New Yorkers’ Opinion of Congestion Pricing: Same as It Ever Was

To increase public approval of congestion pricing, first you have to enact congestion pricing.

This hurts our city — and our lungs.  Photo: giggel/Wikimedia Commons
This hurts our city — and our lungs. Photo: giggel/Wikimedia Commons

A new Quinnipiac poll is making the rounds and one of the topline numbers is that more New Yorkers oppose congestion pricing than approve of it, 52 to 42 percent. With budget negotiations culminating in Albany, it’s getting headlines.

But this week’s Q poll is basically showing what every congestion pricing poll in New York always finds: About 40 percent of city voters say they support congestion pricing. (At 42 percent, the most recent poll puts approval a couple of points higher than the 40 percent in October’s poll, but the difference is well within the margin of error.)

You could keep on polling New Yorkers forever, and this number won’t change much. Unless legislators go ahead and implement congestion pricing — then it’s a good bet support will rise.

That’s what happened in Stockholm and London, where the experience of congestion pricing flipped public opinion from majority disapproval to majority approval. As in New York, about 40 percent of Stockholm residents approved of congestion pricing before it was implemented. Fast forward a few years after implementation, and approval stood at 70 percent. There’s been no turning back.

“The closer you get to implementation, the more the drawbacks stand out,” Stockholm transportation director Jonas Eliasson said at a TransitCenter event in November. “If you survive this valley of political death, and people actually see the benefits, and also realize that, in addition to the benefits, it’s actually not as bad as you thought — it’s not so hard adapting to this — then support starts going up again.”

There's a political payoff from congestion pricing. First you have to get through the "valley of death." Graph: FHWA/CURACAO
There’s a political payoff from congestion pricing. First you have to get through the “valley of death.” Graph: FHWA/CURACAO

What has changed over time in the Quinnipiac poll is New Yorkers’ opinion of traffic congestion and subway service.

Today, 55 percent of New York City voters now see traffic congestion as a “very serious” problem, a significant increase from the 48 percent in 2015.

The real stark change is apparent in New Yorkers’ opinion of MTA subway service. In 2009, 52 percent of Q poll respondents rated subway service as “good” or “excellent.” Today, only 26 percent do. Only 40 percent rated subway service “poor” or “not so good” in 2009. Today, 70 percent do — a six-point jump since October.

More people hold the governor responsible for the subways than the mayor, and they’re right. This is Cuomo’s problem to solve. What’s he going to do about it?

  • Larry Littlefield

    “This is Cuomo’s problem to solve. What’s he going to do about it?”

    People agree with DeBlasio that a “$millionaires tax” should be used to fund the MTA. What no one wants to talk about is that a higher state income tax rate on high earners (and not just “$millionaries”was put as a temporary measure during the Great Recession, and then made permanent.

    So we already had that tax increase. And I guess Cuomo could use that money to fund the MTA, along with the hidden $billions from the two sets of books. But somehow, for reasons NO ONE wants to get into, that money doesn’t seem to be available, now does it?

    How about raising the state and local income tax rate on retired public employees above zero? No one wants to talk about that, either. And they still want a congestion pricing exemption for placard holders.

  • AMH

    That graph is very interesting. I really doubt whether we have leaders who are courageous enough to get us through that political valley.

  • Moshe Pipik

    I have a question to ask which I can never find.
    Do the other cities have $ 12.50 tolls coming over the bridge. Remember that is one way. The Midtown Tunnel is half the price but is charged both ways so not much difference. That would be around $ 25.00 a day plus the highest gas taxes. The highest car fees. Etc etc. Does London have those other tolls? Stockholm?


New Pricing Poll Hits the Spin Cycle

A Quinnipiac Poll released today shows that citywide support for congestion pricing remains consistent at 57 percent — compared to 58 percent a month ago — assuming fees can be used to prevent transit fare increases. Given those conditions, Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens showed majority support for pricing, with Staten Island opposed (45% in favor to […]

Compromise “Ruled the Day” at Congestion Pricing Hearings

#Persons %Persons Position 39 26% Support congestion pricing as proposed by Mayor Bloomberg in April 2007 PlaNYC proposal 46 31% Support the concept of pricing, have concerns and recommend changes/additions to Mayor Bloomberg’s proposal 13 9% Express serious concerns with the current proposal and offer suggestions for improvement 39 26% Oppose congestion pricing, suggest other […]

Q Poll: New Yorkers Favor Pricing as Transit Funding Source

A Quinnipiac Poll released today shows once again that New Yorkers are decidedly in favor of congestion pricing with revenues allocated for mass transit. The latest numbers indicate 59 percent approval vs. 38 percent opposed. Here’s the breakdown by borough: Manhattan: 73% – 23% Bronx: 57% – 39% Brooklyn: 51% – 46% Queens: 58% – […]