DOT’s Safety Plan for 21st Street in Astoria Leaves Everyone Wanting More

A street safety plan for 21st Street in western Queens has left elected officials asking for more from DOT.

Since 2009, five people have died on 21st Street in Astoria. Map: DOT
Since 2009, five people have been killed on 21st Street in Astoria. Map: DOT

The plan covers approximately two miles of 21st Street between the Queensboro Bridge and Triboro Bridge. In terms of safety, the street ranks in the bottom third of Queens’ roads. There were five fatalities on 21st Street from 2009 to 2015, including two pedestrians and one cyclist, according to DOT [PDF]. From 2009 to 2013, there were 14 serious injuries, including five pedestrians and one cyclist.

DOT’s plan doesn’t measure up to the danger on 21st Street.

The agency is proposing adding LED lights, which are already in the process of being phased in citywide, to improve nighttime visibility. It will also refresh the street’s paint, adding high-visibility zebra markings to existing crosswalks and installing a new stripe along the curbside parking lane to reduce speeding.

Earlier this month, DOT added leading pedestrian intervals, which give pedestrians a seven-second head start, to 10 intersections. An LPI was already in place at 21st Street and Broadway.

A total of 12 painted curb extensions will be added to nine intersections to shorten crossing distances. Council Member Costa Constantinides says his office will pay the Doe Fund to maintain the painted neckdowns, which could be candidates for capital upgrades funded through the council district’s participatory budgeting process. DOT also says it is seeking funds for capital upgrades to the neckdowns.

One spot that isn’t getting much attention from DOT is the complex intersection of Astoria Boulevard, 27th Avenue, and 21st Street. The Department of City Planning’s western Queens transportation study recommended neckdowns and pedestrian islands for the intersection, but they do not appear in DOT’s plan.

21st Street has long stretches without traffic signals or marked crosswalks, and DOT plans to install a new traffic signal at 29th Avenue. The intersections at 28th Avenue, 30th Road, 33rd Avenue, and 39th Avenue, however, did not meet DOT’s requirements for new signals.

Assembly Member Aravella Simotas, Council Member Jimmy Van Bramer, and State Senator Michael Gianaris all had the same fundamental message: The plan is a good start, but they want more. “It wasn’t everything we were looking to get,” Constantinides said. “There is definitely more that can be done on 21st Street.”

While the elected officials seem most focused on securing additional traffic lights, signals don’t necessarily make a street safer. Steve Scofield, a Transportation Alternatives volunteer who grew up on 21st Street in the 1950s, said bike lanes and pedestrian islands could be included as part of a road diet. “There’s frequently just one lane of moving traffic,” he said, “and you’re just weaving back and forth between double parkers and left turners.”

DOT says it studied a road diet but did not pursue it because of high traffic volumes, including during off-peak hours. Many of the street’s drivers, bound for the free Queensboro Bridge, are avoiding tolls on other crossings.

“Toll shopping’s not good for anyone,” said Constantinides, who added that “there’s a lot of good” in the Move NY toll reform plan. “It looks like it’s more of an Albany proposal,” he said. “I’m going to continue to speak with some of my colleagues about it.”

Constantinides, who called for Select Bus Service on 21st Street during his campaign in 2013, said the street needs a long-term plan as western Astoria continues to densify.

“We’re going to have to constantly re-evaluate this street,” Constantinides said. “I don’t think this is going to be a roadway that is forgotten by DOT.”

The Queens Community Board 1 transportation committee overwhelmingly voted to support DOT’s plan on Monday, said district manager Lucille Hartmann. The plan now goes up for a vote at the full board on March 17. DOT says it hopes to implement the changes after a street resurfacing planned for 21st Street later this year.

This post has been updated with responses from DOT about the feasibility of a road diet and the project’s implementation schedule.

  • 1ifbyrain2ifbytrain

    The article mentions the new streetlights which are much better! We have them now beneath the elevated D (bring back the West End M!) tracks along New Utrecht in Bensonhurst and the visibility is much improved.

    As is linked, we have Bloomberg and Sadik-Khan to thank for this:
    Mayor Bloomberg and Transportation Commissioner Sadik-Khan Announce All 250,000 Street Lights in New York City Will Be Replaced With Energy-Efficient LEDs by 2017, Reducing Energy Consumption and Cost.
    October 24, 2013

  • BBnet3000

    It sounds to me like the local politicians are hinting at wanting a real livable streets plan that would really change the area and make it a more comfortable place to be and less dominated by the noise and fumes of cars (which incidentally would bring huge safety benefits and support local businesses along this corridor).

    Instead they got the low hanging fruit, crossing enhancements-only approach that is becoming typical of Vision Zero. No general improvements in bike/walk infrastructure and no complete/livable/sustainable streets strategy. At some point they’ll probably think to start calling this approach “surgical” but a better description would be “penny ante”.

  • Richard Garey

    We didn’t get much better in the Bronx. I didn’t see any improvements proposed for the Grand Concourse that would suggest to me that we are going to achieve “Vision Zero.” They are improvements…yes. However, I don’t see them as having a transformative effect relative to reduction of the annual death toll.

  • AlexB

    Constantinides is right on by calling for Select Bus Service on 21st. The area west of 31st St (where the N and Q run) is really crying out for better transit and this is the one corridor that could fit dedicated bus lanes and feeds into the upper deck of the Queensboro for direct access to 57th St.

    I bike in Astoria all the time and the neighborhood needs a lot more bike lanes but this area is actually one where there already exists better options that feed into the Queensboro Bridge bike lanes more directly. I’d support bus lanes over bike lanes on 21st, with a series of bus bulbs and curb extensions at crosswalks.

    There are also way too many big trucks on that street, often double parked and not even in a single lane. It’s dangerous for all users and the NYPD should play a role as well.

  • J P

    Absolutely agree – as a longtime Astoria resident who recently moved to 21st street, I’m shocked by a) how dangerous the street is (witnessed multiple accidents and almost been clipped by a car while crossing with the light) and b) how much transit potential it has. The express q100 is such a great conduit to the Queensbridge/Queensboro stops that I’ve pretty much given up taking the N/Q. A dedicated bus lane would make it even better, and probably safer too – people drive so fast that streetside parking shouldn’t even be allowed.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

DOT’s Astoria Park Safety Plan Calls for 3 Protected Bike Lanes

|
Last June, a hit-and-run driver killed 21-year-old Betty DiBiaso at the intersection of 19th Street and Ditmars Boulevard, next to Astoria Park. The loss of DiBiaso prompted a neighborhood-wide discussion about the need to improve street safety around one of Queens’ most visited parks, and on Tuesday night DOT showed Queens Community Board 2 its proposals for the area […]

DOT Shows No Traffic Calming Ingenuity for Astoria’s Deadly 21st Ave

|
Astoria residents demanding a safer 21st Avenue. Image: indiejourno.com. Over the last six weeks, Astoria residents have made a strong push for a safer 21st Avenue, a street plagued by speeding cut-through traffic. In response to requests for traffic calming, NYCDOT recently sent what one resident called a "cryptic letter" explaining only that the street […]

Queens CB 6 Eager for Safety Fixes (Just Don’t Touch Their Parking)

|
The Rego Park senior focus area, which includes several blocks of Queens Boulevard, is slated for pedestrian improvements. Click here to enlarge. Image: NYCDOT. As we’ve recently seen in Astoria, DOT doesn’t always bring innovative traffic calming tools to streets that need them. What happens when they do? At a community board meeting in Rego […]

After Fatal Hit-and-Run, Queens CB 1 Calls on DOT to Redesign 21st Street

|
Queens Community Board 1 endorsed a resolution late last night asking DOT for a “comprehensive redesign of the entire length of 21st Street along Complete Street principles.” The vote comes after a hit-and-run driver killed 45-year-old Sean Crume walking across 21st Street at 30th Road, where there is no signalized crossing, earlier this month. It was the fourth fatality on […]