Cuomo’s Transpo Vision: Huge Garages, Cheap Roads, Lots More MTA Debt

A day before his big statewide policy address, Governor Andrew Cuomo laid out his transportation and infrastructure agenda today at a Midtown breakfast hosted by the Association for a Better New York, a business group. This was not the speech where the governor finally laid out his plan to prevent runaway MTA debt, fix the traffic that is choking New York City’s economy, and revive cities around the state by tearing out decrepit 20th century highways and redeveloping downtowns.

Governor Cuomo talks transportation this morning. Photo: Governor's Office/Flickr
Governor Cuomo talks transportation this morning. Photo: Governor’s Office/Flickr

Instead, surprising no one, Cuomo promised subsidies to keep highway tolls cheap, train stations with tons of parking, and economic development centered around airports. The speech did not even mention the most pressing transportation issue in New York right now: the $15 billion gap in the MTA’s five-year capital program.

Cuomo did mention that the capital program will pay for new buses and subway cars, the Second Avenue subway, Metro-North along the Hell Gate Line, signal upgrades, and Bus Rapid Transit (which he called “a big part of the future”) — all part of the plan already. The governor also touted an attention-grabbing new proposal to build an AirTrain line to LaGuardia Airport from the Long Island Rail Road and 7 train stations at Willets Point, a 30-minute subway ride from Times Square.

Cuomo said the LaGuardia project is in “initial planning phases,” though the administration expects the 1.5-mile line to cost $450 million and take the Port Authority, in consultation with the MTA, five years to build. (A more direct proposal to extend the N train from Astoria to LaGuardia, championed by Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, was scuttled by NIMBY opposition more than a decade ago.) Cuomo also proposed tax-free zones for businesses near Stewart and Republic airports in a bid to boost freight traffic there.

Meanwhile, the most significant new MTA proposal unveiled this morning involves building garages for park-and-ride commuters to Metro-North and LIRR stations at Ronkonkoma, Nassau Hub near Roosevelt Field, and Lighthouse Landing in Tarrytown. Tellingly, the images that flashed on screen as Cuomo spoke did not depict parking structures, but tree-lined streets with apartments and retail from transit-oriented development projects in Westchester County and Long Island. The state will subsidize the garages to the tune of $150 million, according to a press release, but it’s not clear if this will cover the total cost and, if not, whether the MTA will be on the hook for the rest.

The governor wants New Yorkers to think that this infrastructure construction will come at essentially no cost. “All the costs will be from existing state resources,” Cuomo said. He mentioned the $5 billion bank settlement windfall as a potential source of funding, but his staff couldn’t say after the event exactly how much of that kitty might go to transportation.

In any case, nothing the governor mentioned would come close to addressing the $15.2 billion MTA capital program shortfall. According to a press release, the state will contribute $750 million over the course of the five-year program, down from $770 million in the previous capital program [PDF]. While those funds are a new commitment, they still leave the deficit at about $14.5 billion.

The best solution would be to reform New York’s dysfunctional toll system, yielding environmental, economic, equity, and transportation benefits in addition to new funding. Former MTA chief Elliot “Lee” Sander, who hasn’t come out for one fix over another, is calling on elected officials to come up with a solution. He said he was “not surprised” that Cuomo’s remarks failed to address the MTA’s capital plan budget gap. “There’s enough room in there to figure it out,” he said of the governor’s position, “and he’s committed to figuring it out.”

As long as Cuomo avoids crafting a specific solution, however, the gap threatens to saddle straphangers with billions in additional debt — meaning fare hikes down the line.

While transit riders have to worry about rising fares, Cuomo is reassuring motorists on the state’s highways that tolls won’t go up. The state budget will subsidize $1.3 billion in Thruway Authority expenses and send $750 million to the state DOT for roads and bridges, according to a release. And however the state ends up paying for the $4 billion Tappan Zee Bridge, it won’t involve toll hikes on the financially troubled Thruway, which is undergoing a management shakeup. Cuomo reiterated his promise not to raise system-wide Thruway tolls.

Absent from the governor’s speech was any mention of highway teardowns like I-81 in Syracuse or the Sheridan Expressway in the Bronx that are currently in play as economic development projects in several cities around the state. Building healthier cities by reviving walkable downtowns just doesn’t align with the governor’s infrastructure message.

Easy motoring on the Thruway, however, is a great fit. “There won’t be a toll increase,” Cuomo said, “because we want that traffic and we want that volume to continue.”

  • Alex

    There are so many reasons to hate Cuomo. I think the biggest one is that his pandering and BS spewing work.

  • Andrew

    I’m depressed.

  • Mark Walker

    How to lie with pictures: Talk about garages while picturing transit-oriented development. Wow. Glad I voted for the Green Party candidate.

  • BBnet3000

    About the worst the city could hope for. This is his way of setting himself up for his Presidential run, which will fail btw.

  • Bolwerk

    Paper promises. The new garages go in places that are fiercely NIMBY. They’ll fight, and probably win. Toll hikes on the Thruway will happen sooner or later regardless, maybe later if Cuomo manages to steal the settlement money and put it toward the TZB or throughway. If the LaGuardia plan can even reach financial feasibility, it is likely to be tanked by NIMBYs too.

    It’s ugly, but it’s scarcely uglier than it was yesterday, or before the election.

  • HamTech87

    Meanwhile, Cuomo is incredibly popular in NYC. City residents don’t realize how they’re subsidizing projects like the TZ Bridge.

    Watch Cuomo become even more popular among liberals in the next year. With a Republican-controlled State Senate, he can use more liberal rhetoric and be assured that none of it will be realized. It is just for presidential primary voters.

    Here’s Cuomo polling at 71% in the city:

  • BBnet3000

    The Governor Gotham deserves.

  • Larry Littlefield

    He hasn’t failed to say it until he failed to say it.

    But if he does’t talk about the pain needed to pay for the MTA capital plan the reality is this. The last one expired, and there isn’t any. We are in deferred maintenance.

    And I’m pretty sure that never happened before since the first capital plan — one expired without a new one in place. Then again the MTA just kept borrowing before. Now that it has reached to point where there is little future left to be sold, the shrewd political move is just to refuse to discuss the reality and let the system collapse.

    Where is the plan from that man of the people Jim Brennan? You get the idea.

    You see the same thing over in New Jersey, where Chris Christie refuses to deal with either the pension fund he inherited, or the bankrupt transportation trust fund he inherited, by making current and future state residents sacrifice to pay for what Generation Greed did.

    Generation Greed was followed by Generation Apathy. That is what they are counting on.

  • Sad Citizen


    The AirTrain proposal is the very definitiion of a white elephant. It will be slower and more expensive than existing transit options. Nobody will ride it.

  • Sad Citizen

    This is the worst conceived project NYC has seen since… moving Javits to the Aqueduct.

  • walknseason

    No surprise here: the fake libs that didn’t vote for Teachout get exactly what they deserve, a corporate hack who gives lip service to EZ-liberal ideas.

  • Bolwerk

    “In every American community there are varying shades of political
    opinion. One of the shadiest of these is the liberals. An outspoken
    group on many subjects, ten degrees to the left of center in good times,
    ten degrees to the right of center if it affects them personally.” – Phil Ochs

    Explains just about every “liberal” New York politician, including Cuomo and de Blasio.

  • Bolwerk

    Meh. Be realistic. There really aren’t transit options for many LGA riders – anyone with lots of luggage – and it’ll probably get ridden the way AirTrain JFK gets ridden.

    What’s galling about it is the opportunity cost. The alignment isn’t even that bad for a one-seat ride, but it’s horrible for a two-seat ride. The money could go to something better, like the Astoria extension, and serve far more people.

  • Bobberooni

    I agree, looks dubious. Problem is, you have to go way out of your way on the 7 train before circling back on the AirTrain. Which will make it more likely that other existing options will be faster.

    My favorite way to LGA is to take the N train to Grand Central Parkway. Then catch a yellow cab heading for the Triborough Bridge, turn it around, and head right to LGA. Total trip time, 45 minutes from midtown. Cost: ~$8 cab fare plus $2.50 subway.


Cuomo Barely Mentions Transit in 2013 Agenda

Tuning in to this afternoon’s State of the State address, you could be forgiven for forgetting that New York depends on the nation’s largest transit system — a system burdened by debt and ravaged by Hurricane Sandy, which is in desperate need of leadership from the governor. Between the inside political jokes and grand pronouncements, […]