DOT Waffles on Bed-Stuy Ped Safety Project After Resistance From CB 3

A plan to improve safety at a busy Bedford-Stuyvesant intersection [PDF] may not move forward after members of Brooklyn Community Board 3 opposed it, according to two CB 3 transportation committee members.

DOT buckled after Bed-Stuy community board members said pedestrian safety changes at this intersection would lead to traffic congestion. Image: DOT [PDF]
DOT buckled after Bed-Stuy community board members said pedestrian safety changes at this intersection would lead to traffic congestion. Image: DOT [PDF]
DOT’s Claudette Workman revealed the news at the CB 3 transportation committee meeting on May 13, said Shawn Onsgard, a public member of the committee. “She just said [it] off the cuff,” he told Streetsblog. “She was taking the safety changes off the table.”

“They said they may not do it, but then again they may do it,” said CB 3 member Doug Williams. “It depends on how much support they get.”

Asked for the status of the project, DOT spokesperson Bonny Tsang said the agency is “still discussing the project with local stakeholders.” DOT did not reply to a question asking if it has stopped moving forward with the design, which it presented to the committee last month.

Update 1:45 p.m.: “We are still discussing this project with the local stakeholders — in fact, we will be meeting with the Council Member, the District Manager and the CB Chair,” Tsang said. “We never said that we are not doing the safety improvements. As we do with many projects, we discuss with the local community if they have concerns about the project and try to address them.”

Onsgard and Williams said most board members were worried that closing two “slip” lanes, which allow drivers to make quick right turns from Fulton Street to Utica Avenue and Malcolm X Boulevard, would create congestion. Closing the lanes would create additional space for pedestrians, reducing crossing distances for people transferring between the B46, B25, and A/C trains.

“That slip turn is dangerous,” Williams said. “I would hope that they would change it.”

There were 58 traffic injuries at the intersection between 2009 and 2013, according to DOT. Fulton Street and Utica Avenue have been identified as Vision Zero priority corridors in need of safety improvements. In addition, the existing pedestrian islands are not accessible to people in wheelchairs, forcing them into the street.

The proposal was made in tandem with plans to upgrade the B46 to Select Bus Service later this year.

The intersection is in the City Council district represented by Robert Cornegy Jr. An inquiry to his office this morning was not returned. Borough President Eric Adams, who appoints community board members, also did not reply to a request for comment.

This isn’t the first time DOT has been cowed by Community Board 3. Last year, DOT scrapped plans to install a neighborhood Slow Zone, featuring 20 mph speed limits and speed humps, after CB 3 members objected that it would cause traffic congestion and pollution. The Slow Zone stops short at Classon Avenue, CB 3’s western border.

While more than two-thirds of households in Bed-Stuy don’t own cars, many CB 3 members view street redesigns from the perspective of motorists, said Onsgard. “People feel like they need to drive,” he said. “There’s a real resistance to Vision Zero-style, safety-oriented traffic engineering in Bed-Stuy.”

  • Reader

    Aren’t those islands in the slip lanes non-ADA compliant? Someone should sue CB3.

  • BBnet3000

    The CB system is wreaking havoc on safety and livable streets improvements, and it seems to me, wasting a ton of resources. We either need to ignore them and make these improvements, or not bother proposing further improvements in districts that rebuff them and focus our clearly very limited livable streets resources where improvements can be implemented.

  • neroden

    These “community boards” are *appointed*. They do not represent the community. Why are they being used as an excuse to cancel community-supported projects?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Big CB Meetings in Brooklyn and Manhattan, Starting Tonight

|
There are several important community board meetings scheduled this week in Manhattan and Brooklyn — two one of them tonight. Manhattan Community Board 7 is set to vote this evening on a DOT proposal to install curb extensions at 72nd Street and Riverside Drive. The plan is intended to slow traffic and reduce crossing distances for pedestrians […]

Antonio Reynoso: DOT Should Forge Ahead With Myrtle-Wyckoff Plaza

|
Council Member Antonio Reynoso wants DOT to move forward with its safety plan at the busy Myrtle-Wyckoff transit hub, with or without the endorsement of the local community board. Last Wednesday, Brooklyn Community 4 voted against DOT’s plan, which would dramatically reduce potential conflicts between drivers and pedestrians and create a car-free plaza on one block of Wyckoff Avenue between Myrtle and […]

Myrtle-Wyckoff Plaza Gets Support From Queens CB 5 Transpo Committee

|
Last night, the Queens Community Board 5 transportation committee endorsed DOT’s safety plan for the Myrtle-Wyckoff transit hub on the border between Brooklyn and Queens, including the creation of a one-block pedestrian plaza on Wyckoff Avenue between Gates and Myrtle [PDF]. The project straddles two community board districts and was voted down by Brooklyn CB 4 […]

CB 2 Panel OKs Hudson Street Bike Lane Upgrade, Bowery Ped Safety Tweaks

|
Last night, Manhattan Community Board 2’s transportation committee unanimously supported two safety measures: one to upgrade a bike lane on Hudson Street, and another to tweak pedestrian improvements at the car-clogged intersection of the Bowery and Delancey Street. Almost two-and-a-half years after asking DOT to upgrade the faded buffered bike lane on Hudson Street to a […]