Ravitch: The Next Mayor Must Get Serious About Congestion Pricing

The next mayor will have to take the lead on transportation funding challenges that, while difficult to address in campaign speeches, are critical to the city’s future, former lieutenant governor and MTA chairman Richard Ravitch said today at a Fordham University infrastructure forum.

Richard Ravitch says the next mayor will have to get behind congestion pricing, whether it's an election topic or not. Image: ##http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Ravitch_crop.jpeg##Wikimedia##

Ravitch said that while raising fares to cover the MTA’s operating expenses is acceptable, using fare hikes to cover debt service for infrastructure investment — which is already happening — is highly problematic. “That’s when it begins to hurt,” he told Streetsblog after his afternoon panel wrapped up. There needs to be a new source of revenue for the MTA’s capital program, and congestion pricing is necessary, Ravitch added.

The next mayor will need to make congestion pricing a top-tier priority and work with Albany to make it happen, Ravitch said. (The other top priorities he mentioned are dealing with union contracts and retiree health care costs.) But Ravitch isn’t hopeful that a productive discussion will break out during the mayoral campaign.

“They probably won’t be talking about what they should be talking about,” he said. “It’s hard to get elected on a platform of increasing taxes. The next mayor’s going to have to do that.”

With shrinking federal support for transportation, the burden of investment will fall to the local tax base. “The planning commission has done a great job in rezoning large parts of the city, particularly in the outer boroughs,” Ravitch said, but he wants to drastically ramp up outer-borough growth to help generate revenue. “There is plenty of space; it’s a question of density and access,” he said.

But there’s one rezoning project that Ravitch remains skeptical of: East Midtown. “I’m personally not yet persuaded that that’s a good idea,” he said, saying that without major investment, the additional subway crowding and traffic congestion will be serious.

Although the city has proposed transit capacity improvements funded by new development, Ravitch is skeptical of geographically-targeted funding mechanisms, such as the 7 train extension, to address challenges that are regional in nature.

He is, however, bullish on the Tappan Zee Bridge’s chances to win a federal TIFIA loan. When Streetsblog asked how the multi-billion dollar loan will be repaid, given the Cuomo administration’s apparent lack of will to raise Thruway tolls, Ravitch said that TIFIA’s low interest rates are enough to keep repayment costs under control. “They’re going to solve the Tappan Zee Bridge problem,” he said.

  • Larry Littlefield

    Ravitch wants the next Mayor to take the state legislature off the hook for the next MTA capital plan.  Perhaps by loading sacrifices onto city residents while sending the benefits elsewhere.

    He would do better by honestly talking about the problem:  how it came about, who created it, and who benefitted.  Unless that conversation is had first, the tendency is for the beneficiaries of past deals to demand more, and more, and more.

  • JK

    Ravitch worked for Hugh Carey, the governor who saved the MTA from collapse. He darn well knows that the MTA is a state authority — it is not controlled by the mayor.  The MTA is the governor’s responsibility, not the mayor’s. The lesson of Bloomberg congestion pricing is that the governor should be the champion, not the mayor. The mayor has to bring home money from Albany for city run schools, city run social programs, city run hospitals. What mayor has the political capital to fight for funds for a state run transit authority when they have so many of their own programs to fund?

  • Larry Littlefield

    Moreover, the “transportation trust fund’ for roads was pillaged and encumbered by debt just like the MTA.  This was a statewide decision to rob the future by the generations in charge.  Cuomo needs to tell them that they’ve done enough damage, and if they are unwilling to stop they should take their winnings and move to Florida now.

  • Anonymous

    @77dd00db93265cc480eeb02d3429821a:disqus Given Governor Cuomo’s love for low, taxpayer-subsidized tolls (see Tappan Zee Bridge boondoggle) to keep suburban drivers happy, I doubt this happen in the near term.  But maybe Cuomo will be carried to the White House on the wings of the new bridge in 2016.

  • We manufacture minimum pressure valve,compressor valves, nbdlfd.com have advanced CNC processing machines and complete inspection equipments,to provide customers with quality products. llkjihygjhfg

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Will Richard Ravitch Resurrect Congestion Pricing?

|
Marc Shaw, former chair of the Traffic Congestion Mitigation Commission, caused something of a stir in the local press on Friday, when he predicted that congestion pricing would "rise again" as a proposal to toll East River bridges and a cordon across 60th street. Speaking at a panel discussion at the RPA’s Regional Assembly, Shaw […]

Joe Lhota: The MTA Needs New Tax Revenue

|
The MTA needs new revenues, announced chairman Joe Lhota during a broad-ranging panel discussion at Fordham University this morning. “There’s going to be the need for broad-based tax revenue somewhere within the system over the next couple of years,” Lhota said, noting that he’s generally the kind of conservative person loath to call for tax […]

What We Know So Far About Cuomo’s MTA Reinvention Commission

|
In early May, Governor Andrew Cuomo directed the MTA to create a “transportation reinvention” panel as the authority prepared its next five-year capital plan. Members were appointed late last month, and the commission has launched Facebook and Twitter accounts. But details about its agenda and how open it will be to the public are scant. […]

Ravitch: Big Business, Cuomo Have Failed to Lead on Transportation

|
New York’s infrastructure is dangerously underfunded and threatening to cripple the region’s economy, warned former lieutenant governor and MTA chairman Richard Ravitch in a speech on Thursday. Having taken the helm of the transit authority in 1979, at the system’s absolute nadir, Ravitch knows a thing or two about what it takes to bring the […]

Daily News to Congestion Pricing Opponents: “Your Fault”

|
With higher gas prices pushing drivers onto the city’s trains and buses, the Daily News today blasted Speaker Sheldon Silver and Assembly Dems for passing up the billions of dollars that congestion pricing would have brought to MTA coffers.  The trends prove that the theory of congestion pricing was valid: When the cost of driving […]

Ravitch Commission Faces Difficult Task of Shoring Up MTA’s Future

|
The panel headed by former MTA chief Richard Ravitch held its first public hearing yesterday at NYU’s Kimmel Center. Representatives of advocacy groups, local government, think tanks, trade associations, and unions gave the commission a variety of proposals, including but certainly not limited to road pricing, to help the MTA navigate its funding crisis. Streetsblog […]