NYPD Is Still Shielding NYPD Crash Data From the Public

It’s been almost six months since Streetsblog filed a freedom of information request for data on traffic crashes involving NYPD personnel. NYPD has not released the data, or given us a reason for not doing so.

Photo: ddartley/Flickr
The 2016 Mayor’s Management Report says crashes involving NYPD personnel are up, but the department is hiding data that would reveal a more complete picture. Photo: ddartley/Flickr

The 2016 Mayor’s Management Report, released this week, says crashes involving city-owned vehicles increased 10 percent from FY 15 to FY 16 — with 5,726 crashes and 6,344 crashes, respectively. While other agencies provided the actual number of crashes involving their respective fleets, NYPD reported 3.9 collisions per 100,000 miles in FY 16, compared to 3.2 collisions per 100,000 miles in FY 15.

The per-mile figures are useful and reveal that NYPD crashes increased 22 percent — more than other agencies — but they don’t convey the scale of what’s happening. NYPD could easily provide a more complete picture by disclosing total crashes if it chose to.

Instead, NYPD has declined to tell the public and other city agencies how many traffic collisions police officers and other department staff are involved in, or the resulting costs in injuries, deaths, and property damage. Annual reports from the city comptroller’s office show NYPD consistently leads city agencies in legal settlement claims, some of which stem from vehicle crashes — a trend that continued in FY 15.

Our FOIL request, filed in March, asked NYPD for the most recent five years of department data on collisions involving NYPD vehicles, on-duty personnel, and vehicles and drivers contracted by the department. In May, about a month after we sent the FOIL, Lieutenant Richard Mantellino responded.

“Before a determination can be rendered,” Mantellino wrote, “further review is necessary to assess the potential applicability of exemptions set forth in FOIL, and whether the records can be located.”

Mantellino said the department would make a determination as to whether to honor the request within 90 days. We’ve heard nothing about it since then.

Streetsblog has asked NYPD for an update on the status of the records request.

  • Miles Bader

    Surely the FOIA has enforcement provisions… If it didn’t, requests would simply get stonewalled like 98% of the time….

  • Larry Littlefield

    I get the feeling that the public availability of data, after surging in the wake of the creation of the internet, is going away.

    For example, the last comparative data on Medicaid by state is from 2011. The last report on Medicaid by state is 2005.


    The latest city budget documents eliminated year-to-year comparisons based on a table that shows total city spending by agency, including pensions and other benefits. I recreated data showing change over time by using old documents from the Bloomberg Administration.


    And after new GASB standards were imposed, NYC changed its pension reporting to make $1 billion in retirement benefits seem to disappear in Census Bureau data.


    This is all Democratic Party stuff, not showing on what is going on in government.

    Of course the Republicans keep trying to de-fund the American Community Survey (having previously gotten rid of the Census of Population long form) to hide how much worse off so many people are in the private sector.

    The executive/financial class and the political/union class don’t want the serfs asking impertinent questions. They want them focused on nonsense as dished out from Fox News and MSNBC.

  • Vooch

    who killed Matt van Ohlen ?

  • neroden

    This is how crime gangs behave. Step one, FOIA the data. Step two, sue the hell out of the NYPD crime gang.


Streetsblog FOILs NYPD for Data on Crashes Involving Police

Streetsblog has filed a freedom of information request for NYPD data on traffic crashes involving NYPD personnel. NYPD doesn’t tell the public — or other city agencies — how many crashes police officers and other department staff get into, or what the costs are in terms of injuries, deaths, and property damage. When the Department of […]

Action Plan Ups NYC’s Commitment to Ped Safety, But Is NYPD on Board?

Mayor Bloomberg discusses DOT’s Pedestrian Safety Study and Action Plan at yesterday’s press conference with several elected officials, Transportation Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan, and NYPD Chief of Transportation James Tuller. Photo: Noah Kazis "Safety isn’t just about statistics," NYCDOT Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan said yesterday while announcing her agency’s new Pedestrian Safety Study and Action Plan. "It’s […]

New Report Breaks Down Crashes Involving City Agencies, Except NYPD

A new report sheds light on the extent to which drivers working for city agencies are involved in traffic collisions [PDF]. But the picture is incomplete: NYPD, the agency involved in the most pedestrian injury claims, is withholding its crash information from the city’s database. Excluding the police department, drivers of city-owned vehicles were involved in eight of the 250 traffic fatalities in New […]