Survey: With Parents Worried About Safety, Few NYC Students Bike to School

Although 70 percent of students said they live Images: Department of Health and Mental Hygiene
Although most sixth-graders surveyed live close enough to school to bike there, few of them do. Most students and their parents said local streets aren’t safe enough for biking. Images: Department of Health and Mental Hygiene

Just one percent of sixth-graders surveyed at 15 schools in Brooklyn, Manhattan, and the Bronx said they get to class by bike, scooter, or skateboard, according to a survey released by the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene last week [PDF]. Although most students live within walking distance of school, many of them take buses or cars to get to class. The report’s implication is clear: The rate of walking and biking to school in NYC may be far higher than other parts of the country, but there’s plenty of room for improvement.

The survey, first reported by Capital New York, is from the newly-formed Center for Health Equity, funded with $3.2 million in the de Blasio administration’s executive budget to address public health problems that disproportionately affect communities of color. The health department surveyed 1,005 sixth-graders, 24 parents, and principals at 15 schools in East Harlem, Bedford Stuyvesant, Bushwick, Highbridge, and Morrisania. It is not a representative sample of all NYC students, but it shows how kids get to school in walkable areas where most people are in the habit of getting around without driving.

Although 75 percent of students live within 20 blocks of school (about a mile), not all of these kids walk or bike to class. About 60 percent of all students said they walk, and just one percent arrive by bike, scooter, or skateboard. Nearly four in ten students don’t walk or bike, with 24 percent taking an MTA bus or subway, 14 percent being driven to school, and two percent riding a yellow school bus.

While a 61 percent mode share for active transportation might sound good compared to a national average of 13 percent, there’s a lot of room for improvement. The schools surveyed are located in zip codes that had a Walk Score greater than 85 out of 100, placing them in some of New York’s more walkable neighborhoods.

It’s hard to say how these numbers compare to other NYC schools because students and parents are rarely surveyed on travel choices. DOT said that in the relative handful of schools it works with directly, it typically finds that three-quarters of elementary students walk to school. At most middle and high schools, three-quarters of students walk or take transit. As with the DOHMH study, DOT said bike-to-school numbers barely register.

In the survey, bike- and walk-to-school rates fell steeply as distance from school increased — even at walkable distances like 11 blocks, or about half a mile. Within five blocks of school, 94 percent of students walk or bike. Between six and 10 blocks, that number falls to 79 percent. It drops to 45 percent for students who live 11 to 15 blocks away and to 24 percent for students 16 to 20 blocks away. Only 3 percent of students who live more than 20 blocks from school walk or bike there, according to the survey.

About 15 percent of students live between 11 and 20 blocks away from school — distances that are easily walkable or bikeable but where active transportation rates are under 50 percent. About 25 percent of students live more than 20 blocks from school, where biking would be especially useful.

Parents in the focus groups, which were two-thirds women, told the health department that their top concerns are making sure kids get to school quickly and safely. For short distances, active transportation takes the same or less time than other options, though many parents opt for other modes because they are worried about safety. Traffic isn’t the only concern, either. Parents said they are also wary of criminal or gang activity, and the potential for bullying or fights with other children.

Parents use a variety of tools to deal with these concerns. Some accompany their kids all the way or part-way to school; others have a “buddy system” with other students at the same school.

When looking at traffic safety specifically, parents said they worry about reckless drivers, dark streets, and the availability of crossing guards. Many said they don’t let their kids bike to school because they fear drivers don’t respect bike lanes and won’t look out for people riding bikes. “Parents also believe that sixth graders are too young and inattentive to ride responsibly,” the report says.

“You have delivery trucks, the school buses, people driving their own kids. You are just scared to send your kid off on a bike,” a Bronx parent said in one focus group. Students themselves have doubts about street safety, with just 49 percent saying it is safe to walk near their school, and 32 percent saying it is safe to bike around school.

There’s another possible reason why bike-to-school rates in NYC are so low: Few schools do much of anything to promote bicycling. The report found that just two of the 15 schools surveyed have a bike rack or safe place for storing bikes, scooters or skateboards during the school day. In addition, only two schools reported hosting an activity that encouraged active transportation in the past year.

“You have to get everybody involved for the child to be able to go, on a bike, to school,” said one Brooklyn parent in a focus group. “And the school itself has to have parking for it.”

There are city programs to encourage biking and walking to school, but they have a limited reach.

The Brooklyn District Public Health Office has worked with a handful of schools in Brownsville and East New York on bike- and walk-to-school programs, including walking school buses, street safety audits, bicycle mechanics classes, and bicycling clubs.

Today, DOT began accepting applications for its third annual Bike to School program for middle and high schools. Participating schools receive, among other interventions, an in-classroom curriculum, helmet fittings, helmet giveaways, and bike rack installations over a three-year period. DOT will select up to five schools to participate in this competitive program.

Most promising is changing the streets themselves to become safe enough for kids to walk or bike. Last year, Columbia University academics studied DOT’s Safe Routes to School program, which adds safety improvements like crosswalks and curb extensions to areas around schools. The study found that traffic injuries to school-age children dropped by a third in areas where the Safe Routes to School program had been introduced.

DOT has secured federal funding to expand the program, but it is far from reaching all of the city’s schools. The health department report recommends the de Blasio administration’s Vision Zero initiative feature greater interagency collaboration on reducing barriers to walking and biking to school, including a focus on creating new protected bike lanes where young bike riders and their parents feel safe.

  • BBnet3000

    I don’t have kids, but to be honest I’d be quite worried about them cycling in New York with the streets the way they are today. Schools are sadly where you see some of the most reliable double parking in bike lanes too. Literally every commute home I have to take the lane passing the Hellenic Classical Charter School in Park Slope on the fairly high traffic 5th Ave (high enough car traffic to require a segregated cyclepath in The Netherlands?).

    Is there any infrastructure in New York that can rightfully be called 8-80 design, other than the Hudson River Greenway and the short older sections of the 8th/9th Ave protected bike lanes? How many schools are actually close to those?

  • Vernon6

    If these are the dismal findings from the ‘best city for biking in the usa’, imagine what it’s like in others.

  • Greg Costikyan

    I or my sweetie occasionally bike to school with our middle-school-aged daughter. It’s a straight shot up the Hudson River bike path to 18th, and only a couple of crosstown blocks to her school, so fairly minimal risk. However, there is not only no secure bike storage at the school, there’s not even a rack outside. Consequently it works like this; I rent a Citibike, she rides her bike, I return the Citibike, then pull out her seat to its highest point, and pedal back on it, looking like an idiot on a pink-and-purple kid’s bike.

  • Jonathan R

    I can attest that the three Bronx zip codes the survey studied suffer from degraded pedestrian (and bicycle) infrastructure, so no wonder half the students don’t think it’s safe to walk around school.

    The issue that Stephen Miller avoids discussing is that without safe, inexpensive transportation, the concept of school choice is meaningless.

    General education public schools that enroll sixth- and seventh-grade students within the selected zip codes were recruited to participate….Most students (70%) live within 15 blocks of school, and 42% live within five blocks of school…

    I bet parents with cars are sending their kids further away to schools of choice.

  • IlIlIl

    The way I see kids ride around when I see them ride around makes me okay with them not cycling to school.

    Kids do dumb shit.

  • walks bikes drives

    Storage is a major issue. Our school (teacher) does not allow kids to bring skateboards or scooters into the building. There is no where to safely store them. I bring my own bike into my classroom. My students know I bike every day. I get koodoes from them especially when it is freezing cold. This has sparked a few of them to ride themselves over the years, but they are stuck locking their bikes up to sign posts outside where other students might even mess with their bikes. Add that to the safety issue, and I am not surprised few students ride a bike.

  • Zee

    A boy walking home from school got hit by a car outside JHS 157 last week in Forest Hills, Queens. He was a block away from the school on yellowstone boulevard. I see no news reports of this accident anywhere, and even the school did not send out a notice to us parents. His head was bleeding, and I think he broke something, but he will be okay. It really is bad out there for kids just walking-never mind biking.

  • erica holder

    When my son started high school in SoHo, he considered riding there. But then he saw how difficult it would be to get from the Hudson River Greenway to 6th Avenue and dropped the idea.

  • MarkinArl

    Ask Bono how safe cycling is.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

STREETSBLOG USA

Report: More Kids Are Walking to School

|
The long–term decline of walking and biking to school has been linked to the childhood obesity epidemic, a big share of morning rush hour traffic, and even kids’ lack of attention in class. In 1969, 41 percent of children in grades K–8 lived within one mile of school, and of those kids, 89 percent usually walked or biked. By […]

Confirmed: New Yorkers Reap Health Benefits From Walking and Biking

|
Graphic: NYC Department of Health The NYC Department of Health announced the results of a citywide survey today [PDF] assessing the health benefits of regular walking and biking. Based on telephone interviews with more than 10,000 New Yorkers, the health department reveals that people who incorporate walking and biking into their daily routine are significantly […]

A Bike-to-School Bright Spot in NYC

|
Photo: Josh Brustein/New York Times. No sooner did Brad post about the dismal state of biking to school in most of the country than City Room published this great little story about the opposite trend here in New York. A few dozen schools are trying to make it easier for students and parents to bike […]