Safety Fixes Near NYC Schools Reduced Kids’ Traffic Injuries By a Third

Traffic injuries to school-age kids are down by a third in areas of New York city that received safety improvements like crosswalks and curb extensions as part of DOT’s Safe Routes to School program, according to new research, while kids walking in areas without the enhancements did not see such pronounced safety gains.

The numbers are in: NYC's Safe Routes to School Program has led to dramatic gains in street safety near schools. Photo: ##http://www.flickr.com/photos/en321/3407732895/##Susan NYC/Flickr##

The study, conducted by Columbia University public health researchers and published in the journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics, provides solid empirical footing for continued expansion of pedestrian safety initiatives.

“The pedestrian injury rate is a major public health issue for children,” said Dr. Guohua Li, who co-authored the study. By focusing the bulk of its effort on fixing pedestrian safety hotspots, New York City’s SRTS program “has achieved something that other interventions tried but could not achieve for many, many decades,” he said. “I think that’s really remarkable.”

“The New York City Department of Transportation has somewhat of a unique arrangement,” explained Margo Pedroso, deputy director of the Safe Routes to School National Partnership. Because the state agreed to give the city more control over its SRTS program, she said, “they were really able to target focused on safety.”

Youth pedestrian injury rates are falling citywide, Li noted, but by drilling down to the times and places where students can benefit from SRTS interventions, the researchers were able to cut through the noise to see if the program has had an impact.

NYC DOT launched its SRTS program in 2004, influenced by Transportation Alternatives’ “The Bronx Safe Routes to School” initiative. By 2009, 30 schools had received SRTS interventions, such as new crosswalk markings, or capital projects like sidewalk extensions at intersections. Using crash data provided by the city, researchers compared before-and-after numbers from these 30 schools with areas that were not selected for SRTS.

The study found that while safety improvements around schools benefit everyone — pedestrian injuries near SRTS schools dropped 14 percent for those outside the school-aged demographic (5- to 19-year-olds) — the biggest beneficiaries were kids, especially during the busy hours when they go to school and depart, from 7 a.m. to 9 a.m. and from 2 p.m. to 4 p.m. during the school year. After interventions had been installed, the injury rate for school-aged pedestrians near participating schools dropped by a third, and by a staggering 44 percent during school commute hours. Meanwhile, youth pedestrian injuries during these hours outside of SRTS locations remained unchanged.

The authors wrote that “the SRTS program in New York City has contributed to a marked reduction in pedestrian injury in school-aged children.” If expanded to all of the city’s 1,471 schools, Safe Routes to School improvements could prevent 210 injuries each year, they concluded.

“It’s the one study that makes a direct link between Safe Routes to School improvements and child injuries,” Pedroso said, adding that this research will be useful in convincing state DOTs to fund their own SRTS programs.

“I wish I had this study a year ago,” Pedroso added. MAP-21, the federal transportation bill passed in June, made SRTS an optional funding category, replacing the previous practice of requiring states to dedicate funds to SRTS programs.

  • Anonymous

    Now that the Columbia team has scientifically proven what we all suspected — that the Safe Routes to School program saves children’s lives — NYC DOT simply must make it their number ONE priority.  Yes, I mean before another Citibench is installed, before another bike lane is striped, before another pedestrian plaza is mapped, before any of the many wonderful things they are doing for our city is implemented, they must place these SRTS street enhancements at every intersection near every school in the city.  

  • Danny G

    @jooltman:disqus Benches, bike lanes, and plazas are part of the Safe Routes to School (SRTS) Toolkit. Check the “mitigation measures” PDF on this page:http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/safety/saferoutes.shtmlSometimes a street closure that creates extra space for a plaza or a lane reduction that makes space for a bike lane is an important piece of SRTS improvements. Sometimes someone with a bad back or knee will walk their children to school on this new safe route, and a bench is a necessary amenity for them to be able to walk back home.I agree with you completely that saving lives should be a number one priority. Keep in mind that traffic engineers have used the “saving lives” argument to widen highways, remove crosswalks, or do whatever else they wanted to do. But the study has found that something about the NYC DOT SRTS program is working, and there should be more of it. I wouldn’t be surprised if you that those “wonderful things” – benches, plazas, and bike lanes – are already a part of SRTS.

  • Joe R.

    While we’re on this subject, how about prohibiting school buses and other large vehicles from parking in the spots nearest the crosswalks? At the local school by me (PS 200), a school bus ALWAYS parks overnight at the first spot near the crosswalk. As a result, I can’t even see what’s coming when I cross the street. It’s even worse because turning cars can’t see me. This is a highly dangerous situation which can be easily corrected.

  • Anonymous

    Danny G, I am all for these improvements, but I haven’t seen any near schools in my Brooklyn neighborhood. The SRTS has yet to be expanded to all 1,471 NYC schools.  That’s what I’m calling for, before any more street calming happens in other locations.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Safe Routes to Schools Study Complete

|
Walking to school is a healthy way for many kids to get their daily dose of exercise. Unfortunately many parents are rightfully concerned about their children’s safety on the city’s streets because of aggressive driver and lack of good pedestrian safety infrastructure. Everyday in front of many city schools you see parents dropping kids off in […]

Motorists Still Pose the Biggest Danger to NYC School Kids

|
With the new school year in session, an analysis of traffic injury numbers by WNYC shows that NYPD and DOT need to step up on enforcement and engineering improvements to prevent motorists from hurting kids. Year after year, traffic crashes rank as the leading cause of injury-related death for children in NYC. Drawing on state DMV data […]

House GOP Urges Elimination of (GOP-Backed) Kid Safety Program

|
House Republicans aren’t known for their well-reasoned spending proposals lately, but they took it to a new level today by sending President Obama a $375 billion budget-cutting plan that slices $1 billion from bicycle and pedestrian programs. One hopes that crossing guard in orange isn’t a House GOPer. (Photo: CA DOT) The cuts have next […]

Pedestrian Safety: London Shows How NYC Can Do Better

|
Saturday afternoon traffic congestion on a London street near Covent Garden with dimensions and land use almost identical to Prince Street in Manhattan. In the days before Wednesday’s hearing on pedestrian safety, the City Council should consider how badly New York City pedestrians fare compare to those in London. While pedestrian safety has been improving […]