Pedestrian Deaths Have Fallen in Every Borough Except Staten Island

Pedestrian fatalities in New York City have been cut in half over the past three decades -- except for Staten Island. Chart: DOT
Pedestrian deaths in New York City have dropped by half over three decades — except for Staten Island. Chart: DOT

DOT released the final installment of its pedestrian safety plans yesterday with a report for Staten Island [PDF], where the nature of pedestrian crashes is different than in the other boroughs.

Map: DOT
DOT’s priority areas cover locations where nearly three-quarters of Staten Island’s pedestrian deaths or serious injuries occurred. Click to enlarge. Map: DOT

Over the past three decades, the city as a whole grew approximately 19 percent while the number of pedestrian fatalities was cut in half. On Staten Island, while the population has increased at a more rapid clip of 30 percent, pedestrian fatalities have not declined at all.

On average, about 40 pedestrians are severely injured and seven are killed on Staten Island streets each year. The borough’s rate of 1.4 pedestrian deaths per 100,000 residents is lower than the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, or Queens.

But that doesn’t mean, as Transportation Commissioner Polly Trottenberg told the Advance, that “Staten Island is by far the safest borough.” Because people don’t walk as much in Staten Island as they do in other boroughs,  it’s difficult to compare to other parts of the city — but the risk of getting around on foot is still substantial.

DOT’s report notes that most of Staten Island is auto-dependent, with 82 percent of households owning at least one car, almost double the citywide average. Two-thirds of Staten Islanders drive to work, more than double the citywide rate.

The North Shore is less car-dependent than the rest of Staten Island, and that’s where pedestrian deaths are concentrated. The area east of the Bayonne Bridge and north of the Staten Island Expressway accounts for about 45 percent of the borough’s pedestrian fatalities and serious injuries, but only 18 percent of its land area. (Outside of the North Shore, Hylan Boulevard is another danger zone.)

Here are more factoids from the report:

  • Afternoons and evenings are deadly, with four in five Staten Island pedestrian fatalities occurring between 3 p.m. and 9 p.m., compared to 31 percent citywide.
  • Almost two in three Staten Island pedestrian fatalities are on arterial streets. DOT identified 16 priority corridors that make up just 6 percent of the borough’s street network — but were the site of 40 percent of pedestrian fatalities and 54 percent of all pedestrian deaths or serious injuries.
  • When combined with priority intersections and areas, priority locations cover just more than half of all pedestrian fatalities and 72 percent of all pedestrians killed or seriously injured.
  • 45 percent of Staten Island pedestrian deaths occurred mid-block, higher than the citywide rate of one in three.
  • Nine in ten Staten Island pedestrian fatalities, compared to 68 percent citywide, were inflicted by someone driving a private car. Dangerous choices by drivers are the primary cause or a contributing factor in 67 percent of Staten Island pedestrian fatalities.
  • Seniors aged 65 and older comprise 14 percent of Staten Island’s population but 25 percent of its pedestrian deaths.

The top Staten Island complaint on DOT’s Vision Zero map was speeding, at 26 percent of all complaints, followed by failure to yield at 20 percent and red light running at 10 percent.

While Staten Islanders may be more car-dependent than other boroughs, they are very interested in traffic calming: DOT says that when it launched the Neighborhood Slow Zone program in 2012, 43 of 97 total requests came from Staten Island.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

TSTC Names the Most Dangerous Roads for Pedestrians

|
A new report from the Tri-State Transportation Campaign names five New York City streets among the region’s 10 most dangerous roads for pedestrians, based on the number of fatalities from 2005 to 2007. Making the list were: Third Avenue, Manhattan: 10 fatalities Broadway, Manhattan: 10 fatalities Grand Central Parkway, Queens: 9 fatalities Hylan Boulevard, Staten […]

Older Pedestrians More Likely to Die in Traffic: Will New York State DOT Act?

|
Manhattan is the most dangerous borough for residents age 60 and older to walk, and older pedestrians throughout the metro region suffer disproportionately from deadly traffic violence, according to a new report from the Tri-State Transportation Campaign. The report recommends that New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut adopt NACTO design guidelines for safer, multi-modal streets. […]

City Numbers Show Highest Cyclist Death Toll in Eight Years

|
 Traffic fatalities in 2007 were at their lowest level since the city began keeping records almost 100 years ago, according to data released today by the Bloomberg administration. However, while the number of pedestrian fatalities last year dropped sharply percentage-wise from 2006, down to roughly one death every two-and-a-half days, cyclist fatalities were up, and […]