd

    there’s always a cab in that lane just south of fulton.
    i’ll be on the look out if they’re now just further out (and still inthe bike lane)

  • Geck

    “upgrading the two-block stretch of southbound bike lane on Smith Street between Fulton and Schermerhorn” is good, but they also need to finish the protected lane southbound from Metrotech to Fulton.

  • Joe R.

    Flower power! Sorry, I couldn’t resist. 🙂

  • JarekFA

    the Partnership expects to work with DOT next year on upgrading the two-block stretch of southbound bike lane on Smith Street between Fulton and Schermerhorn

    Interesting how that will play out. I sent a complaint to the DoT Borough President earlier this year re: the block between Schermerhorn and Livingston and the bottleneck it causes in the morning. I noted that the north bound right turn lane is regularly used as dollar van pick-up/drop-off which causes bottlenecks as many trucks and buses go up this designated truck route. I also noted the absurdity of having curbside parking here, literally right next to a surface parking lot. The DoT Borough President wrote back that Dollar Vans shouldn’t park in no standing zones [NOTE: I believe they can do “expeditious” drop-off/pick-up in no standing zones but they certainly can’t in the active right turn lane at the intersection.] They noted that cannot install dollar van signage and to notify the local precinct re: illegal parking. They also ignored my comment re: removing the curbside parking lane. Just mindblowing. There are tons of parking lots in this area (in addition to subway lines) and we have to allocate curbside space for car storage, causing bottlenecks every morning.

    Well, as chance would have it, on my ride in on Tuesday morning, the Dollar Van couldn’t park in the right turn lane, because the NYPD was parked there. Instead they were parked in the lone travel lane causing everyone to cross the double yellow. Like what a #VisionZero f—ing disaster.


    See tweet below documenting the high bike volumes. This stretch gets totally jammed up by just 4 or 5 vehicles. There were twice that many people on bike taking up the space of 2 cars. I’m sick of the ribbon cuttings over such incremental gruel. We’re the densest place in the NYC and we should organize our streets accordingly instead of being captured by the car owning minority.

  • Brilliant ! A much better option than cars , and a benefit for pedestrians as well.

  • HamTech87

    Is there a plowing plan for the snow?


Sneak Preview: The Jay Street Protected Bike Lane

Tonight, DOT will present plans for a protected bike lane on Jay Street in Downtown Brooklyn to the Brooklyn Community Board 2 transportation committee. DOT shared this rendering of the redesign with Streetsblog this afternoon. Jay Street is an essential connection for bike commuters traveling over the Manhattan Bridge, but it’s chaos during rush hour, when cyclists must weave around a slalom […]

Reimagining Jay Street With Shared Space and Protected Bike Lanes

Jay Street is one of the major north-south spines of Downtown Brooklyn. The street is full of pedestrians near MetroTech, cyclists going to and from the Manhattan Bridge, and buses connecting to nearby subways, but it’s not designed to serve anyone particularly well — except, perhaps, people with parking placards. Double-parked cars constantly obstruct bike lanes […]

Eyes on the Street: The Jay Street Bike Lane Gets Protected

That’s right: There’s now a stretch of parking-protected bike lane on Jay Street in downtown Brooklyn. The project’s not done yet, but this afternoon DOT tweeted this photo showing a rideable section on southbound Jay near Myrtle Avenue. Implementation of the Jay Street redesign began last Thursday, when crews started to remove the old un-protected bike lane markings overnight. When […]

Fixing Jay Street Starts With Cracking Down on Illegal Parking

Jay Street, the north-south route often overshadowed by nearby car-clogged Adams Street and Flatbush Avenue, is a major artery in the heart of Downtown Brooklyn, flush with pedestrians going to and from the subway and cyclists heading to the Manhattan Bridge. It’s also overrun with illegally-parked drivers, creating an obstacle course for anyone trying to navigate […]