With Hayley and Diego’s Law Unenforced, Sponsors Aim to Strengthen Law

Graph: Transportation Alternatives, based on data from New York State DMV

In 2010, State Senator Dan Squadron and Assembly Member Brian Kavanagh stood on the corner of Essex and Delancey Streets to tell motorists: “Careless driving is unacceptable.” Said Kavanagh, “You can suffer serious consequences.”

A year later, however, the new enforcement tool the two legislators were touting, Hayley and Diego’s Law, had gone almost entirely unenforced. Intended to offer law enforcement an intermediate option between simple moving violations and serious criminal charges, the law hasn’t proved as useful as hoped.

Now, Squadron and Kavanagh are back with an amendment to Hayley and Diego’s Law intended to help police and prosecutors put it to use.

“Hayley and Diego’s Law made it clear that a driver’s license is not a license for carelessness,” said Squadron. “But we now must provide law enforcement with additional tools to effectively crack down on careless driving.”

Based on conversations with district attorneys and police officers, the law’s sponsors and Transportation Alternatives found a police protocol they believe to be a key obstacle to bringing charges of careless driving. “Unless a cop witnesses a violation, they cannot write the ticket,” said T.A. general counsel Juan Martinez.

Squadron and Kavanagh’s new law would make it explicit that police can make arrests under Hayley and Diego’s Law without having directly witnessed a violation, assuming officers have reasonable cause to make the arrest.

Said Kavanagh, “Now with the benefit of our experience of how the law is working in the field, we’ve worked with law enforcement and safety advocates and identified a way to make it far more effective at holding careless drivers accountable for their dangerous behavior and making our streets safer.”

The current problem, said Martinez, is the intermediate status of Hayley and Diego’s Law. Though it’s intended to be more serious than a traffic violation, legally it’s lumped in with other moving violations, which is how police have treated it so far. “Nobody wants the police to be out there writing tickets for ordinary traffic violations they didn’t see,” said Martinez, citing red-light running as an example.

Hayley and Diego’s Law only applies to crashes that injure a pedestrian or cyclist, not careless driving in general. “There are often several witnesses who want to say, ‘This is what I saw happen,'” said Martinez. “It’s a different kind of violation.”

  • HamTech87

    Can anyone say whether this bill is being enforced outside of NYC?

  • SauronHimself

    It wasn’t enforced for me. I was hit by a drunk driver on 16JULY2013 while bicycling, and I was seriously injured. The driver was never prosecuted under this
    law. He just got his second DWI conviction in two years.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Kavanagh and Squadron Usher Hayley and Diego’s Law Into Effect

|
“Careless driving is unacceptable.” That’s the message that State Senator Daniel Squadron and Assembly Member Brian Kavanagh delivered today as they announced that Hayley and Diego’s Law, which they sponsored and ushered through the legislature, is now in effect. “You can suffer serious consequences,” Kavanagh warned drivers. “That has not been true up to today.” […]

Careless Driving Amendment Passes Senate, Awaits Action by Assembly

|
A bill targeted at NYPD’s self-imposed ban on penalizing motorists for careless driving has cleared the State Senate, but awaits passage in the Assembly. The bill would amend Hayley and Diego’s Law by explicitly stating that officers may ticket or arrest drivers who harm pedestrians, cyclists and other vulnerable street users whether or not they […]

De Blasio Wants Albany to Make Careless Driving a Crime [Updated]

|
As part of his Vision Zero agenda, Mayor Bill de Blasio wants Albany to elevate careless driving to a criminal offense, increasing penalties while making it easier for police to hold reckless motorists accountable. Enacted in 2010, Hayley and Diego’s Law was intended as a default infraction for crashes that injure pedestrians and cyclists. But under Ray […]

Senate Committee Votes to Close Loophole in Careless Driving Law

|
Just hours after the City Council transportation committee unanimously passed a resolution asking Albany to take action, the Senate transportation committee advanced a bill, with an 18-1 vote, that would close a loophole in Hayley and Diego’s Law, with the goal of increased enforcement of the state’s careless driving law by police and district attorneys. The law is named after […]