What Happens to an Injured Crash Victim After Police and the Press Move On

Every day some 40 pedestrians are wounded by drivers in NYC. Victims are often left with serious injuries, but rarely is the public made aware of anything beyond the basic immediate circumstances of a crash — where it occurred, the condition of the victims when transported from the scene, and whether the driver was (a) intoxicated or (b) immediately cleared of wrongdoing by NYPD.

Shirley Shea was struck by a school bus driver on the Upper West Side in February 2012. She died last December.

Injury-causing crashes are so common that, even if they wanted to, the city’s innumerable media outlets would have difficulty reporting them all, much less keep up with the story of each victim’s recovery, or eventual death. In the words of “Killed by Automobile” [PDF], the seminal 1999 report on city traffic fatalities, these incidents “flicker briefly across the city’s consciousness and then flutter away, leaving in their wake only grieving families and friends.”

Susan Shea-Klot is the daughter of Shirley Shea, who was struck by the driver of a yellow school bus on the Upper West Side on February 17, 2012. Media coverage was scant. Shea’s name was not cited in the only report we could find, a brief WABC item that seems to exist only because the crash happened near the station’s studio.

A woman was struck by a school bus Friday afternoon on the Upper West Side.

It happened around 4 p.m. at the intersection of 67th Street and Columbus Avenue, right outside the Eyewitness News studio.

The victim was rushed to St. Luke’s Roosevelt Hospital by ambulance.

She is said to have serious head and leg injuries.

Shea, 78, was indeed seriously hurt. She died on December 7, after 10 months in the hospital, during which time she was largely incapacitated and unable to speak.

The collision that killed Shea was notated as a pedestrian injury by the 20th Precinct in the February 2012 NYPD crash report, along with two other incidents at the same intersection. According to Shea-Klot, the driver was not charged by NYPD or Manhattan District Attorney Cy Vance. “The district attorney’s office never contacted my father or anyone in my family,” says Shea-Klot.

This crash was one of an untold number of cases where a pedestrian or cyclist suffers fatal injuries, but a death is not reported by the press. It’s also one of thousands of crashes that happen every year in which a victim and loved ones are left to deal with the terrible life-altering consequences of an act of recklessness by a motorist who is free to keep driving. And since Shea lived for months, it is unlikely that the crash was investigated by the NYPD Accident Investigation Squad.

We learned of her mother’s death from a comment posted by Shea-Klot, who was kind enough to provide us with an account of her mother’s life, including the agony she and her family endured after the crash. We originally planned to publish passages from this account, but it is so eloquent and moving that we decided to run it verbatim. It appears in full after the jump.

My mother, Shirley Shea, was treated with great kindness and professionalism by the responders to the accident. As you know, she was struck by a privately owned yellow school bus as she was crossing 67th street at Columbus Ave with the light, only a block away from her home on February 17, 2012. The bus driver turned right onto 67th from Columbus and struck her with the rear wheel, knocking her down and rolling over her left foot and leg. Unfortunately, no one was with her at the time of the accident. My father, who lives across the street on 66th Street and Columbus, did not hear of the accident until she was already en route to St. Luke’s Roosevelt Hospital on 114th St. When my father arrived at the hospital she was being treated in the emergency room. Police investigators were questioning her, and she was able to answer all their questions despite severe injuries to her foot, lower leg and head. My father reports that the investigators stayed with my mother and treated her very kindly, going out of their way to help her.

As to the investigation, according to my father, the police completed the investigation and issued a report which stated that the driver claimed not to have seen my mother in the crosswalk. No charges were filed against the driver by anyone. We heard later that the bus driver was fired by the bus company, but of course he could still be driving for another company by now. That is very disheartening to think about.

My mother spent the remainder of her life in three different hospitals. In June, she seemed to be improving, having successfully undergone skin grafting on her left foot and lower leg. She finally came off the ventilator, and it was decided to place her in the rehabilitation center at Mt. Sinai. There, she made progress with speech and walking. However, it was clear that she had suffered brain trauma, and was finding everything tremendously difficult. She was unable to swallow or eat and continued to need a feeding tube and dialysis. In July, she suffered a relapse due to aspiration of food during a rehab session. She never fully came off the ventilator after that, and continued to need dialysis. Finally, she developed an infection in her bowels which was untreatable and killed her. Throughout this ordeal, she smiled at us all the time and continued to be the sweet and stoic person she always was. My father visited her in the hospital almost every day for 10 months. My sister Sarah was also there almost every day in the last five months. Although I have school age children, I was able to visit every other week. My brother Michael, who lives in New Jersey, also visited frequently. I cannot describe the torment that my mother and my entire family suffered during this time. During the entire 10 months, I never was able to really speak with her. Except for a short time in June, she was unable to speak during all of her hospitalization. I know that it caused her a lot of pain not to be able to communicate with us.

As you can see from the picture, my mother was a beautiful, vibrant person. She kept the whole family connected and was the kind of mother who made you feel special and loved. Shirley Ashton was born in 1934 in Chesterfield, England. She went to Oxford University where she studied medieval French and received her bachelors and masters degrees. She married my father, George Shea, in 1956 and had three children, Sarah, Susan, and Michael. She taught French for many years at Fairleigh Dickinson University in Rutherford, New Jersey. She loved New York, and especially her neighborhood, the West Side. She loved the city’s restaurants, museums, plays, ballet, chamber music, and movies. She cooked wonderful meals for people and was a world traveler, visiting her family in England, accompanying my father to teach in Rome and Tokyo and to visit Europe, India, Peru, Alaska, all of the United States, and many other places. When she suffered her (eventually) fatal accident she was in good health for a 78-year-old, and would probably have lived many more years. I feel that she was stolen from us before her time. Her many remaining relatives, including a brother and sister and seven grandchildren, also feel this way. Her many friends feel this way.

The life of pedestrian in the city is held very cheap. I would like to see that bus driver held accountable, as well as all the other reckless drivers who killed people in the city this year. Is it too much to ask for justice when a life is taken this way? It feels like murder to me. Mayor Bloomberg and Raymond Kelly should know that they have blood on their hands for not insisting that police officers pursue criminal investigations for drivers like this. Knowing that they will not be prosecuted, reckless drivers will continue to kill people legally in this city until someone does the right thing, and insists that drivers be given tickets and summonses. In the meantime, speed limits of 30 mph or lower should be observed in the city and buses should not be permitted to make right turns when pedestrians are crossing. Why can’t we put people first; when did the rights of the automotive vehicle and its drivers usurp those of the more plentiful pedestrians? We in this city should be ashamed of ourselves and our acceptance of this nonsensical status quo. Enough!

Shirley Shea’s name will be added to our 2012 memoriam post.

  • That’s an eloquent and moving tribute, Susan. Your mother would be very proud of how you’re speaking out.

  • This is really sad.

    Regarding Susan’s mention of buses making turns while pedestrians are crossing: well, that’s clearly and plainly illegal for all vehicles. Vehicles are not at all allowed to enter crosswalk while a pedestrian is in it, period. There is no question of the legality, but it’s very well observed in these parts that the police have no motivation to pursue drivers who violate that law, for whatever set of reasons that they either provide, lie about, or refuse to cite. There’s no excuse, the NYPD is breaking the law to refuse to issue summonses to drivers in these cases. We think the city would be a lot safer if the NYPD would meet this obligation, and not put so much energy into finding ways to skirt it.

  • kyle

    my condolences to your family for your tragic loss.. i always feel like drivers of these large vehicles have no regard to life…like they own the road and you need to get out of their way.. it’s not right…

  • Driver

    “Vehicles are not at all allowed to enter crosswalk while a pedestrian is in it, period.”

    Could you cite that please?

  • Andrew

    As to the investigation, according to my father, the police completed the investigation and issued a report which stated that the driver claimed not to have seen my mother in the crosswalk.

    Which implies one of three things: either the driver had a vision problem and was unable to see Shea, or the driver was careless and couldn’t be bothered to look for pedestrians while turning across an active crosswalk, or the driver was playing the common I-don’t-feel-like-waiting-for-you-so-I’ll-threaten-to-kill-you game.

    In the first two cases, the driver has proven himself incompetent to drive, and should be stripped of the privilege for life.

    The third case is no different from holding a gun to somebody’s head and demanding his money, and the consequence should be no different. Except this was no idle threat – in this case the driver pulled the trigger.

  • Joe R.

    Thank you for sharing your memories of your mother, Susan. Sadly, stories like this are all too common. The NYPD needs to prioritize protecting pedestrians and cyclists. We as a society need to permanently revoke driving privileges from anyone who kills or seriously injures a vulnerable user.

    @Brad Aaron-Just a pet peeve of mine but in the caption you use “last December” to refer to December 2012. This is a common mistake which I see everywhere. The way I learned it, unless the present month is December, “last December” means the December prior to the previous one, or December 2011, while “December” refers to the most recent occurrence of December, or December 2012 in this case. For example, if I say I rode 200 miles in March, everyone knows I mean March 2013. If I start saying I rode 200 miles last March, it should be obvious I mean March 2012 but a fair number of people will think I meant March 2013. It’s probably easier if people would just use the month and year to avoid all ambiguity.

  • Joe R.

    As far as I know, there is no such rule. The rule states drivers must yield to pedestrians in a crosswalk. Generally, the definition of yield means to give right-of-way. Once the pedestrian is no longer in your path, you have technically ceded them the right-of-way, and are free to resume forward motion.

  • Joe R.

    Also note that the legal requirement is to let the pedestrian go before you go. Technically, that doesn’t even mean you need to completely stop. If you’re going slow enough so that the pedestrian has crossed in front of you by the time you enter the crosswalk, you’re in compliance with the law. You can also go if a crossing pedestrian is far away from the path your turning vehicle will make (i.e. if they’re starting to cross on the opposite side of the street). What you *can’t* do is turn directly in front of a pedestrian who has just entered the crosswalk on the same side of the street you’re turning on to. I see this a lot. It’s illegal, and the law should be enforced.

  • Anonymous

    This is really unspeakably sad.

    It feels like murder to me.

    It simply is murder. And it’s really got to stop.

  • Daniel Winks

    Section 1151. Pedestrians’ right of way in crosswalks.

    (a) When traffic-control signals are not in place or not in operation the driver of a vehicle shall yield the right of way, slowing down or stopping if need be to so yield, to a pedestrian crossing the roadway within a crosswalk when the pedestrian is upon the half of the roadway upon which the vehicle is traveling or when the pedestrian is approaching so closely from the opposite half of the roadway as to be in danger, except that any pedestrian crossing a roadway at a point where a pedestrian tunnel or overpass has been provided shall yield the right of way to all vehicles.


    This pretty clearly states that you have to stop entirely whenever a pedestrian is on the same half of the road as your car, and also need to stop whenever a pedestrian is within “danger” on the other half. The “so closely from the opposite half of the roadway as to be in danger” under ever examination I’ve seen is about 10 feet.

  • Gillian

    How incredibly sad for all of you. I knew you and your family many years ago (1967), and I knew Shirley to be a vibrant, intelligent, hard working, healthy, delightful and loving woman. How tragic that she should be taken away from you in such a cruel and heartless manner. Thank you for writing about your tragedy, without which I wouldn’t have known how she had so sadly died. Love to all of you, Gillian

  • Susan Shea-Klot

    Dear Gillian,
    Thank you for responding so kindly to the article posted above. I remember you very fondly and have such happy memories of the time you spent with us. I miss my mother terribly, and it was wonderful to find your comment recently. I would love to hear from you again. My email is susanklot@gmail.com.


How the Daily News Gets the Right of Way Law Completely Wrong

Bianca Petillo McCloud, 18, was walking across 132nd Avenue in Rochdale, Queens, when she was struck by a turning truck driver and killed. Police did not issue so much as a citation, even though the circumstances of the crash suggested that McCloud had the right of way. Nor did police issue any charges to the truck […]

DOT: Drivers Injured 1,305 Pedestrians and Cyclists in July, and Killed Six

Editors’ note: Beginning with July, we are basing our monthly fatality and injury data posts on DOT’s compilation of crash data instead of NYPD’s. DOT data gives a more complete picture of citywide injuries, though accounting of fatalities may be delayed in cases where the victim died days or weeks after the crash. Known discrepancies will be noted. Eighteen people […]

NYPD: 1,399 Pedestrians and Cyclists Injured, 10 Killed in December

Twelve people died in New York City traffic in December, and 4,116 were injured, according to the latest NYPD crash data report [PDF]. Unofficial numbers from DOT indicate that 132 pedestrians and 20 cyclists were killed by city motorists in 2014. Drivers injured 14,922 pedestrians and cyclists last year, according to NYPD. Citywide, at least […]

TA Report: NYC District Attorneys Are Failing to Lead on Vision Zero

New York City district attorneys are not using the power of their offices to deter acts of traffic violence by holding reckless drivers accountable for harming innocent people, according to a new report from Transportation Alternatives. TA researchers worked with representatives from all five DA’s offices for “Justice Denied: New York City’s District Attorneys Plead Out […]