Why the Next Mayor Should Reform the Parking-Obsessed NYC EDC

For an investigation published this weekend, the New York Times calculated that governments in New York state give away at least $4.06 billion in corporate subsidies every year. In New York City, the agency that oversees much of this largesse is the Economic Development Corporation. And when it comes to shaping city fabric, NYC EDC has a predilection for showering its subsidies on a specific type of project: the kind with tons of parking.

NYC EDC gave the politically-connected operators of this parking garage in Jamaica, Queens, a slew of tax exemptions. Photo: ##http://maps.google.com/maps?q=162nd+street+and+jamaica+ave&ie=UTF8&hq=&hnear=Jamaica+Ave+%26+162nd+St,+Queens,+New+York&gl=us&ei=tiT5TOKkEsmr8AbFxrWWCQ&oi=geocode_result&ved=0CBgQ8gEwAA&ll=40.705774,-73.798599&spn=0.007645,0.018775&z=16&layer=c&cbll=40.705699,-73.798543&panoid=B7CsJkiqHMzemcZ3-cr_Lw&cbp=12,53.38,,0,-1.79##Google Street View##

So when Comptroller John Liu suggested at a mayoral candidates forum last week that all business subsidies should be eliminated, along with the city’s Industrial Development Agency (the arm of EDC that oversaw the Yankee Stadium garage debacle, among other things), he struck on an idea that could do a world of good for NYC’s walkability.

EDC has a hand in many things, from training small business start-ups to encouraging the installation of solar panels, but its biggest imprint on the city comes from large-scale real estate development and financing deals that shape the built environment. EDC projects like the parking-saturated Gateway Center in the South Bronx are completely out of step with the Bloomberg administration’s professed intent to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

While NYC DOT has helped carry out the city’s sustainability goals by redesigning city streets to enhance walking, biking, and transit, EDC has continued to insist on a car-oriented development strategy that produces large volumes of parking and hostile streets for walking. “The worst thing we could do,” EDC President Seth Pinsky told Streetsblog in 2010, “is create projects that create a parking need and then not provide that parking.”

Because EDC’s primary focus is on brokering business deals, said Hunter College city planning professor Tom Angotti, it’s common for EDC’s goals not to align with other administration environmental or transportation priorities. “EDC operates relatively independently,” he said, and it “isn’t subject to the same kind of sunlight that other agencies are.”

So far, Liu is the only mayoral candidate seeking to end EDC business subsidies entirely. But even if EDC continues to offer development subsidies in the next administration, there are ways to better target the incentives so they meet broader goals.

City Council Member Brad Lander, who sits on the economic development committee, told Streetsblog that he wants more rigorous requirements — including transportation benchmarks — if the city continues to subsidize development. “The Community Redevelopment Agency of Los Angeles has a whole series of criteria for sustainability,” Lander said. “I would like EDC to have similar set of standards and guidelines to what the CRA/LA has, including a broad set of transportation issues, such as maximizing use of public transportation.”

There’s a compelling case to be made that EDC’s eagerness to subsidize parking is harming the city, and that the next mayor should reform the agency. Take a look at this by-no-means-comprehensive list of how EDC has spent millions to build more parking, often for no other discernible reason than to distribute political spoils:

  • Yankee Stadium parking: EDC approved the business plan for parking garages around the new stadium, arranging $237 million in tax exempt bonds to build nearly 4,000 parking spaces on what used to be parks. When the spaces went empty during Yankees games, the garage operator began racking up back rent and unpaid interest before eventually defaulting on the bonds entirely.
  • Greater Jamaica Development Corporation parking: A politically-connected local development non-profit scored a bunch of incentives to finance its 2,000 space parking garage, including $13 million in tax-exempt bonds arranged by EDC. As icing on the cake, the city’s Finance Department decided that the garage didn’t have to pay property taxes.
  • Moisha’s Discount Supermarket parking: EDC arranged $2 million in tax breaks for this Midwood supermarket to expand as part of a program to improve access to high-quality and affordable groceries. The politically-connected supermarket owners took the money to build 15,000 square feet of store space and 18,000 square feet of parking lot. The program cuts parking minimums for participating stores, but Moisha’s built the extra parking anyways — despite the fact that the program is designed to improve food access for people without cars.
  • Funding Willoughby Square Park with parking: In Downtown Brooklyn, a new park isn’t being paid for with city funds. Instead, EDC had a developer build a 694-space underground parking garage with a park on top.
  • Seward Park Urban Renewal Area: As part of the long-overdue redevelopment of parking lots on the Lower East Side, EDC requested special permits for the construction of 500 underground parking spaces, pushing the project above the maximums allowed under the city’s zoning code.
  • Flushing Commons: Zoning required 700 spaces for a development project in Queens, but the project included more than double that — 1,600 spaces — because EDC required that the project replace public parking spaces already on the site.
  • Preserving unused parking in Harlem: For a development site in Harlem containing a 450-space parking garage, EDC’s request for proposals asked developers to “maintain as many parking spaces as possible,” despite the fact that the garage was rarely filled to capacity.
  • Building thousands of parking spots at the most transit-accessible place on Staten Island: The massive EDC-led waterfront development in St. George on Staten Island will replace every parking space currently on the site and add even more parking, bringing the total to 2,200 spaces. “We literally are putting every possible bit of parking on that spot that we can,” the project’s EDC-approved ferris wheel developer told Streetsblog.
  • Lavishing taxpayer funds on FreshDirect: It isn’t just parking that EDC cares about — the agency also has a penchant for subsidizing traffic-intensive businesses. Liu cited the FreshDirect example specifically at the candidates’ forum. A $128 million EDC subsidy deal to keep the grocery delivery service from moving its warehouse to New Jersey will end up bringing thousands of truck trips to the South Bronx, which already has one of the nation’s highest asthma rates.
  • Snuffing out the Sheridan Expressway teardown: After environmental and neighborhood advocates campaigned for years to remove a lightly-trafficked freeway stub in the Bronx and replace it with affordable housing and parkland, the city agreed to a comprehensive study. But the city abruptly ruled out the highway removal solely because of a flawed traffic analysis. The surprise decision was reportedly the product of horse-trading during EDC’s drawn-out lease negotiations with wholesalers at the Hunts Point Produce Market, who opposed the highway removal.
  • Anonymous

    Amen. EDC seems to have the lethal combination of caring enough about parking to force it in everywhere while not caring enough to think about how parking works (even from a pro-parking perspective!).

    And remember: mayoral candidate Bill de Blasio thinks we need MORE EDC support for things like the Jamaica parking

  • fj

    Addressing the accelerating frequency of extreme weather events and that cars float very easily and can cause lots of damage and be very dangerous banging into things, they should be banned from flood zones.

    The city has much more important things to worry about before or after major events.

  • fj

    In any case, the insurance industry will likely limit its exposure if it hasn’t already (hopefully, by not getting the public sector to provide the coverage.)

  • Ari

    I applied for a job at EDC a number of years ago.  I’m glad I didn’t get it.  They suck.

  • Miles Bader

    … and please do this stuff quickly, before somebody like Christine “SUV?” Quinn gets her grubby little hands on the tiller…

  • Phil

    this is really important reporting that I wish NYT would pick up. thanks Streetsblog.

  • Boris

    I will favorite this list and print it out to post in my office. What a disaster. But the EDC can be fixed: revamp its policies regarding parking, and require new or improved transit access at every megaproject.  Transit improvements can be funded through Scott Stringer’s New York Transit Fund idea, as long as the money stays under city control and is specifically designated to be spent on transit.

  • Anonymous

    Are you in need of a Loan/Funding for a project? Have you been trying to obtain a Loan from any of the Banks or Loan Companies and got Ripped off and they have refused to grant you the Loan? we offer all types of non-recourse Loan and funding at a low Interest Rate of 2% both long term and short term. 

    The categories of Loan/financial funding offered include but not limited to: Business Loan, Personal Loan, Company Loan, Mortgage Loan, debt consolidation and financial funding for both turnkey and mega projects E.T.C. from a minimum of Euro/US$1Million to Euro/US$5Billion Max. 

    We also also specialize in lease and sales of Bank Guarantee {BG}, Standby Letter of Credit {SBLC}, Medium Term Notes {MTN} and Confirmable Bank Draft {CBD}, this financial instrument is issue from AAA Rated bank such as HSBC Bank, UBS Zurich, Barclays Bank , Standard Chartered Bank E.T.C. 

    The financial instrument can be invested into High Yield Investment Trading Program {HYITP) or Private Placement Program (PPP). We are direct to a genuine and reliable Financial Organization, without broker chain or chauffer driven offer. 

    Kindly get in touch for further details and procedure. 

    James Allen
    Email: jamesallen308@yahoo.com 

  • Andrew

    As a big supporter of mass transit and walkable cities, I have to disagree with your characterizations of some of these projects. Downtown Flushing simply needs more parking. It is absolutely loaded with transit options, which are maxed out; and lots of people do heavy grocery shopping and other kinds of shopping here. The muni lot is an essential piece of a multi-modal puzzle. Same with Downtown Jamaica. I have worked here and there simply must be parking for the miles of retail outlets supplying the region, the higher ed, research, and court functions here. Not everybody can get there and out by bus. The details of the parking lots there are complicated. I don’t think you have to bash these policies to show your support for other, more progessive options as well.

  • Joe R.

    I’m very familiar with downtown Flushing. I agree with the need for some parking, but I’m not sure if more is really needed. I’d much rather see personal cars banned altogether within a 3 or 4 block radius of Main Street and Roosevelt Avenue. You can put a multistory parking facility maybe on Northern Boulevard or College Point Boulevard, and get rid of the muni lot on Union Street. That real estate is quite valuable. It should be used to provide more commercial/residential. The idea here is there would still be parking, but several blocks away. This is still close enough. By keeping personal cars out of the most congested parts of downtown Flushing, you’ll enhance the shopping experience somewhat. I would even love to turn most of the streets there into pedestrian plazas, but given the heavy bus traffic I realize that’s not possible.

    Jamaica I think could do with more loading zones and less curbside parking. That would probably be most beneficial to the businesses there. In the case of both downtown Jamaica and downtown Flushing I’m not even totally against the idea of adding more parking garages, but only if we totally eliminate curbside parking, then use the space for bus lanes, widened sidewalks, or bike lanes.


NYC’s Top Parking Subsidizer, Seth Pinsky, Moves On

Seth Pinsky, whose legacy as head of the New York City Economic Development Corporation will be years of parking-induced traffic in city neighborhoods, with taxpayers footing the bill, is headed to the private sector. The news came this morning, via announcements from City Hall and RXR Realty, which hired Pinsky. During Pinsky’s five-year tenure, NYCEDC incentivized […]

Anybody Interested in Tearing Down a Couple of Yankee Stadium Garages?

Another attempt to salvage something positive from the Yankee Stadium parking boondoggle is underway. The company that operates the garages, having defaulted on hundreds of millions in triple-tax exempt bonds, has issued a request for proposals for the sublease and redevelopment of two lots. Even back in 2007 and 2008, when the NYC Economic Development Corporation […]

Eyes on the Street: A Bike-Friendly Approach to the Q’Boro

We’ve got another highlight from 2010 construction season to share with you. A two-way, protected approach to the Queens side of the Queensboro Bridge bike-ped path has been paved, striped and open for business since the end of October. Clarence took these photos of the new approach, part of a package of bicycle and pedestrian […]

Today’s Headlines

London Transpo Commissioner: Pricing Right for NYC (News) Suit Filed to Stop Houston Street Construction (AMNY) More on Yankees ‘Stadium Planning’ Rent Subsidy (Crain’s, AMNY) EDC Wants to Revive Brooklyn Freight Rail for Ground Zero Rebuild (NYT) US Open Exec Downplays Park Parking (News) Housing Replaces Parking Lot; Neighbors Want More Parking (SI Advance) Families […]

Will Michael Schlein Stop NYC EDC From Subsidizing Parking?

This morning, Mayor Bill de Blasio announced the appointment of Michael Schlein as chair of the city’s Economic Development Corporation. Schlein, a Wall Street insider with close ties to the mayor, joins EDC President Kyle Kimball atop the agency’s leadership. EDC has a terrible track record of subsidizing parking garages and overseeing mega-projects with acres of excess parking. The […]