Bike-Share Works Just Fine in Historic London, Boston, and DC Neighborhoods

Sumner Place in the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea has homes dating to the 19th century, luxury SUVs built in the early 21st century — and a bike-share station sponsored by a multi-national bank. Photo: ##https://maps.google.com/maps?q=25+Sumner+Place,+London,+United+Kingdom&hl=en&ll=51.491258,-0.173733&spn=0.007655,0.017209&sll=51.491257,-0.173743&sspn=0.007709,0.017209&oq=25+Sumner+Place+London&hnear=25+Sumner+Pl,+London+SW7+3NT,+United+Kingdom&t=m&z=16&layer=c&cbll=51.491258,-0.173733&panoid=wlLCF9C3H7uXSciDfeUZbg&cbp=13,146.75,,0,-1.37##Google Maps##

While polls have shown that upwards of 70 percent of New Yorkers support bike-share and DOT engaged in a multi-year public process for station siting, a vocal minority in Fort Greene is objecting to public bike stations in the landmarked district. At least one extremist has gone so far as to tar newly-installed stations with wheatpaste posters decrying the Citibank-sponsored kiosks. In response to the neighborhood chatter, Council Member Tish James has scheduled a community meeting about bike-share for tonight.

The historic preservation arguments simply fail to hold any water. The Landmarks Preservation Commission has signed off on the stations. Take a stroll in Boston or Washington, and you’ll see that other cities have managed to introduce bike-share stations on historic residential streets without harming their architectural legacy. And a quick glance at historic Fort Greene will reveal that its residential streets and sidewalks already have commercial activity in the form of bus shelter advertisements, newspaper boxes, and ice cream trucks.

One of the arguments against the bike-share stations is that sponsorship from a multi-national corporation like Citi has no place in historic neighborhoods. This, of course, conveniently overlooks the Coca-Cola logo on a Fort Greene storefront or the brightly-colored cars with BMW and Volvo logos parked throughout the neighborhood, which have failed to attract the ire of the anti-bike crowd.

It also doesn’t account for Boston, a city full of historic neighborhoods where the Hubway system is sponsored by footwear manufacturer New Balance, and London, where the bike-share system is named for another financial giant, Barclays Capital.

In fact, some of London’s most historic neighborhoods, including pricey West End districts like Mayfair, Kensington, and Chelsea, have Barclays-sponsored bike-share stations on residential streets. When the stations were first installed in 2010, neighbors raised an array of bizarre objections, from bird droppings to human rights violations — and yes, historic preservation.

But as the system has rolled out and proven to be a big success, the objections have waned. As the later phases of the system have come online, elected officials who had accommodated the initial complaints by slowing implementation have been less likely to give serious attention to the dwindling NIMBYs. “The administration was considerably less sympathetic to concerns that were purely subjective and hampered the roll out in phase one,” London bike blogger Danny Williams told Streetsblog.

In Washington, DC, 37th Street NW is within a federally-designated historic district and contains a Capital Bikeshare station on a residential street. Photo: ##https://maps.google.com/maps?q=37th+and+o+st+nw+washington+dc&ll=38.907699,-77.071624&spn=0.010887,0.014441&hnear=37th+St+NW+%26+O+St+NW&gl=us&t=m&z=16&layer=c&cbll=38.907568,-77.07161&panoid=w4vKeKh7Qj5hDH57aK9ZoQ&cbp=12,5.56,,1,-3.34##Google Maps##

The irrational objections on display in NYC are best summed up by this account from WNYC of a woman watching a bike-share station installation from her third-floor window in Greenwich Village, another historic New York neighborhood. “This is going to ruin the block!” she shouted at the workers, over the sounds of a blaring car alarm.

If the experience of other bike-share cities is any guide, in the not-too-distant future, when bike-share isn’t so new anymore, the objectors will come around and realize that public bike stations are nothing to be afraid of. In the meantime, if you live in Fort Greene or Clinton Hill, the forum organized by Council Member James is happening tonight at 6:30 p.m. at the Benjamin Banneker Academy, 71-77 Clinton Avenue.

UPDATE: The location of tonight’s meeting has changed to Sacred Heart Church, 30 Clermont Avenue. It will still start at 6:30 p.m.

  • Morris Zapp

    This makes me SO ANGRY!!!

  • Guest

    Can someone print 100 copies of this story and enlarge the picture of Sumner place and mount it for display at tonight’s meeting in Fort Greene? Thanks.

  • da

    As is usually the case, the nominal objections (based on historic preservation, in this case) are probably just stand-ins for objections to loss of vehicle parking.

  • It’s interesting to note that the two stations that have been defaced in Fort Greene are located in the on-street parking lane. The stations on sidewalks haven’t been touched. Your theory is 100% correct.

  • J

    Meh. this isn’t a big deal. Councilmember James is a huge supporter of bikeshare. The meeting is simply a vent session to let people blow off some steam and hear from a bunch of bikeshare supporters how silly their arguments are.

    Also, I agree with everyone else, that the real issue here is parking.

  • Tacony Palmyra

    The people against having Citi’s name on the bikes should simply raise the $41 million Citi paid themselves.

  • Anxiously Awaiting Bikeshare

    There will always be people who hate change, no matter how good that change is. The key is to drown out their message with a message about how positive the change will be.

  • David in Brooklyn Heights

    Too bad local, neighborhood businesses can’t sponsor a single rack, like a ball team, with logos and everything. Bikes could end up in other neighborhoods, but that would be part of the fun.

  • Anonymous

    Even if one is not bothered by the Citibank branding, this article doesn’t include a rational point to support that position. The commentary essentially argues that because other advertisements exist in neighborhoods, more advertisements do not detract from aesthetic charm. By that reasoning, no amount of advertising would ever be a negative.

    Similarly, it is the author’s opinion – not an indisputable fact – that the neighborhood in the first photo looks just as good as it ever did with the corporate-sponsored bikes.

  • The real issue here is people are afraid of change and are just trying using arguments like ‘historic preservation’ as a way of expressing this fear. This always happens. Within a few weeks of it being operational, you won’t hear anything. In fact, you’ll probably hear the same people saying how nice it is to see cyclists strolling by

  • whopper

    how about people video caming the site to catch any vandals in action?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Prepping for July Bike-Share Launch, DOT Shows Prelim Station Sites to CB 3

|
After several months of public meetings and online feedback on bike-share station siting, NYC DOT is beginning to tour community boards with preliminary station maps in preparation for launching North America’s most expansive bike-share system this July. Yesterday evening, NYC DOT Policy Director Jon Orcutt walked the transportation and public safety committee of Manhattan Community […]

Other Cities’ Mayors on Bicycling

|
London Mayor Ken Livingstone:"Cycling is the fastest, cheapest, most healthy and environmentally friendly way to get around London, which is why we are investing almost £20 million this year to improve cycle facilities in the capital. The number of cyclists on our roads has doubled since 2000 and we’ve already exceeded our cycling targets five […]

Citi Bike Map Now Shows Over 100 New Stations Coming Soon

|
New York City’s bike-share expansion is almost here. Citi Bike has added more than 100 new stations to its system map in Brooklyn, Long Island City, and between 59th Street and 86th Street in Manhattan. While it’s difficult to assess station density with much detail from eyeballing the map, you can see that parts of the Upper West Side, […]