Political Deal Results in Bad Pedicab Regulations

More on tomorrow’s rally and press conference on the city’s proposed pedicab regulations: Chad Marlow of the Public Advocacy Group, the pedicab industry’s lobbyist, sends along this press release arguing that Mayor Michael Bloomberg and Speaker Christine Quinn’s proposal to put a cap on the number of pedicabs and ban electric-assist technology harms the industry and compromises safety while, really, helping no one in particular. We don’t like publishing press releases verbatim, but this one is really pretty good reading. You get the sense that these new pedicab regs were designed with the same level of sensitivity and awareness as the city’s new school bus system. Here’s what the pedicab industry has to say:

New York, New York – February 13, 2007: In an event organized by the New York City Pedicab Owners Association (NYCPOA), concerned pedicab owners, drivers and their supporters will meet on the steps of City Hall at noon to lift the veil off ongoing negotiations to reconcile the Mayor’s and City Council’s pedicab regulation bills. In particular, the noontime event will highlight how two imprudent "political deals" will needlessly stagnate the environmentally friendly pedicab industry, prevent pedicabs from utilizing the best available safety equipment and exclude the industry’s most experienced drivers.


The first "political deal" involves severely restricting the number of pedicabs in operation – a decision whose genesis lies with theater and hotel complaints that groups of pedicabs were blocking traffic in front of their businesses. According to George Bliss, NYCPOA’s President, "the pedicab industry wants to be a welcome member of the midtown business community. As such, the theaters’ and hotels’ concerns became our concerns and we sought to address them through the Council legislation."

But despite proposing numerous solutions, none were accepted. As NYCPOA’s lobbyist Chad Marlow of The Public Advocacy Group LLC explained, "first we sought the solution the theaters, hotels and pedicabs all wanted: creating a series of stands where pedicabs could unobtrusively wait for their customers, but that solution was flatly rejected by the DOT. We then proposed a ‘Rule of Five’ that would have prohibited more than five pedicabs from grouping together while seeking passengers. The Community Board covering the Times Square-Theater District favored that proposal, but the Speaker’s office turned it down. We even begrudgingly offered to limit the number of pedicabs in a Times Square zone, but the Mayor said no. We’ve had no problem coming up with on-target solutions, we just cannot find anyone willing to enact them."

Instead, the Mayor and Speaker are preparing to place a cap on the number of pedicabs. The number being considered, which is in the low 300s, would take 40% of all currently operating pedicabs off the streets. This would stagnate the pedicab industry, drive numerous owners and drivers out of work and create an artificial shortage of pedicabs that cannot meet demand, all while failing to address the theaters’ and hotels’ concerns.

The second "political deal" reached between the Mayor and Speaker would, without any reasonable justification, ban all pedal-assisted, electric-assist pedicabs. The pedal-assisted, electric-assist power sought by the NYCPOA among others has two elements. First, pedicabs would be allowed to supplement their human power with no more than 750 watts of electric power, which is half the power an average electric lawn mower uses. Second, to ensure electric-assist pedicabs are always operated as bicycles, sensors would prevent electric-assist power from being used unless the pedicab is also being pedaled.

Electric-assist is important because it improves safety. As Amir Chizic, owner of BicyTaxi NYC, explained, "right now my pedicabs operate with a 250 watt motor, which allows me to place a heavy fiberglass shell on them to provide additional protection for my passengers. If the City bans electric-assist, I will just remove the motors and take off the safety shells, but is that what the City wants?" Allowing electric-assist also enables older, more experienced pedicab drivers to remain in the profession. Doug Korman, 53, who has driven a pedicab for 10 years commented that "at my age, after 6 or more hours of driving, when I am pedaling 600-plus pounds of pedicab and passengers up a hill, yes, I need a tiny bit of extra help, and that’s all electric-assist provides. If the City was taking a safety-first approach to pedicab legislation, it would be doing everything it could to keep drivers like me on the road because experienced pedicab drivers are the safest pedicab drivers."

As Bliss summarized, "this City needs more than just a pedicab regulation bill. It needs a good one, and that is not what is on the table right now."


 

  • Bikes, not cars

    Very well written Press Release. It shows that when people who try to work within the system get shut out, good ideas and logic seems to be shut out as well.

    I highly recommend that folks contact your council member. Start with an email and then follow-up with a real live phone call. Ask for the person on the Councilmember’s staff who works on transportation issues or environmental issues.

    If you don’t have their information close at hand, you can find it here:

    http://www.nyccouncil.info/constituent/index.cfm

  • ABG

    The main problem with the electric assist seems to be truth in advertising. I think most people think of pedicabs as entirely human-powered, and that’s part of what they’re paying for. All electric-assist pedicabs should have a notice that prospective customers can see before buying a ride. If they already do, then electric-assist should be legal.

    It still seems lame, though. If the pedicabs require a heavy fiberglass shell to be safe, and that shell can’t be pulled under full human power, then they’re not really viable on the streets of New York.

  • Nice post and great press release. We operate a pedicab business in Denver and train new pedicab operators across North America. We’re all watching what’s going on in NYC. Fortunately, Denver has had regulations in place for years and have the support of the downtown business community when issues arise.
    Tez in Denver
    pedicabblog.blogspot.com

  • I own and operate a pedalcab in Orlando, FL. After the four-day, 130,000-attendee Builders’ Show at our huge Convention Center, I’m more interested in electric assist now (I’m 56 -and sore!)

  • Harry Franootie

    Pedicabs are out of control, especially in midtown. I don’t know about the ones in front of the theaters, but they block sidewalks and go the wrong way on one-way streets. The owners may be trying to be responsible, but the drivers are not. They can whine about political deals, but they need to be brought under control.

  • bob

    Harry,

    And capping their numbers will do this how?

    What do you mean by “control”? How would you accomplish this? Pedicab drivers are asking for regulation, just not mindless regulation in order to quash competition.

    Think about how reckless taxi drivers are? Where’s your outrage towards them?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Pedicabs Protest New Regulations

|
Pedicabs took to the streets yesterday to protest the City’s new regulations on New York’s greenest for-hire transportation industry. In a press release, The Green Transport Association says that City Council Speaker Christine Quinn "dealt pedicabs a crushing blow capping our number at 325 city-wide" — a reported 35 percent reduction in the pedicab workforce: Pedicabs are […]

Pedicab Law Put on Hold

|
Attorneys representing the pedicab industry have succeeded in getting a temporary reprieve from restrictions adopted by the City Council earlier this year, including a cap on the allowed number of operators and a ban on electrically-assisted rigs, until their lawsuit against the city can be heard in court. From a September 19 Public Advocacy Group […]

Mass Pedicab Ride on City Hall

|
Fair Regulation, Not Strangulation No Cap, No Bans on Pedicab Industry 100 plus Pedicabs will ride en masse from Columbus Circle down Broadway to City Hall starting at noon. Media are invited to "embed" as pedicab passengers at any point during the ride. 2 p.m. press conference on City Hall steps will target City Council […]

Do Pedicabs Belong in Bike Lanes?

|
A pedicab (sort of) makes use of the Broadway bike lane. Photo: Brad Aaron Last week’s collision between a pedicab and a yellow taxi in Brooklyn was followed by a renewed, or at least better publicized, interest from Mayor Bloomberg and the City Council in enforcing long-awaited pedicab industry standards. The rules, initiated by pedicab […]

Cyclists Ride with Pedicabs to Rally at City Hall

|
The City Council Consumer Affairs Committee is set to vote on regulations that would put a very low cap on the total number of pedicabs in the City and ban certain types of pedicabs from City streets. Time’s Up! joins the Pedicab Owners’ Association against these unreasonable regulations to say: NO CAPS! NO BANS! SAVE THE […]

Pedicab Ride, Rally and Press Conference in Opposition to Proposed City Council Regulations Limiting Non-Polluting Transportation

|
The City Council Consumer Affairs Committee is set to vote on regulations that would put a very low cap on the total number of pedicabs in the City and ban certain types of pedicabs from City streets. Time’s Up! joins the Pedicab Owner’s Association against these unreasonable regulations to say: NO CAPS – NO BANS […]