Eyes on the Street: The Fifth Avenue Bike Lane Gets Flipped

Fifteen blocks of the busiest bike route in Manhattan won't be a slalom course around double-parked cars any longer.

At 23rd Street, the Fifth Avenue bike lane is now protected from moving traffic by parked cars. Photo: Justin Pollock
At 23rd Street, the Fifth Avenue bike lane is now protected from moving traffic by parked cars. Photo: Justin Pollock

DOT crews made quick progress on striping Fifth Avenue’s new protected bike lane this week. The project flips the parking lane along 15 blocks of the old buffered bike lane, providing protection from moving traffic between 23rd Street and 8th Street [PDF].

Fifth Avenue gets more bike traffic than any other Manhattan avenue despite a severe double-parking problem that forces cyclists to weave in and out of its 1980s-era buffered bike lane. Manhattan Community Boards 2 and 5 voted for DOT’s plan to protect the bike lane this spring.

Transportation Alternatives and its volunteer Manhattan committee have been running a long-term campaign to win more space for transit, biking, and walking on Fifth and Sixth avenues. By 2014, Council Member Dan Garodnick and Community Boards 2, 4, and 5 had signaled support for the idea of “complete streets” on both. A petition specifically calling on DOT to “flip” the Fifth Avenue bike lane garnered 17,000 signatures.

DOT crews have laid down thermoplastic stripes for the new design. Green paint and bike stencils are on the way, as are plastic bollards on the southernmost block of the protected lane, between 9th Street and 8th Street. The block between 8th Street and Washington Square is not slated for a bike lane upgrade.

This project is pretty low-hanging fruit for DOT and essentially brings the existing section of bike lane up to the agency’s current safety standards without major adjustments to motor vehicle capacity. North of 23rd Street, DOT recently installed a protected bike connection on Fifth Avenue from Broadway via 25th Street. In the heart of Midtown, there’s still no bike lane.

To create a complete north-south protected bike route connecting people to the city’s densest cluster of jobs and attractions, the Sixth Avenue bike lane has to be extended north of 33rd Street, and the Fifth Avenue bike lane has to go north of 25th. Wider sidewalks will need to be part of those plans too.

  • super excited to use this. i’ve been doored twice on 5th avenue below 23rd.

  • Vooch

    thank Janet & Willow plus the rest of the TA volunteers. They spent beaucoup time on this.

    BTW – Fifth should be car free from 58th to 34th to protect our President from car bombs. It will be hard on us New Yorkers to pedestrianize Fifth, but if it’s for our President we’ll do it

  • guest

    I really really need DOT to build something going south through Midtown from CP down though; 5th Ave, 7th Ave, whatever it is, PLEASE don’t make us detour to the horrible-quality 9th Ave lane or the deathtrap that is the 2nd Ave lane.

  • J

    Great, but why did it take so long to do such an obvious project? Do we really need a TA campaign for each and every decent bike lane project in NYC?!? Given the (lack of) leadership we’ve seen from Polly Trottenberg and Bill De Blasio, it seems that the current answer is a resounding “Yes”.

    As such, I guess let’s go ahead and start fund-raising and drafting petitions for the “Connect Midtown” and “River-to-River” campaigns.

  • AMH

    Exactly–let’s not let a good crisis go to waste!

  • MoveMidtownNow
  • Vooch

    glad you think protecting our president from car bombs is so vital

  • William Lawson

    Actually I don’t mind taking Broadway downtown from CP to Union Square. It’s one of the least harrowing routes in Manhattan, apart from a brief interlude through Times Square (which isn’t that bad really – just two or three blocks of no bike lane until you get past those cops blocking the raised lane).

  • William Lawson

    I never go within an open door’s length of a car.

  • BruceWillisThrowsACar@You

    It is essential to our daily life and patriotic values.

  • Vooch

    It’s totally worth giving up Fifth Ave to protect our President.

  • qrt145

    Going through Herald Square on a bike is unpleasant enough that I prefer to take my chances on 7th Ave.

  • Vooch

    check out the TA movemidtown campaign linked above – it’s exactly what you want 🙂

  • i see what you are doing here. and i like it.


Fifth Avenue is the most heavily cycled southbound avenue in Manhattan, even though it doesn’t have a protected bikeway. Image: Google Maps

This Week: See the DOT Fifth Avenue Bikeway Plan

On Thursday, DOT will reveal its plan for a protected bike lane on Fifth Avenue. Fifth gets more bike traffic than any other southbound avenue in Manhattan, according to DOT bike counts, and New Yorkers have been asking the city to make it a complete street for years. DOT committed to studying a redesign in 2014.

Tonight: Crucial Meeting on Lafayette Street Protected Bike Lane

NYC DOT’s proposal to upgrade the northbound buffered bike lane on Lafayette Street and Fourth Avenue to a protected lane is up for a vote at Community Board 2 tonight, and while the plan sailed through the board’s transportation committee earlier this month, a “Yes” vote is far from a sure thing. Redesign opponents who didn’t […]