Seniors Are Not to Blame for NYC’s Failure to Make Streets Safer

The white arrow indicates the approximate path of Lubov Brodskaya - it’s unknown if she was walking north or south - and the red arrow indicates the approximate path of the FedEx driver who killed her at E. 12th Street and Avenue J. Image: Google Maps
The white arrows indicate the approximate path of Lubov Brodskaya — it’s unknown if she was walking north or south — and the red arrow indicates the approximate path of the FedEx driver who struck her at E. 12th Street and Avenue J. Image: Google Maps

In response to motorists fatally striking seniors in the Brooklyn South command, NYPD admonished seniors to be more careful when going outside. A recent fatality in the 70th Precinct is a prime example of how focusing on the behavior of victims is a wrongheaded and ineffective approach to street safety.

One of the victims cited in last week’s DNAinfo story was Lubov Brodskaya, age 90, who was struck on August 19. NYPD told JP Updates Brodskaya was crossing at the intersection of Avenue J and E. 12th Street at around 1:35 in the afternoon “when she was hit by a FedEx van turning right into the avenue.” She died the next day.

The 27-year-old FedEx driver remained on scene and the investigation is ongoing by the NYPD’s Collision Investigation Squad, a police source said, adding that the CIS was not immediately requested by the 70th precinct for an unknown reason.

The driver is not expected to face any charges, the source said.

Brodskaya was at least the second city pedestrian in four months killed in a crash that involved a FedEx driver. I asked FedEx about the crash and received the following generic statement: “First and foremost, we extend our heartfelt condolences to the family and friends of Ms. Brodskaya. FedEx Ground cooperated fully with all authorities who investigated the accident.”

Avenue J at E. 12th Street is a signalized intersection with marked crosswalks, and E. 12th Street is one-way with no turn lanes or dedicated turn signals. If the FedEx driver had a green signal while turning right from E. 12th onto Avenue J, Brodskaya should have had a walk signal, meaning it’s likely she was crossing with the right of way.

Yet before CIS completed its investigation — after reportedly arriving late to the scene — the department was telling the press the driver probably wouldn’t be charged. Over a year after Mayor de Blasio and the City Council made it a misdemeanor for drivers to harm people walking and biking with the right of way, NYPD is failing to enforce the law consistently. As long as motorists are allowed to injure and kill people in crosswalks with impunity, the Right of Way Law will not be as effective as it could be in deterring reckless driving.

The 70th Precinct issues an average of about three failure to yield citations a day. As of July motorists had injured 159 pedestrians and cyclists in the precinct this year, and killed three, according to DOT’s Vision Zero View. Crash data indicate the 70th Precinct is behind other precincts in keeping injuries low.

As is the case with thousands of crossings citywide, drivers are allowed to park to the edge of crosswalks at the intersection where Brodskaya was struck, hindering visibility. A bill introduced in the City Council would require DOT to daylight 25 of the most hazardous intersections per year. It wouldn’t cost much to scale that up and improve safety at many more intersections.

We know what causes crashes like the one that killed Lubov Brodskaya, and it isn’t recklessness on the part of senior pedestrians.

  • JK

    Don’t forget driver culture. Compare Fed Ex to UPS drivers. Fed Ex drive like maniacs — often remarked on this with other everyday cyclists. Why? Do they have different incentives, training, union etc? (Incidentally, commercial garbage haulers and tow truck drivers seem like worst of worst “professional” drivers.)

  • Brad Aaron

    I have asked FedEx about their training and safety protocols for NYC-based drivers. No response as of now.

  • Maggie

    It is so disturbing that a driver can strike and kill a pedestrian anywhere, anytime, in New York City: in a building, on the sidewalk, in the crosswalk, and NYPD’s publicly-funded reaction is: enh. No problem.

    This is a profound disgrace. Bill de Blasio and Bill Bratton should be speaking up to fix this. A disregard for pedestrians’ right of way in the crosswalk is ridiculous.

  • WalkingNPR

    I can’t seem to find what their current status is in NY, but FedEx has recently been in hot water for possible mis-classification of their drivers as independent contractors rather than employees. I can imagine this might have an effect on how well–or not–their drivers are trained and what kind of oversight the company takes for their safety behaviors (guessing none…somewhat like Uber, et al, putting more drivers on our streets without taking any sort of responsibility for them or the havoc they cause.)

  • JamesR

    FedEx is notorious for treating their drivers like sh*t. I once had to help a FedEx driver who was sent to my work place (in a tractor trailer) to unload a pallet of goods without a dolly. It was literally just him and I, wrenching this 80lb thing off the truck while he was under the gun to get to the next job. Totally an OSHA violation. The guy was profusely thankful, but he should’ve been provided with the provided with the proper equipment to begin with.

    Miserable employees drive… miserably. The power provided by a vehicle is an easy target for projecting one’s mental state. There’s your answer.

  • Bernard Finucane

    Notice the Nissan Minivan illegally parked in the image. And the guy in a wheelchair stepping out into the street on the right. This is a crowded street that needs bulbouts on all four corners.

  • Alexander Vucelic

    both Bratton and Trottenberg bear signifucant responsibility for the negligent homicide of this poor woman

  • Bernard Finucane
  • neroden

    NYPD behavior seems to range from dereliction of duty to active conspiracy to commit crimes.

    This wouldn’t be so upsetting if they weren’t pretending to be a police department.

  • It is very dreadful that the most populous city faces such huge fiscal challenges. And this really puts a on the city officials. While they are making an eight-member team of data analysts to help the agencies apply data and analytics, yet there is a lot change required to boost the safety of streets.


MTA Bus Driver Kills Anna Colon, 73, on the Lower East Side

An MTA bus driver killed a senior on the Lower East Side this morning. Anna Colon, 73, was crossing East Houston Street north to south at around 9:50 a.m. when the driver, who was also southbound, hit her while turning left from Avenue D onto East Houston, according to NYPD. “[The light] was about to turn red […]

NYPD to Brooklyn Seniors: Stop Getting Killed by Motorists

Drivers keep killing seniors in southern Brooklyn and the NYPD’s response was to admonish seniors to be more careful crossing the street. DNAinfo reports that as of September 9, eight of 15 pedestrians killed by drivers this year in the Brooklyn South command were age 65 or older. To combat the trend, precincts in the area […]