While PBA Obstructs Speed Cams, DC Police Union Shows Support

Although maintaining that cameras “are never going to be a replacement for officers,” a prominent police union official told Streetsblog that he strongly supports automated enforcement. “People drive in this town with impunity,” he said. “I’ll take any help we can get at this point to try and reign in some of the problems.”

Without enough officers to pull over speeding drivers, one police union leader says automated enforcement is needed. Photo: ##http://www.flickr.com/photos/33080709@N08/4707991462/##ynkefan1/Twitter##

Unfortunately for New Yorkers, those words came not from Patrolmen’s Benevolent Association President Pat Lynch, but from Kristopher Baumann, Chairman of the Fraternal Order of Police for the Metropolitan Police Department in Washington, DC.

In fact, the DC police union has been a strong supporter of the entire automated enforcement program in the District, which also targets red-light running, blocking the box, failing to yield to pedestrians in crosswalks, and failure to observe stop signs.

At a DC Council hearing last November, Baumann testified against the council’s efforts to lower fines for violators caught on camera. He implored the council “not to pander to a bunch of people that can’t control themselves behind the wheel and think it’s okay to endanger others.”

Baumann had tough words for people who oppose traffic enforcement cameras. “If they don’t like the automated cameras, follow the rules. Stop endangering other people,” he said. “The idea here is not ‘gotcha’ and we’re going to charge money. It is public safety,” he added. “These cameras do work.”

Since installing speed cameras, DC has seen an 82 percent reduction in speeding that exceeds 10 mph above the limit, according to Richard Retting, the director of safety and research for Sam Schwartz Engineering. Since DC began installing speed cameras, the number of annual traffic fatalities has dropped from 72 in 2001 to 19 last year — a decline of about 74 percent. In 2011, MPD Police Chief Cathy L. Lanier received an award from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration for overseeing the nation’s biggest traffic fatality rate drop. In NYC, which has 150 red light cameras but no speed cameras, traffic deaths fell 30 percent in the same period.

The DC police union supports speed cams, according to Baumann, because MPD doesn’t have enough manpower to enforce traffic laws without the automated help. “We’re not out there to enforce the laws, and when that happens, people start disregarding the laws,” Baumann told the council. “That means we have to rely on the cameras.”

When Streetsblog asked if he thought the cameras were being used as an excuse not to hire needed officers, Baumann was unequivocal. “No,” he said. “I don’t think that it’s being used as an excuse.”

Baumann wouldn’t go so far as to question the opposition of his New York counterparts to speed cams. “This is one of these odd positions where I think the PBA is correct, but I also think we’re correct,” he said, noting that DC does not have a dedicated traffic unit and that while some MPD districts have officers dedicated to traffic enforcement, most do not.

But while NYPD has a Transportation Bureau, which issues the majority of the city’s speeding tickets, most are issued along highways, not local streets. NYPD trains only one officer per precinct to operate a speed gun.

Up in Albany, State Senators Marty Golden and Simcha Felder continue to oppose speed cameras, while Senate Co-Leader Jeff Klein said he wants the cameras approved this year. Golden, who is strongly associated with the PBA, has introduced legislation to deflect attention from his opposition to the speed camera bill. The bill, which will never pass, would compel NYC DOT to install school zone signage and traffic calming, and does not address speed enforcement. Needless to say, at this point DOT doesn’t need legislative coercion to redesign streets for greater safety, but New Yorkers do need Albany to step up and enable the city to save lives with automated enforcement, just like DC has.

  • NYPD devotes nearly zero resources to speeding. So how can cameras be a “replacement” to something that doesn’t exist?

  • Mark Walker

    “If they don’t like the automated cameras, follow the rules. Stop endangering other people.” Bingo.

  • KillMoto

    This is why DC gets my tourism dollars and NYC does not

  • Larry Littlefield

    No police officer likes giving tickets. Aside from the late night hours, where those stopped for traffic violations may be dangerous, civil enforcement like this should be handled by automation or others, the brownies for example.

    So we go from 2 1/2 times the national ratio of cops to people to just double. That will not be a problem for the cops, although it might reduce the revenues of the union.

  • ceefer

    Not surprised to hear the DC police union is just wet over cameras. Saves their lazy butts a lot of work.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Pat Lynch Makes the Case for Automated Traffic Enforcement

|
If there’s one thing to glean from the story of Joseph Spina — the NYPD officer who got caught on tape telling a motorist, “Mayor de Blasio wants us to give out summonses, okay?” — it’s that NYC needs more automated traffic enforcement. Whatever you think of NYPD’s decision to suspend Spina without pay, the incident has brought to the surface the […]

Looks Like Marty Golden Is Holding Up Speed Cameras, Again

|
Dana Rubinstein at Capital New York reports that State Senator Marty Golden has again emerged as an obstacle to NYC speed cameras. On Monday the Assembly passed a bill that would allow the city to deploy 120 additional cameras, bringing the total to 140. We reported yesterday that the allocation of speed camera revenue was a […]

Albany to Consider Bus Lane Enforcement Legislation

|
Bus-ted! In London, automated enforcement has led to significant improvements in bus service. A package of legislation recently introduced in the state legislature would help speed New York City buses and enable traffic agents to cite drivers for blocking the box. Members of the Campaign for New York’s Future, the same coalition that fought for […]