Skip to Content
Streetsblog New York City home
Streetsblog New York City home
Log In
Barcelona

New York City Sidewalks Don’t Have to Be Garbage Dumps

Above-ground waste receptacles in Barcelona. NYCHA may use giant trash containers like these. Photo: Clarence Eckerson Jr.

In many parts of the city, sidewalks are too narrow for two people to walk abreast comfortably. One way NYC compromises the walking environment is by dumping garbage on the sidewalks before pick-up.

Whether in commercial or residential areas, every week people are forced to walk around mountains of waste on streets where curb lanes are reserved for vehicle storage.

For his "Rebranding Driving" series, Streetfilms' Clarence Eckerson Jr. took a walk with pedestrian advocate Christine Berthet to survey sidewalks in Hell's Kitchen prior to pick-up time:

It's gross & unfair that pedestrians are overwhelmed by sidewalk garbage in parts of NYC. It's tough for parents w/strollers, seniors & people in wheelchairs. Let's change that and start dedicating road space to a #GarbageLane. @MarkGortonNYC @Chekpeds @StreetsblogNYC @Gothamist pic.twitter.com/IXI4f6nRmH

— ?????????? ??????? (@RebrandDriving) May 16, 2018

Dumping trash on the sidewalks is not just unsightly. As shown in the video, it creates pinch points, which can be impossible to navigate for people with strollers or in wheelchairs. Sidewalk garbage was also cited as a contributing factor in the death of Andrew Schoonover on the Upper East Side in 2012.

There's another way. Over the weekend Clarence sent these shots from Barcelona.

barcelona2

Notice the refuse bins are sited on asphalt, rather than the sidewalk. The trash is out of sight, and people aren't tripping over it.

barcelona1

The video features pics from other cities with similar systems.

New York has room to get trash off sidewalks. What it needs is the political will to use curb space for something other than parking.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog New York City

Eyes On The Street: Coastal Resiliency Causes Mess For Pedestrians and Cyclists

Unfortunately for cyclists and pedestrians, this situation won't be fixed until "at least 2026.”

State Pols Still Haven’t Spent Millions Alloted for Transit as Congestion Pricing Looms

There's like $45 million sitting there — unspent — for outer borough transit improvements. What are state pols waiting for?

April 30, 2024

Supporters, Mayor Rally for ‘City of Yes’ Zoning Change as it Enters Public Review Phase

The mayor's signature zoning plan is ready for review by all 59 community board, plus the city's five borough presidents and then each Council member. Advocates are worried it will be watered down.

April 30, 2024

‘Buy, Bully, Bamboozle’: Report Alleges App Companies Threaten Democracy

App delivery companies seek to block worker-led improvements by spending big money on political influence, leveraging their data, and even co-opting progressive language, argues a new report that lands days before a national one-day strike by app-workers. 

See all posts