Victims’ Families to Electeds: End the Obstruction of Safe Streets on the UWS

Council Member Mark Levine, Borough President Gale Brewer, and Council Member Helen Rosenthal can decide whether or not to reappoint longtime street safety foe Dan Zweig to Community Board 7. Photos: NYC Council

Years of frustration with the leadership of Manhattan Community Board 7 boiled over at a traffic safety forum on the Upper West Side last night. Twice during the event, neighborhood residents who lost family members to traffic violence called on elected officials not to reappoint Dan Zweig, who has co-chaired CB 7’s transportation committee for at least 15 years and blocked or delayed key street safety proposals.

Last night’s panel included Dana Lerner of Families For Safe Streets, whose son Cooper was killed by a turning cab driver last year. She told the audience she was shocked to learn after her son’s death that there were proposals from neighborhood groups to improve street safety — including for the block where Cooper was killed — that had failed to receive support from the community board. “When I found out about this, I was crushed. I was just crushed. I couldn’t understand,” she said. “All I could think was, if they had — if this had been looked at, might Cooper be alive? I always wonder that.”

After Cooper’s death, DOT implemented a road diet on West End Avenue, including pedestrian islands at the intersection where Cooper was killed. Lerner said neighbors ask her if she’s pleased to see the changes. “I don’t understand why it was my son’s death that made this happen,” she said. “Community Board 7, particularly Dan Zweig, was not receptive to the ideas of the community. And I feel that moving forward, we absolutely have to have people who are willing to listening to the community members.”

Zweig has a long history of stonewalling street safety projects. A redesign of Columbus Avenue added a protected bike lane and pedestrian islands, improving safety for all street users, including a 41 percent drop in pedestrian injuries. But Zweig, who had used parliamentary process to try to block the project, said he doesn’t trust DOT’s numbers and insists the street has become more dangerous.

Other projects have been stalled at Zweig’s hands, as well. Last September, he and committee co-chair Andrew Albert sent a letter asking DOT to stop a one-day demonstration program that would add tables and chairs to an extra-wide sidewalk on 97th Street between Columbus and Amsterdam until the committee had given its two cents. The letter, sent on CB 7 letterhead, was never approved by the committee, and residents who were asking for the upgrades weren’t copied on the letter [PDF].

“They’re supposed to consult the rest of the committee before they make a move like that. And apparently that’s par for the course,” said Bob Leonard of Friends of Stryker Park. “These guys wound up pulling the rug out from underneath us.”

Albert defended Zweig after last night’s forum. “It does appear there’s a campaign to vilify us, and I think that’s a shame. We’ve done a lot of very pedestrian-friendly things,” he said. But when the subject turned to the neighborhood’s wide arterial streets, where speeding is rampant and injury rates are high, Albert opposed ideas that would calm traffic. He said removing a traffic lane or narrowing car lanes to less than 12 feet on north-south avenues leads to dangerous congestion. Instead, he said the board had already secured a significant safety improvement from DOT for Amsterdam Avenue: a change in signal timing.

“It was really unfair to single Dan out. Dan has fought for pedestrian safety improvements, as I have. If we didn’t do it to everybody’s speed and liking, there’s no way to control that,” Albert said. “These things, unfortunately, unless there’s a death, move very glacially in the city.”

Mary Beth Kelly, whose husband was killed in 2006 by a truck driver on the Hudson River Greenway, spoke up during last night’s forum. “We have had leadership at the community board that is morally bankrupt,” she said, adding that it is unacceptable for Albert and Zweig “to wait and to push off and to allow deaths to happen that should not have happened, that could have been prevented if the right leadership at that transportation committee had been placed there.”

Community board members are appointed to two-year terms by the borough president, with half recommended by local council members. Zweig was last appointed by former Borough President Scott Stringer two years ago at the recommendation of Inez Dickens, when her district included a northern section of Community Board 7. The area is now represented by Council members Helen Rosenthal and Mark Levine, who must decide whether to recommend Zweig for reappointment.

“As for particular members of the community board, I actually think it’s inappropriate to discuss that in this venue,” Rosenthal said during last night’s panel. “If anybody wants to talk with me about particular community board members, reach out to me.”

“We are still in the process of reviewing applications, but are committed to ensuring that every member we appoint supports a vision of safe, pedestrian-friendly streets on the Upper West Side,” Levine said in a statement.

“Our process is underway,” said Borough President Gale Brewer’s director of communications, Jon Houston. Brewer ultimately appoints all community board members and re-appointed Albert last year. “We announce appointments and reappointments on April 1st.”

“That’s something I really feel needs to be remedied,” Lerner said of community board appointees who drag their feet on street safety plans. “There needs to be accountability here.”

  • Brad Aaron

    Here’s why Brewer’s spox gave a date instead of a commitment:

    Brewer is generally amenable on livable streets but her CB friends have done more than enough to cancel her out.

  • dporpentine

    “As for particular members of the community board, I actually think it’s inappropriate to discuss that in this venue,” Rosenthal said during last night’s panel. “If anybody wants to talk with me about particular community board members, reach out to me.”

    I mean, my goodness! The NERVE of voters to hold people accountable in public for the devastation their irresponsible decisions have caused. If we unelected power mongers aren’t constantly petted for defending our own narrow interests, how will anything good ever get done?

  • Parent

    I think Zweig and Albert are right. It’s pointless to keep vilifying them. They aren’t going to change.

    The keys are in the electeds’ hands, most notably Gale Brewer’s. Yet in April 2014 she said the best approach to change at the community board was to just wait for people to “eventually come around.” We’re still waiting, even though more people have been injured and killed. Let’s not wait for any more dead children and then pretend to be so impressed when everyone springs to action to institute another round of half-baked safety “improvements.”

    The number one improvement we could see is for these politicians to show some courage, clean out these committees, and stand up for young kids who don’t get a seat on community boards.

    “I don’t take people off just because they have — you know, they’ve been going to meetings and they have good attendance and they work well, I don’t take them off. But we can talk to them. I’m very conscious of what you’re talking about. And I think eventually people will come around to the fact that what TA and others know, which is that bike and pedestrian and car safety is better when you have cars going slower.”

  • BBnet3000

    Just because the Community Board system sometimes gives good results doesn’t mean it isn’t fundamentally flawed. The majority of voters in this city support expanding protected bike lanes and other improves for pedestrians and cycling. We talk a lot about “electeds”, but that is exactly what Community Board members are not.

  • Mark Walker

    Zweig should go and Albert should be next. They’ve had enough second chances.

  • J

    If public representatives are not accountable to the public they represent, there is a serious problem. Put it to a vote, and Zweig would be quickly voted out. There is no vote, though, so people must resort to alternative means of making their voice heard.

  • Appalled Upper West Sider

    ”These things, unfortunately, unless there’s a death, move very glacially in the city.” Thanks to obstructionists like you, Mr. Albert.

  • Parent

    There have been deaths! And still there’s glacial process. Time for Albert to go. NOW.

  • Sean Robertson

    Why the hell are CBs appointed and not elected in the first place? That’s the real fail here. Make them like DC’s Advisory Neighborhood Commission and make them elected positions. And do it yesterday.

  • WoodyinNYC

    Community Board members should eventually rotate off. The Committee Chairs particularly need to be refreshed. “Longtime” Board Member and Transportation Chair Zweig has been around for 5 years, or more. Time for him to go move his parked car and then just keep on moving.

  • Guest

    Make that on the board for 25-30 years and co-chair for at least 15 of those, probably more.

  • JK

    People are rightly angry? How many pedestrian and bicycle safety projects have Andrew Albert and Dan Zweig delayed or obstructed in their decades on CB 7? A dozen, two dozen? It is simply astonishing that people like this have a major say over the safety of UWS streets in 2014.

  • Komanoff

    Has anyone drawn up a bill of attainder against Alpert and Zweig? I’d like to write to MBPrez Brewer urging her to not reappoint them, and a fairly comprehensive list of their obstructions and exceedances would be really helpful.

  • Nemo

    Wasn’t one of those guys quoted as saying that he dislikes road diets etc because they make it harder for him to reach the tunnel on Friday afternoons when he’s on his way to his house in the Poconos or someplace like that?

  • ADN

    I get why elected officials don’t want to un-appointment CB members. That’s politically difficult. But these lifetime appointments are clearly not good for the community. It’s insane that a guy like Zweig would be allowed to run the same committee for 15 years. Who thinks that is a good idea?

    If Gale were smart she would just sort of create a rule by which she limited CB appointments to some set term — say, eight years. After eight years you’d have to wait some period of time and then if you really wanted to re-join the CB you could re-apply.

    This is what we did with the Park Slope Civic Council and it was a huge boon to that organization. It brought in loads of new members, new energy and new ideas. Term limits ensured that the PSCC was keeping in step with the neighborhood which, of course, is always changing. Prior to term limits the PSCC felt like a coffee klatch for a bunch of cranky people who’d been sitting around the table together for twenty years grinding the same old axes. It was the place where new ideas went to die. Community Boards clearly need term limits too.

  • Carol
  • Komanoff

    Thanks. Saw.


Gale Brewer Reappoints Safe Streets Foes to Manhattan Community Boards

Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer has reappointed a slate of community board members with a long history of opposing safer streets and better transit. Brewer announced her 2015 board appointments on Monday. Among those granted another two-year term was Community Board 7’s Dan Zweig. Zweig was recommended by Council Member Helen Rosenthal and reappointed by Brewer despite […]

UWS Residents to Brewer: No More Street Safety Obstructionists on CB 7

Will Gale Brewer reappoint noted street safety obstructionist Dan Zweig to Community Board 7? Families of traffic violence victims came to her State of the Borough address yesterday seeking an answer. Protesters stood outside Columbia University’s Alfred Lerner Hall with signs — “Gale, You Have the Power to Fix CB 7” and “Lives Matter More Than Parking […]

CB 7 Members, Upper West Siders Back Amsterdam Ave Protected Bikeway

The room was packed last night for DOT’s long-awaited plan for a protected bike lane and pedestrian islands on Amsterdam Avenue on the Upper West Side [PDF], with about 120 people turning out at the Manhattan Community Board 7 transportation committee meeting. Most residents and committee members praised the plan, though no vote was held. DOT says it […]