After the Service Cuts: Riders Cram on to Overburdened, Unreliable B61

Bus riders waited at least 15 minutes for this crowded B61 during the morning rush today. A practically empty B61 was bunched up right behind it. Photo: Ben Fried

Toward the end of a press conference at the corner of Fourth Avenue and 9th Street this morning, Council Member Brad Lander remarked that not a single B61 bus came by during the 15-minute event. This was only fitting, since Lander was unveiling a new report from his office that found most rush hour B61 buses don’t arrive within the guidelines established by the MTA.

During rush hours, the B61 is supposed to arrive every eight to ten minutes, but the service is anything but reliable, according to the report, “Next Bus Please.” Fully 57 percent of buses are either spaced at least three minutes farther apart than they’re supposed to be, or bunched at least three minutes tighter together. For straphangers this translates into long waits, crowded buses, and the frustration of watching an empty B61 pull up right as you’re boarding that jam-packed bus.

“It gets really packed every morning,” said Vian Hernandez, a senior at South Brooklyn Community High School in Red Hook, who transfers from the train to the B61 to get to school. “Sometimes it comes really late.”

The current B61 route is the byproduct of the 2010 MTA service cuts (themselves a byproduct of Albany budget raids, the mounting cost of MTA debt service, and the collapse of the real estate market). The line was extended east from Red Hook to Park Slope and Windsor Terrace, absorbing passengers who used to take the now-defunct B75 and B77. The nearby B37 and B71, which served parallel routes, were also eliminated, and the Smith-9th Street subway stop has been closed for maintenance since June, further increasing reliance on the B61.

A year and a half after the cuts took effect, the study from Lander, Congresswoman Nydia Velazquez, and City Council Member Sara Gonzalez documents the strain on the riders who depend on this line, which is now the only bus or subway route that directly serves Red Hook.

Service seems to be deteriorating. A November, 2010 New York City Transit study of the B61 found that 36 percent of buses were arriving outside the MTA’s service guidelines. While NYCT was looking at all buses, not just rush hour service, the authors of “Next Bus Please” say their measurements — 57 percent of rush hour buses failing to meet the guidelines — indicate things have gotten worse on the B61 since then.

They outline a package of improvements for the bus line, including additional peak-hour service, limited stop service for the most popular stops, real-time arrival info, and better contingency routes in the event that a ship passes through the Gowanus Canal at the 9th Street Bridge, a drawbridge that can delay B61s for up to 15 minutes.

Some of those recommendations should come at little or no cost to the financially strapped MTA. (One recommendation, for instance, calls for merging bus stops that are too close together, which could actually cut the cost of operating the B61.) While adding peak hour service won’t be free, the MTA has restored service on several lines since the 2010 cuts in response to rider demand and political pressure. “Next Bus Please” is, I believe, the most rigorous and thorough attempt to document why additional service would benefit a specific bus line.

Velazquez said that Red Hook’s dependence on the B61 justifies the increased service. “The MTA has to prioritize needs,” she said. “Red Hook suffers from a lack of transportation options.”

The authors have shown the report to the MTA and are awaiting a response.

  • Larry Littlefield

    That’s the bad news.

    The good news is that there was a drastic reduction in the effective fare from 1995 to 2002, not only in inflation-adjusted dollars but also in nominal dollars.  

    At the same time the several pension enhancements were passed, spending on other things increased at lower tax levels because money was diverted from the MTA, and lots of contractors got higher prices on the MTA capital plan.

    Of course all that is over, except the pension deals which are immortal.  But to be fair and balanced mentioned the good news along with the bad news.  Since all those making those deals and decisions got re-elected multiple times, often unopposed, this must be what people wanted.  Or at least what people who matter wanted.

  • carma

    that reminds me of the q58 here in queens.  Im very shocked straphangers didnt find bunching on the 58, even though it ALWAYS wins the pokey award.

  • Cotb16

    Carma, at least the Q58 runs frequently, running every 5-6 minutes during the rush (combining limited and local service). The B61 runs less frequently, but still manages to bunch.

  • carma

    i feel with the introduction of the limited on the 58, service has gone down more and actually created more bunching problems.

    on paper, it runs 5-6 minute headways, but i can tell you that its not surprising to find 15-20 minute service gaps.  it doesnt help when the next bus flies past you saying “NEXT BUS PLEASE”

    i would love for the bikeshare to come to parts of queens where buses run, so folks can take it on their own 2 wheels instead of not knowing when the next bus will come.

  • Larry Littlefield

    Basically, the message is ride a bike if you can’t afford a car or find a place to park it.  On a bike you can cover the entire distance of the B61 in short order, with no wait.

    BTW, I took the subway to work today instead of the bike. I was crush loaded from Prospect Park Station on the F on.  I jumped down to the BMT at 4th Avenue, and ended up crush loaded on the D.  This is the future.

  • carma

    larry,  for me a car is affordable.  in fact i own 2 cars.  but i still choose to bike and do the mass transit thing.  sometimes, its just easier than to drive in traffic and then you end up wasting more time b/c you cant find parking.

    and with a bike, it is ALWAYS faster than any bus route.  at least for me it is.

  • fj

    these public streets and vehicles that run on them are manmade.  kind of bizarre that they are not designed to be safe and to allow safe, practical, low-cost transportation.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Local Electeds Announce Specific MTA Service Restorations

|
Local pols are sending out word about MTA service restorations in their districts. Yesterday Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver got the jump on announcing a restored bus route — letting slip that the M9 will be extended back to Battery Park City. The MTA will be announcing the full slate of service changes later this afternoon. All […]

Riders Want Faster Buses Across Q’Boro. Are Bus Lanes Coming?

|
NYC DOT is studying how to speed buses across the car-clogged Queensboro Bridge, and data the agency collected over the summer [PDF] show just how great the need is. Buses are crawling and riders are fed up. Relieving the bottleneck for riders could make transit a far more attractive option for Queens residents. One potential […]