Mugging for TV, James Vacca Turns Transpo Committee Into Kangaroo Court

If City Council Transportation Committee Chair James Vacca wanted media attention for "getting tough" on DOT, he got it. Image: ##http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2011/05/04/city-councilman-baghdads-roads-better-than-nycs/##CBS 2##

When James Vacca called a hearing of the City Council transportation committee to discuss the DOT plaza program yesterday, what was he trying to get out of it?

For many neighborhoods, the plaza program offers the best and only chance of expanding their limited supply of public space, and most of the council members who showed up used the opportunity to clarify a few points about how to get a plaza for their neighborhoods. (We’ll have more on that in a follow-up post.)

Vacca struck a much more theatrical tone than his colleagues. He tiptoed around attacking DOT directly, preferring insinuations and gotcha questions instead. It was the performance of someone looking to score points in the tabloid media — knowing full well his inquisition had no merit.

In one line of questioning, for instance, Vacca grilled DOT over the cost of making the Times Square plazas permanent. DOT Assistant Commissioner Andy Wiley-Schwartz explained that Times Square had been set for a full-scale reconstruction for years, well before any plans to pedestrianize Broadway had been introduced. The funding for the plan was the same, he said, only the design of the reconstruction changed.

Vacca put on his best prosecutorial demeanor. “So what will it cost?”

Wiley-Schwartz again explained that the price tag was for a much larger project than the plazas, reconstructing the street from sidewalk to sidewalk on both Broadway and Seventh Avenue, but that the total will be $20 million. The pedestrian plazas barely added to the cost. “Basically, instead of putting asphalt there, you’re putting concrete there,” he explained.

Vacca seized on the $20 million and feigned ignorance, pretending that the plaza would cost $20 million itself. “It’s going to be a very expensive pedestrian plaza at the end of the day.”

But Vacca isn’t dumb. After one more back-and-forth, Vacca made clear that he understood that the plaza wasn’t a significant cost item and moved on. He “got tough” with DOT for the benefit of the tabloids and the TV cameras, but then corrected course, presumably to avoid embarrassing himself further in front of the people in the room.

Vacca’s loaded questions presented DOT with several “damned if you do, damned if you don’t” moments. After asking whether the Midtown plazas were an attempt to keep people from driving into Manhattan, Vacca followed up by asking whether traffic volumes in the area had gone down. If the answer had been yes, it would no doubt have been taken as proof positive that the plaza program is really a plot to make life more difficult for car owners.

According to DOT, though, total traffic was the same. At Times Square, it just flowed more smoothly down Seventh Avenue instead of Broadway. That set Vacca off on a string of accusatory questions implying that the increased traffic on Seventh was destroying that street. “That concerns me from an access point of view, from a traffic movement point of view, and certainly from a pedestrian safety point of view as well.”

Just to be clear, neither safety risks, congestion, nor air pollution shifted from Broadway to other avenues. Pedestrian injuries fell by 35 percent in the entire study area for the Green Light for Midtown project, which included not just Broadway but also Seventh near Times Square and Sixth near Herald Square. And while air pollution plummeted in Times Square after the creation of the plazas, according to recent environmental data, it didn’t rise in the rest of Midtown.

Vacca played the same game when asking whether DOT planned to bring plazas to every community district. It was a no-win: Either DOT would be favoring certain parts of the city or foisting plazas on potentially unwilling communities. (For the record, the plaza program is entirely opt-in — a paragon of community engagement — and Wiley-Schwartz nailed the answer, saying that the goal is for every community to eventually request one.)

While the mainstream press coverage today is mainly about a “contentious hearing,” the only council member who really blasted the plazas was Eric Ulrich. Unlike Vacca, Ulrich hewed to his conviction: that making any more room for pedestrians and public life is a waste of money. That’s a foolish position, but at least a coherent one. Vacca never took such a stand — he never had to. By using his committee chairmanship to lob innuendo and false assumptions at DOT, he did far more to impede the continued improvement of NYC streets than Ulrich.

  • Council-boy Vacca is such a tool.

    I wish he would take a permanent vaccation.

  • Shemp

    The guy definitely reached his natural level when he was on his local community board.

  • Shemp

    The guy definitely reached his natural level when he was on his local community board.

  • I’d like to remind everyone that none of us got a chance to vote for Vacca as Transportation Chair. He was appointed by Speaker Quinn in order to consolidate her power. There was not even any discussion in the Council about it; I asked my council member (a confidante of Quinn’s) if he could recommend someone and his staff basically told me it was a done deal.

    Looks like we’re stuck with this joker for three more years. Maybe in 2013 we can vote for a Council that will select its committee members through a more open process. In the meantime, you might want to write to Quinn or your local councilmember and complain. Maybe if enough of us do, they’ll get him to focus on real transportation problems.

  • Also, Andy Wiley-Schwartz is married to your colleague Kim Wiley-Schwartz, right? Probably a good idea to mention that for full disclosure.

  • Mark Walker

    He’s so pretty, oh so pretty … Vaccant.

  • vet

    Ulrich is a twit. Maybe some of the military guys and gals his age who spent actually some time on Baghdad streets would have a different view as to how our streets compare.

  • Guest

    Jimmy is smarter than this, I’m not sure what point he was trying to make that actually serves the city in the long run.

  • If a Republican like Latourette can be turned around with a constituent blitz, then Vacca may be worth a try. How about everyone printing out the Weekly Carnage and sending it to him by snail mail every week?

  • fdr

    None of us voted for Quinn as Speaker either. That’s the way the Council works.

  • Charles_Siegel

    They need to be able to give him a cost for just the pedestrian plaza. Eg, maybe:

    The earlier plan for reconstruction without a pedestrian plaza cost $20 million.
    The current plan with a pedestrian plaza costs $20.1 million
    Therefore, the pedestrian plaza costs $100,000

    They are just playing into his hands by giving him the cost estimate of $20 million for the entire project.

  • Not many of us are Vacca’s constituents. He was elected by the people of the southeastern Bronx, and appointed as Transportation Chair by Christine Quinn. If you want to complain about him, the best person to do it to is your own City Council rep. The only reason he’ll listen to people from outside his district is if he’s planning on running for something else after he’s term-limited out in 2013.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Introducing “Vacca Watch”

|
When Streetsblog interviewed City Council Transportation Committee Chair James Vacca a year ago, he was fresh off a press appearance with AARP calling for complete streets legislation in Albany. The Ninth Avenue protected bike lane was the backdrop. During our conversation a few weeks later he came across as someone who took street safety seriously […]

Vacca Looks to Squeeze $ From Bikes, But Won’t Touch the Price of Parking

|
The headline from today’s City Council transportation committee oversight hearing was Janette Sadik-Khan’s announcement that the official launch date for Citi Bike is Memorial Day. Meanwhile, for Transportation Committee Chair James Vacca, it was another occasion to flail at bikes and defend cheap parking under the guise of holding a budget hearing. Sadik-Khan kicked off the hearing […]

Vacca Watch: At Budget Hearing, Council Calms Down, Focuses on Potholes

|
Call it the case of the missing demagoguery. Yesterday’s City Council transportation budget hearing was less notable for what was said than what wasn’t. Attacks on the city’s proposed parking meter rate increase were largely absent, and the scapegoating of bike lanes and pedestrian plazas that has dominated recent hearings in James Vacca’s committee failed […]

Eric Ulrich’s Cure for BQE Potholes: Stop Building Public Plazas

|
Transportation Committee Chair James Vacca convened a hearing this afternoon on NYC DOT’s plaza program, a sequel of sorts to the bike policy hearing where opponents of the Prospect Park West bike lane got a big media moment and several council members laid out their windshield perspective on bike lanes for all to see. Today, […]