The 10th Precinct’s Grievance-Based Policing Isn’t Making Streets Safer

The precinct, where drivers have killed four people walking and biking this year, has ticketed more cyclists in 2017 than speeding motorists, drivers who failed to yield, and off-route truck and bus operators combined.

10th Precinct CO Captain Paul Lanot and NYPD Commissioner James O’Neill
10th Precinct CO Captain Paul Lanot and NYPD Commissioner James O’Neill

Motorists have killed four people walking and biking in the 10th Precinct this year, and injured nearly 100. Meanwhile, precinct officers have issued almost twice as many summonses to cyclists in 2017 as they have to motorists for speeding, failure to yield, and truck route violations combined.

Last June cyclists Dan Hanegby and Michael Mamoukakis were killed by off-route tour bus drivers in the 10th Precinct in crashes that happened a few days apart. In July a motorist hit 21-year-old Frederick Swope in a crosswalk near Chelsea Piers, inflicting fatal injuries. In August a tractor-trailer driver with a suspended license killed a 73-year-old man in the 10th Precinct.

With so much motor vehicle carnage on their watch, you’d think the 10th Precinct would be cracking down on reckless driving behaviors that are getting people hurt and killed. But as of August precinct officers had ticketed just 383 drivers for failing to yield to pedestrians, and had issued only 22 truck route summonses.

Like other NYPD commands, the 10th Precinct responds to fatal collisions by ticketing potential victims. At their September community council meeting, reports Chelsea Now, precinct officials boasted about their misplaced enforcement priorities.

Bicycles and traffic safety also generated much discussion at the meeting, when an older resident expressed her concern about the speed of bicycles going down the street (there are designated bike lanes on both Eighth and Ninth Aves., the source of most complaints). Traffic/Youth Sergeant Paul Mondone said the command has already given out 815 summonses this year to speeding and other unlawful bicyclists. There are also auxiliary officers handing out flyers to every bicyclist they see.

“These people are flying through the bike path,” Sgt. Mondone noted.

The 10th Precinct issued 68 speeding tickets during the first eight months of 2017. It’s unknown how many of those went to motorists in multi-ton motor vehicles and how many were given to people on 20-pound bicycles. (Transportation Alternatives told Streetsblog it’s unlikely that many of those 815 bike tickets were for speeding.)

This week Mayor de Blasio and Police Commissioner James O’Neill announced that homicides and shootings in NYC are at their lowest levels in modern history. While NYPD attributes the decline in crime to data-driven policing, there is no evidence that such analysis extends to preventing traffic injuries and deaths.

Allowing individual precincts to shape their enforcement agendas based on who shows up to complain isn’t helping.

  • Vooch

    How many of those gov’t employees live in Chelsea ?

  • AMH

    “These people are flying through the bike path,” Sgt. Mondone noted.

    And what of the many drivers “flying” through the street at 50+mph?

  • JD

    Kudos to the precinct for so much focus on reckless and dangerous cyclists. When the uber self-righteous and self-absorbed know they can get tickets for endangering pedestrians and other cyclists, hopefully they will slow down, stop when appropriate, and yield… oh, and stay off the sidewalks. Further, there is definitely an upswing in reckless driving across the city. Just this morning a moving truck that was stopped at a red light (at a crosswalk where kids walk to/from elementary school) proceeded to run it while kids (and adults) were about to cross the street; the taxi immediately behind the truck did the exact same thing. WTF! There are many, many more examples on a daily basis. Point: Traffic (reckless, that is), which includes motor vehicles, motor cycles, electric bikes, regular bikes, etc. AND pedestrians, needs to be put under more control citywide.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Cyclists Need Protection From Reckless Driving, Not From Themselves

|
Cyclists remember following traffic rules will help prevent most collisions. Bike smart & stay safe #VisionZero #UES pic.twitter.com/Kw4V67Ca0J — NYPD 19th Precinct (@NYPD19Pct) July 27, 2016 The 19th Precinct, on the Upper East Side, tickets more cyclists than almost any other precinct in the city. So it was fitting that the above tweet this morning came from the […]

Drivers Have Killed Seven People in Bike-Obsessed 19th Precinct in 2016

|
Blanca Pagan, the senior who was struck last Friday by a driver who failed to yield, was at least the seventh pedestrian killed by a motorist this year in the 19th Precinct, on the Upper East Side. Deputy Inspector Clint McPherson, the precinct’s commanding officer, has prioritized ticketing people on bikes, with encouragement from local City Council members Ben […]