Stringer: Blocked Bus Lanes Are Stifling Select Bus Service

NYC's bus lane network is growing - and on track to grow faster under the MTA's bus action plan - but the city isn't keeping bus lanes clear of cars, according to the comptroller's office.

What's wrong with this picture? THERE'S A TRUCK IN THE BUS LANE! Photo: TransitCenter
What's wrong with this picture? THERE'S A TRUCK IN THE BUS LANE! Photo: TransitCenter

Ten years ago, the MTA and NYC DOT debuted New York’s first “Select Bus Service” route on the Bx12 in the Bronx. At the time, it was a breakthrough, the first route in the city with off-board fare collection and terra cotta transit lanes. Trips on the Bx12, one of the busiest routes in the city, immediately got faster, and more people started riding.

The “bus action plan” released by the MTA on Monday promises to expand those types of upgrades citywide. But to deliver for riders, City Hall and Albany will have to solve a problem that has vexed SBS routes for a decade: blocked bus lanes.

Despite success improving bus speeds, Select Bus Service has failed to increase bus ridership, according to a new report from Comptroller Scott Stringer [PDF]. And one of the main reasons is that bus lanes are not doing what they are supposed to do. They are constantly obstructed by parked vehicles, negating the benefits for bus riders.

Currently, bus lanes are enforced with cameras at 94 fixed locations along 10 routes. Those cameras aren’t enough. They don’t cover the whole length of bus lanes, and they’re undermined by the city’s own lax attitude to maintaining the integrity of transit priority on the street.

Image: NYC Comptroller's Office
Table: NYC Comptroller’s Office

Repeat bus lane and bus stop offenders account for 28 percent of all violations. Unsurprisingly, commercial vehicles are the most likely to be cited for multiple violations. The city’s stipulated fine program, which essentially allows companies to receive bulk discounts on traffic fines, reduces incentives to adhere to bus lane rules.

Riders still appreciate Select Bus Service. People surveyed by Stringer’s office give the program high marks, with 64 percent of riders rating SBS with an “A” or “B.” Only 27 percent gave subway service such high marks. While SBS is performing better than the bus network as a whole, the overall results are underwhelming.

According to MTA data compiled by Stringer’s office, on the nine SBS routes introduced through 2015, 2016 ridership was down .2 percent compared the year before each route was implemented. That’s markedly better than the 5 percent drop in total bus ridership between 2013 and 2016, but the bar for bus improvements should be higher than just stopping the bleeding.

Image: NYC Comptroller's Office
Table: NYC Comptroller’s Office

Moving forward, Stringer recommends physical barriers for some bus lane segments and enforcement cameras mounted on every bus. The latter recommendation was one of the top-line strategies in the MTA’s bus action plan, and will require authorization from the state legislature.

The comptroller’s report also called on the city and MTA to hasten the implementation of transit signal priority for buses. NYC DOT is only planning to add signal priority on five bus routes per year through 2020, but the MTA’s bus fleet is capable of interfacing with traffic signals on many more routes.

The MTA also needs to do a better job adhering to its own stop spacing guidelines, the report says. While the agency aims to have SBS stops half a mile apart, on five of the nine routes listed above, stops are less than 1,000 feet apart.

“Select Bus Service was a first step toward modernizing the city’s bus system. But the City and the MTA are failing those who depend on its service,” Stringer said in a statement. “If we’re going to build a real and rapid bus transit system in New York City, we need to do it right. No more half measures and cutting corners.”

  • The only real solution here, as with blocked bicycle lanes, is enforcement. Unfortunately, this requires cooperation on the part of the police, which is not forthcoming.

    If the police gave appropriate enforcement priority to this and other forms of driver misconduct, the quality of life of all street users would improve dramatically.

  • Greg Costikyan

    Actually, enforcement by cameras mounted on buses work tolerably well in other cities, such as San Francisco.

  • Vooch

    I’ll argue Engineering – ie Bollards is decent solution.

    Camera enforcement doesn’t work for the Marty Golden’s & Dorothy Bruns.

  • Joe R.

    Bollards and/or jersey barriers are the only real solution here. In the event a driver is bold enough to enter a bus lane at an intersection (the only place where they could enter if there were bollards/jersey barriers) buses should be allowed to physically push them out of the way. In fact, they should be allowed to do this now. The message should be if you block a bus lane, you risk having your car destroyed.

  • I am sure that that would work. But even that would require the police to buy into it.

    I don’t know whether other cities face this problem, but New York’s police force actually believes that it’s their role to set policy. Consequently, they simply won’t take direction from the mayor on policy matters. I have frequently likened the police department’s mindset to that of a military junta which considers the elected government to be irrelevant.

  • AnoNYC

    Madison and 5th Ave in Midtown are great places for physical separation (double bus lane) with split turning phases for other drivers to avoid buses getting cut off (and collisions). Bus lanes would be a defacto adjacent street.

  • AnoNYC

    A lot of drivers here unfortunately realize certain stretches are not camera enforced. Additionally, the commercial drivers just rack up the tickets with impunity.

    Should be multiple tickets for every minute you are in the bus lane.

  • Boeings+Bikes

    Next: when Mayor Stringer’s NYPD shrugs at the problem, will his DOT commish install hard barriers to keep illegal parkers (typically NYPD vehicles) out?

  • Andrew

    Install front-facing cameras on all buses.

    Then assess fines in all bus lanes and at all bus stops based on the number of passengers delayed – specifically, the number on board the bus plus the number waiting at stops downstream (not including those who only caught the bus because it was delayed). These numbers are easily modeled.

    That way, no motorist can claim to have been ticketed for a victimless crime. (If it were actually victimless, the fine would be $0.)

    No exceptions for anyone, even (or especially) the police. For emergency vehicles, institute a system to review emergency response records and to automatically waive the ticket if the vehicle was responding to an emergency in the immediate vicinity.

  • Vooch

    Even better

    widen sidewalks
    add PBL
    buses only

  • com63

    What happens if a police car is parked in the lane and is captured on the enforcement camera? I assume nothing. I think the solution would be to make the precincts somehow suffer for getting caught doing this.

  • Anon resident

    When was the last time we saw Stringer on a bus or train? Is he grand standing again?


Upgrades to LaGuardia Bus Service Will Speed Local Trips Too

Mayor Bloomberg, NYC DOT Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan and MTA Chairman Joe Lhota this morning announced a long-anticipated plan for Select Bus Service to LaGuardia Airport, which should speed travel times to and from neighborhoods in the Bronx, Manhattan and Queens while improving service for local transit users. On the table are three routes: a Select Bus […]