Senate Joins Assembly in Rejecting Cuomo’s $40 Million Transit Raid

This week kicked off with news that Speaker Sheldon Silver would remove Governor Andrew Cuomo’s $40 million transit raid from the Assembly’s budget plan. Today comes word [PDF] that the State Senate has followed suit, rejecting the transit raid in its own budget resolution.

Photo: Matt Wade via Wikipedia
Photo: Matt Wade via Wikipedia

A united front from the Senate and Assembly provides a boost to advocates as the legislature begins two weeks of negotiations with Cuomo over the final budget, which covers a fiscal year beginning April 1.

It’s also a step up from last year, when a $20 million raid was rejected by the Senate but remained in the Assembly’s resolution and was included in the final budget. “We have a much stronger hand going into the negotiations [this year],” said Nadine Lemmon of Tri-State Transportation Campaign.

The governor’s office has claimed that this budget maneuver does not count as a raid because it’s taking taxes dedicated to MTA operations and diverting it to service debt that funds MTA capital needs. But Comptroller Tom DiNapoli calls it a transit raid, and advocates point out that it reneges on a commitment the state made over a decade ago and shifts funds away from the MTA to effectively create new money on the state’s balance sheet.

Even if the $40 million transit raid is removed from this year’s budget, Cuomo is likely to attempt similar moves in the future to pay off the state bond with MTA funds. His financial plan includes annual raids of $20 million, which would total nearly $350 million by 2031.

“Three hundred and fifty million dollars is a big chunk of change. You can’t bleed the authority in that manner and expect them to perform,” Lemmon said.

Another one of the governor’s hits to MTA revenues is also having ripple effects in the Senate. Cuomo’s plan to deepen Verrazano-Narrows Bridge toll discounts for truckers and Staten Island residents would cost $14 million annually, with the MTA and the state splitting the cost evenly. That kicked off a flurry of press releases and events by Brooklyn legislators angling for a discount for their constituents, too.

Now, they’re using the Senate budget plan to call on the MTA to study and recommend VNB toll discounts for non-Staten Island residents who drive over the bridge. Wholesale reform of New York’s broken toll system, as the state begins to figure out how to fund the MTA’s next multi-billion dollar capital plan, is not on Albany’s agenda.

  • Brownstone

    I don’t understand why there is Republican primary? We already have a republican governor. I’m just wondering who the Democrats will be running against this Cuomo guy.

  • guest

    Does anyone else think Cuomo is trying to woo Republicans by lowering taxes and tolls, not supporting transit properly, so he can claim a “bipartisan”, centrist appeal? Cuomo’s behavior in the last few years makes me think he’ll run for president after Hillary, and he’s laying the groundwork right now. He’s going for the bipartisan / centrist approach, a lot like Christie. Except Cuomo is actually selling out and betraying his core constituencies, treating NY State as just a step on the way to a higher office.

  • neroden

    That’s what I’m wondering too.

  • neroden

    It’s an idiotic idea. Cuomo would easily lose NY. He’s making major enemies already.

  • SFrankel

    With any luck, and if there’s any justice, he’ll be as successful in his presidential run ast Joe Lieberman.

  • Joe R.

    Maybe the Capitol building should be sold to refund the money taken from transit? That building looks like it would fetch a pretty penny on the open market. Considering the job these people are doing, I have zero problems if they have to convene the legislature in tents in a parking lot. That’s about all they deserve.

  • Train rider

    I would like to see Cuomo ride metro north and ride the train to Albany. He seems very out of touch to the average New Yorker who utlizes mass transit. This is what happens when you get chauffered around.


Final Budget Deal Does Not Add to Cuomo’s Transit Raid [Updated]

The final budget agreement reached by Albany leadership will not make additional cuts to transit funding, a state budget division spokesperson confirmed this afternoon. Negotiations with the legislature did not ultimately change the total amount of transit funding from Andrew Cuomo’s executive budget, which raided $100 million from dedicated transit funds. During budget negotiations, it […]

Cuomo Gets His Way, and Transit Riders Get the Shaft

Governor Andrew Cuomo won’t be denied. Overriding proposals from the Assembly and State Senate, the governor continues to pick the pocket of New York City’s transit system, diverting $30 million from the MTA in the state budget. Cuomo had originally proposed a $40 million raid, so it could have been worse. But because this diversion […]