CB 12 Committee Endorses Ped Improvements at Chaotic Inwood Intersection

Left turn bans and added pedestrian space proposed for Broadway, Dyckman Street and Riverside Drive. Image: DOT. Click to enlarge

Long-awaited improvements to a hazardous Broadway crossing in Inwood could be implemented next year, if Community Board 12 passes a resolution that cleared the board’s transportation committee this week.

The committee and around 50 residents gathered Monday night to hear DOT’s proposals for the intersection of Broadway, Dyckman/200th Street and Riverside Drive [PDF], where pedestrians must negotiate long crosswalks and signals that force them to look out for drivers coming from different directions simultaneously. In addition to local traffic, the intersection is consistently clogged by motorists headed to and from the West Side Highway and those who drive through Inwood to avoid tolls on the Henry Hudson Bridge.

There were 128 crashes at the intersection from 2010 to 2012, DOT said, resulting in injuries to three cyclists, five pedestrians, and 10 vehicle occupants. Thirty-five pedestrians and cyclists were injured there between 1996 and 2009, according to Transportation Alternatives’ CrashStat.

DOT’s suggested remedy is a relatively simple mix of turn bans, signalization tweaks, new signage, and enhancements to pedestrian space. DOT would prohibit left turns from northbound Broadway onto Dyckman and Riverside, left turns from Dyckman to southbound Broadway, left turns from southbound Broadway to Dyckman, and U-turns from Riverside to Dyckman. DOT proposes to add paint or concrete to two pedestrian islands on the west side of the intersection, and to extend the curb on the southeast corner. These alterations would shorten crossing distances and eliminate conflicts between pedestrians and turning drivers at the west and south crosswalks.

Currently pedestrians must look out for motorists approaching from different directions simultaneously. Photo: DOT

Alternate routes for motorists would be marked with new signage. DOT staff said peak hour counts showed that the impact on residential streets, where auto traffic would be directed, would be minimal. Still, objections to the plan centered mostly on diverting traffic to narrower streets that are lined with apartment buildings.

Several locals said the plan should take into account the overwhelming number of drivers who are drawn to the area by La Marina, a restaurant and nightclub at the west end of Dyckman Street that offers valet parking. Maria Luna, former CB 12 chair and current board member, and resident Bryan Davis yelled for a while about how the turn bans would make it more difficult to drive in the neighborhood, especially since Broadway is usually lined with double-parked vehicles.

DOT Manhattan Borough Commissioner Margaret Forgione said longer green signals for Broadway and Riverside traffic would mean less congestion on Broadway. DOT staff and committee member Elizabeth Lorris-Ritter also noted that the plan is intended to address pedestrian safety at the intersection, and won’t solve all of the area’s traffic problems.

Other residents who spoke hoped the plan would be enough to make the intersection safer for pedestrians, many of whom cross there with children on the way to and from nearby playgrounds and Fort Tryon Park. Streetsblog reader Jonathan Rabinowitz questioned why the proposal, which has been in the works for at least two years, was so long in the making. “We have not neglected this community board,” replied Forgione.

DOT has made street improvements in Inwood and Washington Heights in recent years, and Inwood was selected for Manhattan’s first Slow Zone. But the Broadway/Dyckman/Riverside intersection is one of the most heavily trafficked in Inwood, and one of the most dangerous.

Last spring DOT proposed a number of bike lanes concentrated in Washington Heights, one of them to be protected by parked cars, two years after CB 12 asked the agency to study ways to “[connect] existing bike lanes and [create] safe ways for cyclists to move uptown, downtown, and across town.” Meanwhile, DOT traded bike lanes for sharrows on one Inwood street, and removed a bike shelter on Dyckman. A citizen-generated proposal for a protected bike lane on Dyckman Street, connecting the east- and westside greenways, has languished for over five years.

When a resident asked about increasing the amount of time pedestrians have to cross Broadway on the north side of Dyckman, DOT staff said it could only be considered if signal times were shortened at other crossings.

Residents at the meeting voted in favor of the proposal, and the board unanimously approved a resolution in support. The committee added clauses concerning NYPD’s lack of enforcement against speeding and double parking, a request for red light cameras, and auto traffic related to La Marina. The reso requests that DOT follow up with traffic count data on the alternate motorist routes. If CB 12 approves the resolution at its next meeting, set for November 26, DOT could get started on the project next March.

After the room had for the most part cleared, DOT previewed changes at another Broadway intersection south of Dyckman, at Nagle and Bennett Avenues, where DOT would use concrete sidewalk extensions to shorten crossing distances and square up “soft” right turns. DOT plans to eliminate an existing Barnes Dance crossing phase, so pedestrians would have to look out for turning drivers. DOT staff said signals would be timed to facilitate more vehicle turns from Nagle to Broadway.

The proposal would add eight parking spaces, a feature that brought applause from committee members, who endorsed the plan unanimously.

  • JamesR

    This is good to hear, since that intersection is a death trap for anyone not in a vehicle. I’ve always hated riding through here. With that said, there needs to be a long term solution to the issue of toll-beaters in this area, as they are responsible for a huge amount of vehicle traffic in this corridor. Could tolling the Broadway Bridge be in the cards someday? With cashless toll technology, it could be done seamlessly.

  • BornAgainBicyclist

    Badly needed for that sh!tshow intersection, so that’s good news. You have to be very assertive as a pedestrian to get across Riverside and Dyckman. As with so many similar intersections, it’s rare for drivers turning right from B’way onto Dyckman or Riverside to yield the right of way to peds crossing with the light.

    But the applause for the addition of what I presume will be free parking at the other location mentioned. . . . ugh.

  • BornAgainBicyclist

    Yes, it seems clear that a huge majority of traffic coming through Seaman is toll-dodgers. It would really quiet the area down and would probably help the La Marina issues as a side effect to toll B’way and the 207th Street Bridge.

  • Streetsblog Reader Jonathan R

    Thanks, Brad, for quoting me!

    To elaborate at greater length, this is weak tea from DOT. The Sherman Creek Inwood Traffic Study was three years ago, and if you look at slides 15 and 16 from the presentation then, the problems were the same. It’s available on the city’s website at:


    I guess counting the 12 pedestrian and 6 bike injuries from 2005 to 2007 was not enough to persuade DOT to do anything right then, instead we have waited for improvements for three years, during which 18 more people were injured. No, those dozen and a half people weren’t killed outright, but I have read enough reporting on Streetsblog to realize that injuries caused by traffic crashes have real and lasting effects.

    The city could have put up turn restrictions promptly in 2010, and it would have forestalled my neighbors’ chief complaint, which is that these changes do not take into effect the many people who drive to the nightclub at the west end of Dyckman Street, which opened IIRC in the summer of 2012.

    Foot-dragging by DOT doesn’t prevent injuries, it doesn’t make streets safer, it doesn’t please residents, and it doesn’t add parking spots. Deputy Commissioner Forgione and her boss, Commissioner Sadik-Khan, knew this intersection was dangerous, and they did nothing. Cathie Black could have done a better job.

  • That would probably just move the problems further south. To be effective, every Harlem River crossing needs to be tolled.

  • Seriously, all it takes to get applause and unanimous approval is eight (8) parking spots?! Give me a break! The entire island of Manhattan desperately needs to abandon the failed concept of free on-street parking.

  • öøøπ

    I can’t count the number of times I’ve been nearly hit by people southbound on broadway turning right onto riverside here. The angle of the turn means that drivers take that turn at >30 mph without looking for pedestrians (who are crossing with the light).

  • There is a general lawlessness on the parts of many drivers. Red light running and cars cutting in front of others as well as turning cars challenging pedestrians at this intersection have been this way for years. Stationing a permanent officer to enforce laws would bring in far more money than it would cost.And I am the citizen who proposed the protected bike lane on Dyckman, complete with diagrams and descriptions at CB12 in Feb. 2008.

  • Guest

    So this never happened. Anybody know why?


CB 12 Endorses Pedestrian Improvements for Broadway at Dyckman in Inwood

Manhattan Community Board 12 last night endorsed proposed improvements to a hazardous Broadway intersection in Inwood. At Broadway at Dyckman/200th Street and Riverside Drive, pedestrians currently must negotiate long crossings while watching for drivers coming from different directions simultaneously. There were 128 crashes at the intersection from 2010 to 2012, according to DOT, resulting in injuries to three […]

City Shows Inwood Some Much-Needed Livable Streets Love

It’s no exaggeration to say that, by and large, the streets of Inwood are a free-for-all. With its two free Harlem River bridges, the neighborhood is a prime cut-through for toll-shopping drivers passing to and from the Bronx and Westchester, and is a seasonal haven for preening boom-car owners and speeding motorcyclists. Wide intersections and […]

DOT: Improvements to Broadway at Dyckman Street Coming in May

DOT should begin work next month on long-awaited improvements to a dangerous Broadway intersection in Inwood. Pedestrians are forced to negotiate long crossings while watching for drivers coming from different directions simultaneously where Broadway meets Dyckman/200th Street and Riverside Drive. There were 128 crashes there from 2010 to 2012, resulting in injuries to three cyclists, five pedestrians, and […]

DOT Plans Safer St. Nick @ Amsterdam, With More Uptown Action to Come

Northbound cyclists on St. Nicholas at Amsterdam will have to negotiate a dogleg to reach the parking-protected lane. The southbound lane, at left, will be opposite a row of back-in angled parking. The speckled blue areas indicate new pedestrian space. At a Monday night meeting with the transportation committee of Manhattan Community Board 12, DOT […]

Tonight: Upper Manhattanites Finally Get to Talk About Bike Lanes

After years of delays, a citizen-generated plan for a separated bike path in Upper Manhattan will get an audience tonight. The Dyckman Greenway Connector would, as the name suggests, link the east- and west-side Greenways a short distance from the northern tip of Manhattan, in Inwood, completing an uptown circuit for commuters and recreational riders. […]