Trottenberg: DOT Staffing Up to Add More Select Bus Service Routes

The City Council transportation committee held a hearing today on the de Blasio administration’s Bus Rapid Transit plans, giving council members an opportunity to prod DOT about its BRT progress and show their support (or lack thereof) for bus lanes and more robust surface transit improvements than the Select Bus Service program has yielded so far.

DOT Commissioner Polly Trottenberg testifies, flanked by Peter Cafiero of the MTA, left, and Eric Beaton of DOT, right. Photo: Brad Lander/Twitter
DOT Commissioner Polly Trottenberg testifying this afternoon, flanked by Peter Cafiero of the MTA, left, and Eric Beaton of DOT, right. Photo: Brad Lander/Twitter

DOT Commissioner Polly Trottenberg said the mayor’s preliminary budget, released yesterday, features $295 million for SBS expansion, including $84 million in new funding. Of that, $55 million will go to operational expenses through fiscal year 2018 and $240 million will go to capital projects through 2025.

The funding boost should help enlarge the agency’s SBS project pipeline, paying for staff to both work with community boards and assist with engineering for new SBS routes. The new money replaces some federal funds that were expiring and roughly doubles the size of the SBS unit to 18 staffers, according to DOT Director of Transit Development Eric Beaton.

Here are some more highlights from the hearing:

  • Mark your calendars: The de Blasio administration has committed to adding 13 Select Bus Service routes by the end of 2017, an effort Trottenberg said would require “all hands on deck.” This year, DOT and MTA are aiming to bring SBS improvements to three additional routes. Upgrades to the M86 crosstown, which will feature off-board fare payment and other improvements but not bus lanes, is expected to launch this spring, followed by the B46 on Utica Avenue by the end of the summer and the Q44 between Jamaica and Flushing in the fall. A typical SBS route costs $10 million to launch, Trottenberg said, with more capital-intensive upgrades like bus bulbs continuing to be rolled out after the initial improvements.

  • All eyes on Woodhaven: The City Council’s Progressive Caucus is pushing City Hall to implement more robust BRT projects with features like physically separated bus lanes. DOT has yet to implement that type of design on any SBS route, but it is studying a center-running transitway for Woodhaven and Cross Bay Boulevards. Trottenberg said the project will include “some of the most cutting-edge things we’re seeing around the world.” DOT is seeking a grant from the Federal Transit Administration for the 14-mile, $200 million project, she said, and hopes to hear back from the feds by August.
  • Bus lane cameras: Instead of using physical separation, the city has set up enforcement cameras to keep bus lanes clear. Trottenberg said the cameras “have worked well” but the state law enabling them expires at the end of September. Albany restricts the cameras to a limited number of routes, and DOT has deployed cameras on only five SBS lines. Trottenberg wants to expand that number. “City Hall has still not put out our full Albany agenda,” she said. “I look forward to working with City Hall and seeing how they want to prioritize this.”
  • Bus lane tantrums will be rewarded: The hearing included an exchange between Trottenberg and Council Member Rory Lancman in which the commissioner all but guaranteed that there would not be bus lanes in his district. “We go block by block, we almost go parking space by parking space, in trying to come up with a configuration that’s going to work,” she said. “And in places where we don’t need to do the dedicated bus lanes, which had folks so concerned in Kew Gardens Hills, we’re not gonna do it.” (Later in the hearing, Trottenberg explained that adding bus lanes can actually help all traffic flow more smoothly, but that didn’t seem to catch Lancman’s interest.)
  • Lander’s bill for BRT planning: Council Member Brad Lander has introduced a bill requiring DOT to work with the MTA to create a 10-year Bus Rapid Transit plan that lays out expected BRT routes and estimates capital and operating costs. The bill, similar to legislation Lander introduced in 2013, did not come up for a vote today.

The hearing also included testimony from the Department of Citywide Administrative Services, which manages the city’s 26,000-vehicle fleet. A bill from Council Member Ritchie Torres of the Bronx would require the city to shift five percent of its fleet to car-sharing each year. DCAS requested changes to the bill that would exclude purpose-built vehicles, such as garbage trucks, from the car-share requirement.

DCAS also touted its existing car-share agreement with Zipcar, which has helped eliminate more than 450 vehicles from the city’s fleet since 2012.

  • Larry Littlefield

    “Lander’s bill for BRT planning: Council Member Brad Lander has introduced a bill requiring DOT to work with the MTA to create a 10-year Bus Rapid Transit plan that lays out expected BRT routes and estimates capital and operating costs.”

    I still say the city should take over the bus and paratransit system, and the payroll tax should be distributed to NYC and the counties, at a net cost to the city of $800 million. Since he is cutting pension funding, shifting the cost of past retroactive pension increases to the further future so more members of Generation Greed can slink out of town before paying, DeBlasio seems to have money for everything else.

    That reduction in costs would be an increased city contribution to the MTA Capital Plan. The tolls would be a similar contribution. Squeezing the contractors would be a third. And the city would finally take responsibility for buses on its streets the way it does for ferries.

    https://larrylittlefield.wordpress.com/2014/02/26/the-city-of-new-york-should-take-over-its-bus-and-paratransit-system/

    Are we really going back to the days when a few nickels for “planning” were enough to get a politician in the newspaper? They pulled that BS for a couple do decades before the media caught on the scam.

  • BBnet3000

    Expect many hours of meetings consisting of “this will make gridlock so we cant do it, but I only drive because the buses are too slow” (ie bloviating and lying). Expect a lot of electeds to sit out most of the planning stages with their fingers in the air trying to figure out which way the wind is blowing.

  • Emmily_Litella

    Great team spearheading the planning and implementation. The inability (after three plus years) to restore the flashing blue lights killed by some two-bit haters does not inspire much confidence in the overall process though.

  • AnoNYC

    Trottenberg said the project will include “some of the most cutting-edge things we’re seeing around the world.”

    NYC DOT cutting edge? Sorry if I can’t even dream it!

    Meanwhile, Albany still controls traffic camera enforcement expansion.

    Any idea what routes are up for SBS enhancements?

  • Boris

    ‘Trottenberg said the project will include “some of the most cutting-edge things we’re seeing around the world.”’

    You mean we’ll finally get LRT?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

De Blasio Commits $250M to Overhaul Major Streets, But How Far Will It Go?

|
Before a City Council transportation committee budget hearing this morning, the de Blasio administration announced its “Great Streets” initiative, which includes $250 million in capital funds to improve safety on Queens Boulevard, the Grand Concourse, Atlantic Avenue, and Fourth Avenue in Brooklyn. From 2009 to 2013, 34 pedestrians were killed and 215 seriously injured on these four […]

DOT Breaks Down Street Safety Spending for City Council

|
At a City Council budget hearing today, Transportation Commissioner Polly Trottenberg outlined in detail how DOT plans to allocate funds for street safety over the next year. DOT will spend $23 million to acquire the 120 additional speed cameras that were authorized by the state legislature this session, Trottenberg said, and will begin the procurement […]

NYC’s Next Transportation Commissioner Is Polly Trottenberg

|
Bill de Blasio has appointed US DOT Under Secretary for Policy Polly Trottenberg to lead the New York City Department of Transportation. Trottenberg is a veteran federal policy maker, whose resume includes stints working for New York Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan on the 1998 federal transportation bill and for Senator Chuck Schumer. At the Obama […]

Select Bus Service Launches on 125th Street

|
On Sunday, Select Bus Service launched on a route that stretches from 125th Street in Harlem to LaGuardia Airport. Public officials marked the occasion — the first SBS route to debut during the de Blasio era — at a Harlem press conference today. With off-board fare collection and dedicated bus lanes (on part of the […]