Car2Go Launches in Brooklyn — Users Will Have to Pay at Parking Meters

Point-to-point car-share service Car2Go will launch next month across the western third of Brooklyn. One of the questions hanging over the launch was whether the company would pay the city to let its customers park for free at metered spaces. Now we have an answer: DOT will not change its parking rules to accommodate Car2Go, whose customers will have to pay to use metered spaces. In areas with a high concentration of meters, the company will secure private off-street parking for its users.

Car2Go will operate on NYC's residential streets, which offer free parking. The city hasn't made a deal with the company for metered spaces. Photo: Car2Go
Car2Go will operate on NYC’s residential streets, which offer free parking. The city hasn’t made a deal with the company for metered spaces. Photo: Car2Go

On October 25, Car2Go will launch operations with 400 vehicles across a 36-square-mile zone covering much of northwest Brooklyn, as well as areas west of Coney Island Avenue and Ocean Parkway. Customers can end their trips at any legal parking space anywhere within the zone, with a few exceptions.

Parking lanes that become moving lanes during rush hour are a no-no. On streets that are swept four days a week, customers can’t park if the sweeping is less than 12 hours away. If the street is swept twice a week, customers can leave a vehicle no more than 24 hours before sweeping.

In many of the cities where it operates, Car2Go pays a fee to local governments for access to residential permit zones. Since New York gives away most of its curbside space for free, that’s not an issue for Car2Go. It’s setting up shop without coming to an agreement with DOT.

The company also usually pays local governments to let customers use metered parking for free, either to run errands or to end their journey in a metered spot.

Offering a pass on meters negates the purpose of parking prices — to ensure turnover. If a Car2Go user closes out a trip at a meter, there’s no guarantee that another customer will hop in the vehicle a short time later.

While research shows that car-share services have reduced car ownership rates in some cities, it’s an open question if that applies in a dense, transit-rich city like New York, which already has a low car ownership rate. If most Car2Go customers already do not own cars, the service could encourage them to drive for trips they would have otherwise taken by transit or bike.

DOT is not alone in refusing to work out a deal allowing Car2Go customers to skirt parking meter rules. The company says it operates in Montreal and Toronto under a similar arrangement, and has signed up 54,000 members in both cities in two years.

Car2Go says it is working with private parking operators to purchase off-street spots for its customers “where metered parking is prevalent,” though it declined to name specific neighborhoods where it’s looking to secure off-street parking. While major commercial streets throughout the borough have parking meters, the greatest concentration of metered streets is in Downtown Brooklyn, which conveniently has a glut of off-street parking due to outdated zoning rules that have since been partially reformed.

  • Jeff

    As a transportation advocate, I haven’t really made up my mind. But as a consumer who just moved and needs to pick up a few things that are too large for transport by bike/transit, too small to justify renting a van, and too infrequent to justify paying a monthly fee for subscription-based car-sharing services, I say Hell Yeah!

  • Alan

    Hertz & Enterprise also offer car-share without the monthly fee, too. And you can always take a cab/car service with bulky items— most of them have minivans, which can hold a lot, versus the piddly li’l Smart Car.

    But I certainly agree, as a consumer— more travel options are nice.

  • street_user

    But these are more driving options–options for people who largely already have options. From a public policy perspective, it seems like a bad idea to be introducing another option to make it even easier to drive. This is basically PRT on rubber wheels.

  • Lee Haber

    Car2go isn’t subscription based. There is an initial membership fee and then it’s all pay as you go.

    As an active transportation advocate, I support it. The most wasteful thing about automobiles is they take up space most of the time and are unproductive. I’ve heard that one car sharing vehicle replaces 15 private ones

  • andrelot

    We shouldn’t reflexively refuse the role of cars in transportation, though it doesn’t mean it should be responsible for 80% of all passenger-mile trips in Bay Area…

  • Chris Mcnally

    I would prefer reserved on street spaces for car2go on every block. Zip car is a slight hassle because you have to go to a parking garage to get the car. Reserved parking on the street (as well as one way rental) are the two incentives needed to reduce car ownership in a typical Brooklyn neighborhood.

    I don’t know that someone like my mom would switch to car share, but many people who are considering buying a car might not given a really attractive alternative.

  • Tristan

    I couldn’t park my car the other day on the block I live on because atleast a dozen of these cars are scattered around by my house. It makes parking a nightmare now.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

As Car2Go Eyes NYC, Will DOT Put a Price on Curbside Parking?

|
Many New Yorkers are familiar with car-sharing services — like Zipcar, Hertz Connect, Enterprise CarShare, and Carpingo — that charge by the hour or day, with a reserved space where customers must start and finish a round-trip rental. Daimler-owned Car2Go operates differently: it charges by the minute or hour, and is focused on one-way rentals, allowing users […]

Levine’s Car2Go Bill Needs Cold Hard Data on Company’s Traffic Impact

|
This afternoon, Council Member Mark Levine will introduce a bill [PDF 1, 2] requiring DOT to give car-share companies designated on-street parking spaces, potentially for a price. Guaranteed parking would boost car sharing, Levine says, and reduce car ownership. Trouble is, there’s not much data to say whether or not car-share in New York is reducing vehicle ownership or just encouraging more driving. […]
STREETSBLOG USA

Seattle Car-Share Is Growing, But Is It Cutting Traffic?

|
After launching a pilot program three years ago enabling the company car2go to use on-street parking spots for its car-share fleet, Seattle is pursuing an expansion that would allow new companies to enter the market and dramatically increase the availability of point-to-point car-share vehicles. Scott Bonjukian at The Urbanist has the details about the expansion […]

DOT Replaces Loading Zones With Metered Parking Along B44 SBS Route

|
DOT announced today that it will adjust the curbside parking rules on Nostrand Avenue in Flatbush, where B44 Select Bus Service launched in November 2013. The agency plans to replace some commercial loading zones with metered parking along the half-mile stretch of Nostrand between Empire Boulevard and Parkside Avenue. DOT says the changes, which merchants asked for, won’t lead to more bus […]