Chin Asks de Blasio to Choose Affordable Housing Over Cheap Parking

Council Member Margaret Chin has set up a simple choice for Mayor Bill de Blasio: Which is the higher priority, affordable housing or cheap parking?

DOT owns 39 parking lots and garages in all five boroughs. Many of them could be affordable housing sites, if Mayor de Blasio follows through on his plan. Image: DOT
DOT owns 39 parking lots and garages in all five boroughs. Many of them could be affordable housing, if Mayor de Blasio decides to prioritize housing over car storage. Image: DOT

In a letter to Transportation Commissioner Polly Trottenberg first reported by the Wall Street Journal [PDF], Chin urged the de Blasio administration to redevelop the city-owned parking garage on Ludlow Street in the Lower East Side, calling it a “great opportunity for the development of affordable housing” in an area with “an urgent need for more.”

According to an analysis by the City Council’s land use division, it could accommodate 89 housing units under current zoning.

Chin’s request comes two months after de Blasio released his affordable housing plan, which singled out municipal parking lots as a type of city-owned property ripe for affordable housing development.

The Department of Housing Preservation and Development is charged with coming up with a list of suitable city-owned properties. Last month, an HPD spokesperson said the effort was in the early stages and it was still reaching out to other agencies. The department offered a similar line today.

After an event in May, I asked Trottenberg whether DOT would get out of the parking lot business to help the mayor achieve the his affordable housing goals. “It’s too soon to say,” she said. “I can’t pre-judge that now.” Trottenberg would only say that DOT is “ready to do whatever we can to help,” including creating an inventory of its developable properties.

DOT has not replied to questions today about Chin’s proposal to redevelop the Ludlow Street garage, but did tell the Journal that it “serves a significant community need for parking” and is undergoing a $5.8 million renovation.

The garage is is one of 39 DOT-managed garages and lots, accounting for more than 8,100 spaces citywide. Many of those municipal lots offer cheap parking well below the going rate. The Ludlow Street garage, for example, charges $4.50 for the first hour and $2 for each additional hour. Nearby garages start at $10 for the first hour.

Which will the city subsidize: car storage or housing? The decision on the Lower East Side should be an easy one, but it’s been overlooked before, by the Bloomberg administration, and de Blasio could repeat that mistake.

The garage site was originally included in EDC’s Seward Park development plan, which is set to bring 1,000 new housing units, half designated as permanently affordable, to long-fallow lots in the area. But in 2012, the Bloomberg administration redrew the project’s boundaries to exclude the site and its 356 parking spaces. The Seward Park project already included 500 parking spaces, more than what would have been allowed if the neighborhood’s zoning rules had applied to the site.

During the Bloomberg administration, EDC and the Department of City Planning tended to pile on the parking, often in an effort to mollify potential critics of new development. So far, de Blasio and his deputies have not shown much interest in shifting that approach. Chin’s request offers one opportunity to change course.

“We must consider taking advantage of any site that could be appropriate for [affordable housing],” Chin wrote. “With a new administration in office, I would like to know if DOT’s position remains the same regarding this site.”

This post has been updated with a response from HPD.

  • Jeff

    Affordable Car Housing is a central pillar of Vision Zero Reduction in Parking

  • walks bikes drives

    And who is it that gets these discounted spaces?

    If the city has extra land laying around that they don’t have the plans drawn up for its use yet, it is not a horrible idea to TEMPORARILY use it as a parking resource, but they should charge market rate and be developed as soon as the plans are ready. We can use that space for affordable housing, or for schools, or for parks. There are enough private garages around, that if you don’t want to park on the street, you can find a spot. And the city doesn’t have to subsidize those spots for people who don’t need them.

  • Maggie

    “Please don’t take it [city-run, taxpayer-subsidized garage] away. I’d have nowhere to park,” said Liz Morrison, a Staten Island teacher who was [parked] in the [taxpayer-subsidized garage in the Lower East Side] on a recent weekday for her hair cut. “I will chain myself to this garage.”

    Wow. Kudos to WSJ reporter Laura Kusisto for this jawdropping quote.

  • StepUpAndSaySomething

    This is a great idea. I just hope the make the outdoor area into parkland instead of useless lawns. If drivers don’t want to pay market rates to store their luxury transportation, then they can take the train like the rest of us.

  • Danny G

    Rather than transferring the property to a different agency, I feel that it would be in the city’s interest to turn some of the DOT-run parking lots into places to learn bicycling and driving in a simulated urban setting ( like this: )

  • Jeff

    Outside of the core, maybe. But does this type of facility really make sense in the Lower East Side?

  • hidden agenda

    And who does Margaret Chin see as a top candidate to develop affordable housing on Ludlow? Maybe Asian Americans for Equality — the organization she used to work for? (And, after this term in office, maybe the organization she goes back to). Politicians always have a hidden agenda.

  • Danny G

    If the percent of kids in the LES who would like to learn how to bike in traffic is similar to that of kids in non-core neighborhoods, then yes.

    I wouldn’t recommend tearing down the garage to make a single-level park. I would simply repurpose the garage as a multi-level traffic park. (I’d even add ground level retail and 10 stories of apartments on top to finance the whole shebang, but I digress.)

  • Eric McClure

    The city is spending $16,292 per parking space to renovate the garage?

    Damned bike lanes.

  • JoshNY

    Even so, it doesn’t make it a bad idea to turn subsidized parking into affordable housing.

  • linstur

    First of all, GREAT IDEA.

    Second, make it MICRO HOUSING. We are ignoring that there is an awesome, market-driven solution to create affordable units — not through subsidies, but through the market — developers and even citizens building smaller and therefore much more affordable units. Seattle is exploding with them — and people love them. You have a micro-unit studio with a full kitchen and hang-out area on your floor to watch a show, cook a big meal with friends, and bond with neighbors. The price? $800 a month and under. Liberals tend to be enamored with the government spending money to help (I am a liberal and I agree – especially health care). But we all know the tragedy of housing projects — just watch The Wire. The government doesn’t have the steadiness and decades-long commitment to keep buildings up. But the market DOES. If landlords need to rent their units they will keep them up and make them desirable.

    The best thing this administration could do is to PRE-ZONE lots for micro-housing units. A small lot in Seattle that housed a dilapidated single-family home housed 64 micro-units. NYC is the place for this — because everyone agrees you do NOT need a car. By pre-zoning lots, small investors and builders and non-profits can jump into the game. Why are developers the only people doing affordable housing? Let everyone get into the game!

    More info:


Chin Urges Council Colleagues to Turn Parking Into Affordable Housing

Last month, Manhattan City Council Member Margaret Chin asked the de Blasio administration to prioritize affordable housing over car storage by replacing a city-owned parking garage in her district with new apartments. Acknowledging that the decision might be politically difficult, last week Chin urged her City Council colleagues to follow her lead if they want to tackle […]

Will Michael Schlein Stop NYC EDC From Subsidizing Parking?

This morning, Mayor Bill de Blasio announced the appointment of Michael Schlein as chair of the city’s Economic Development Corporation. Schlein, a Wall Street insider with close ties to the mayor, joins EDC President Kyle Kimball atop the agency’s leadership. EDC has a terrible track record of subsidizing parking garages and overseeing mega-projects with acres of excess parking. The […]

A Proposal for Incremental Parking Reform in NYC

In most of New York City, zoning requirements compel new development to include a certain amount of parking. These mandates make housing more expensive while causing more traffic and pollution, but the Department of City Planning took only the most timid steps to reform them during the Bloomberg administration, and the de Blasio administration isn’t shaping up […]