TA: NYPD Enforcement Priorities Don’t Match Its Own Street Safety Data

Only nine precincts, in yellow and green, issued more tickets for speeding than excessive window tint in 2011. NYPD has defended window tint summonses on traffic safety grounds, even though its own crash reports do not support that argument. Map: ##http://transalt.org/files/news/reports/2013/The_Enforcement_Gap.pdf##Transportation Alternatives##

Yesterday, Transportation Alternatives released a report [PDF] highlighting the mismatch between what causes fatal and serious crashes, according to NYPD crash reports, and what police choose to prioritize when it comes to traffic enforcement.

The report lists some statistics to illustrate the public safety crisis on the city’s streets: One New Yorker suffers a traffic-related injury every eight minutes, has a traffic-related injury resulting in permanent disability or disfigurement every three hours, and is killed in a car crash every 33 hours. Nearly a third of New Yorkers know someone who has been seriously injured or killed in a crash. Motor vehicle crashes are the top cause of injury-related death for NYC children, and number two for seniors.

These crashes are caused by rule violations that, if enforced, could prevent crashes from occurring, the report says. Six in 10 crashes are caused by a driver who committed at least one traffic violation, with half of those crashes involving speeding or failure to yield to a pedestrian. Speeding drivers are the top cause of fatal crashes, killing more New Yorkers than drunk drivers or drivers on cell phones combined.

But instead of focusing on local streets where pedestrians are most vulnerable and speeding is rampant, 73 percent of speeding summonses in 2012 were issued by the NYPD Highway Unit, and 66 of 76 precincts issued less than one speeding summons a day.

Failure to yield to pedestrians was the leading cause of crashes resulting in injuries in 2011, but on average, NYPD precincts issued fewer than 12 failure to yield summonses each month last year, the report says.

Instead, NYPD has other traffic enforcement priorities: The department issued 24,900 tickets for defective headlights last year, meaning that precincts issued twice as many defective headlight summonses as they did for failure to yield. Defective headlights led to zero fatal crashes and 12 crashes with injury in 2011.

The department issued even more tickets for excessive window tint, writing a total of 95,866 summonses last year, with 70 percent of precincts writing up at least one window tint violation a day. At a City Council hearing on NYPD traffic safety policies last month, Deputy Chief John Cassidy, executive officer of the transportation bureau, made a traffic safety argument for tinted window violations. “These people with the heavily tinted windows are not seeing pedestrians or bicyclists,” he said. NYPD’s own numbers belie that argument: In 2011, officers did not cite tinted windows in any fatal or injury-causing crashes.

The report says there are some precincts that are models for reform, but the department at large has not adopted these changes. The 26th, 28th and 32nd precincts in Upper Manhattan increased the number of speeding summonses by 1,500 percent from 2011 to 2012, while the 40th, 42nd and 47th precincts in the Bronx increased the number of failure to yield summonses by 547 percent over the same period.

With less than three months left in the Bloomberg administration, Transportation Alternatives is looking to the next mayor to change the NYPD’s traffic safety policies. “Just as our city has made it a priority to tackle gun violence,” executive director Paul Steely White said in a statement, “The next mayor needs a serious plan to address traffic injuries and deaths.”

  • Anonymous

    This is a VERY shocking stat, and it would be great to have streets where drivers are not speeding especially in busy pedestrians areas, but this certainly isn’t the case.
    I don’t know how their crash data is calculated, e.g. with a pedestrian injury, are the phone records subpoenaed and any sending/receiving calls/texts checked?? with all pedestrian incidents is the (level of) window tinting accounted for? I doubt it. Even if tickets are issued, this data may very well not make it into a crash report. We just had a cyclist fatality here and after FOILing the “Accident” Report, I saw no mention of checking whether the mobile phone was checked/records subpoenaed, which should be automatic and recorded in the report, whether or not such electronics played a role.
    Certainly speed kills, but I’m not convinced that police should stop ticketing for tinting, or that the data is even very accurate.
    Using window tinting makes it harder for a) law enforcement and others to know when people are texting/talking or just distracted drivers and b) pedestrians and cyclists sometimes make use of widows, especially for large vehicles to preview what is coming on the other side–looking through the truck, or making eye contact with the driver through windshield or side windows.

  • Danny G

    Gonna nitpick here – the legend in that map confused me. I’d change “<10x".. to "2x-10x..", to clarify that numerically speaking, the red precincts are in between gray and orange. Maybe even break the legend into two chunks, to clarify the "speeding-oriented" and "tinted-window" oriented precincts. But nice job getting this map out.

  • Anonymous

    Right, had to figure that out.


TA Outlines a Traffic Enforcement Strategy as NYPD Feels the Heat

Following up on its report highlighting NYPD’s lack of meaningful traffic enforcement and a street safety forum featuring former police commissioner Bill Bratton, Transportation Alternatives released a report yesterday [PDF] outlining case studies of effective traffic enforcement. The report gives Mayor-elect Bill de Blasio and his next police commissioner a broad strategy to help achieve de Blasio’s […]

NYPD Crash Data Now Easier to Use and Updated Daily

The city went live with a major upgrade to NYPD’s crash data today. Information about traffic crashes was previously released via difficult-to-use monthly updates posted on the police department’s website. Now it’s available through a standardized feed updated daily on the city’s open data portal, allowing the public to sort crashes by time of day, […]

Transportation Alternatives Launches Probe Into NYPD Crash Investigations

Transportation Alternatives today delivered over 2,500 citizen letters to Ray Kelly demanding that NYPD crack down on dangerous driving, and announced a comprehensive probe into how the department handles traffic crash investigations. Flanked by dozens of supporters and victims of traffic violence at 1 Police Plaza, TA executive director Paul Steely White excoriated NYPD for […]

Vision Zero: Where Do We Go From Here?

John Petro is a policy analyst for New York City affairs and the co-author of “Vision Zero: How Safer Streets in New York City Can Save More Than 100 Lives a Year.” Mayor Bill de Blasio released his administration’s Vision Zero Action Plan earlier this week, following up on a high-profile campaign promise just six […]