City Offers Tax Exemptions For Politically Connected Parking Operator

The well-connected Jamaica First Parking garage earned a slew of tax exemptions, ostensibly for reducing traffic congestion. Image: Google Street View.
The well-connected Jamaica First Parking garage earned a slew of tax exemptions, ostensibly for reducing traffic congestion. Image: ##http://maps.google.com/maps?q=162nd+street+and+jamaica+ave&ie=UTF8&hq=&hnear=Jamaica+Ave+%26+162nd+St,+Queens,+New+York&gl=us&ei=tiT5TOKkEsmr8AbFxrWWCQ&oi=geocode_result&ved=0CBgQ8gEwAA&ll=40.705774,-73.798599&spn=0.007645,0.018775&z=16&layer=c&cbll=40.705699,-73.798543&panoid=B7CsJkiqHMzemcZ3-cr_Lw&cbp=12,53.38,,0,-1.79##Google Street View.##

Raking in millions by inducing more traffic on Jamaica’s congested streets? It’s charity, says New York City, and the business that does it should not pay taxes.

A local non-profit with politically powerful friends managed to get its off-street parking garages classified as tax-exempt, despite being used exclusively for commercial purposes. The Daily News’ Juan Gonzalez has the scoop about the shady set-up:

The firm, Jamaica First Parking LLC, got the unusual exemption for its 2,000-space parking system from the city’s Finance Department in 2007.

The garage company is a subsidiary of Greater Jamaica Development Corp., a nonprofit tied to several major Queens political figures, including the Rev. Floyd Flake, a former congressman and ally of Mayor Bloomberg, and Rep. Gregory Meeks.

Gonzalez goes on to detail the many pieces of the city’s machinery that work together to subsidize both the car owners who use the garage and the political interests of local elected officials.

There’s the Finance Department, which over the objections of rank-and-file tax assessors granted property tax exemptions for the garages. There’s the Economic Development Corporation, which gave the garages $13 million in tax-exempt bonds.

And then there are the politicians. Gonzalez lists Congressman Meeks and his powerful predecessor, Reverend Flake, but they’re not alone in supporting these tax-free garages. The project also received the support of Council Members Leroy Comrie and James Gennaro and their former colleagues Archie Spigner, Thomas White, and David Weprin.

From a transportation perspective, another scandal is the big lie that makes this possible: that building parking actually reduces traffic congestion. That’s the excuse that the Greater Jamaica Development Corporation’s spokesperson gave to explain why parking garages serve a public purpose and therefore deserve tax-exempt status.

It’s also the assumption written into the state’s environmental review law, which presumes that a given number of people will always drive, and that getting them into a parking space faster will actually reduce traffic. In this world, the same number of people will drive no matter how many parking spaces exist.

Of course, in reality parking has a huge effect on the decision to own a car and to drive. That’s common sense — if you can’t park a car somewhere, you can’t drive there — and it’s also been backed up by rigorous research. For example, one study found that guaranteed personal parking in Jackson Heights led residents there to drive far more than residents of Park Slope, even though Park Slope households have higher incomes and higher rates of car ownership.

The sweetheart deal for this Jamaica parking garage is further evidence that City Hall has failed to convey the message that building and subsidizing parking leads to driving and goes against the sustainability goals of PlaNYC. Parking policy may play a bigger role in PlaNYC 2.0, hopefully including strong policies that bring EDC and the Finance Department into line. It could go a long way just by stating that the city no longer believes that parking garages reduce traffic congestion.

  • fdr

    This is more than a matter of bringing EDC and the Finance Department into line. As your headline and most of the article point out, it’s the political connection that matters. No one in City Hall is going to tell Floyd Flake he can’t get a tax exemption because of PlaNYC.

  • sharon

    Off street parking does reduce traffic congestion as it prevents people from circling looking for a spot. No everyone wants to be crammed into a bus, wait on freezing cold corners and suffer through multiple transfers. People have the right to drive and the developer should pay the same taxes as everyone else does

  • Sharon, I’m looking over the constitution and it mentions nothing about driving being a right.

  • Ian Turner

    Sharon, off-street parking is more expensive than on-street parking, so it does little to discourage cruising. What it does do is attract more vehicles to an area overall, thus increasing congestion.

  • josh

    Jass,

    it doesn’t mention anything about bicycle riding being a right in the constitution either. While it might increase traffic in the area, it actually encourages commuters to stop at Jamaica rather than commuting further into the city at higher cost and congestion to the urban core. It is also safer for car owners who don’t wish to park on the street in a high car-theft area.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

State’s Top Court: Low-Cost Parking Is Not a Tax-Free Charity

|
The owner of five Queens cut-rate parking facilities will have to pay property taxes, the state’s top court has ruled. The New York State Court of Appeals upheld the city’s decision to take back a tax exemption it had previously granted the politically-connected non-profit that operates 2,000 parking spaces in downtown Jamaica. Over the course of a decade starting in 1996, Jamaica […]

NYC’s Top Parking Subsidizer, Seth Pinsky, Moves On

|
Seth Pinsky, whose legacy as head of the New York City Economic Development Corporation will be years of parking-induced traffic in city neighborhoods, with taxpayers footing the bill, is headed to the private sector. The news came this morning, via announcements from City Hall and RXR Realty, which hired Pinsky. During Pinsky’s five-year tenure, NYCEDC incentivized […]

Why the Next Mayor Should Reform the Parking-Obsessed NYC EDC

|
For an investigation published this weekend, the New York Times calculated that governments in New York state give away at least $4.06 billion in corporate subsidies every year. In New York City, the agency that oversees much of this largesse is the Economic Development Corporation. And when it comes to shaping city fabric, NYC EDC has a […]

Congestion Commission Recommendation: First Look

|
Streetsblog has gotten hold of the Traffic Congestion Mitigation Commission recommendation, which should be voted on this hour. According to the version we have (pdf), the commission’s alternative to Mayor Bloomberg’s plan is expected to exceed the 6.3% VMT reduction required by the federal government, and raise an estimated $491 million per year for mass […]

Congestion Pricing Plan Includes a “Livable Streets Lock Box”

|
There is a nice surprise for City Council, neighborhood groups and transportation reformers in the congestion pricing plan approved by the Traffic Mitigation Commission yesterday. On page 8 of the plan, in a section called "Securing of parking revenues," the commission proposes dedicating all revenue raised within the congestion pricing zone from additional parking meter […]