Hudson Square BID Sets Out to Reclaim Streets From Holland Tunnel Traffic

Every day, thousands of drivers, including trucks too large for city roadways, cross from the Manhattan or Williamsburg bridges, through the streets of Lower Manhattan, to the Holland Tunnel – all for a free ride (often to avoid the westbound toll on the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge).

The Hudson Square BID wants to enhance SoHo Square by turning a short side street, Little Sixth Avenue, into a shared space that prioritizes pedestrians. Image: Hudson Square BID

The result is congestion, pollution, noise and dangerous conditions for everyone who dares to get in the way.

This week, the Hudson Square Connection Business Improvement District released a master plan [PDF] for the traffic-choked streets around the Holland Tunnel entrance, outlining $27 million in street improvements – from pedestrian space to bike lanes – aimed at making the neighborhood a less hostile environment.

The plan builds on work already underway to make the area a better place to walk. The BID has hired pedestrian safety managers to help with crossings at often-gridlocked intersections. Manhattan Community Board 2’s transportation committee unanimously supported a DOT plan that was quickly approved by the full board in June to expand pedestrian space and provide clarity for drivers on Varick Street, Canal Street and Sixth Avenue.

The BID’s five-year master plan goes further. In addition to neighborhood-wide recommendations for streetscape features, it focuses on four key places: Varick Street, Hudson Street, Spring Street and “SoHo Square,” at the intersection of Spring and Sixth Avenue.

The plan for SoHo Square would convert Little Sixth Avenue into a shared street and construct raised crosswalks to slow vehicular traffic through the expanded plaza. For Varick Street, the BID wants to examine the feasibility of installing a planted median to separate tunnel-bound traffic from neighborhood traffic, to replace the strip of plastic white posts there today. Hudson Street would gain a protected bike lane —  an idea that Community Board 2 endorsed last year –while the entire neighborhood would see more trees.

Changes to Freeman Plaza, at the entrance to the Holland Tunnel, have garnered the most press attention but are not included in the master plan, which aims to improve streets throughout the neighborhood. In 2010, the BID and the Regional Plan Association collaborated on conceptual plans for the plaza.

The Hudson Square Connection, launched in 2009, serves the area bounded by West Houston Street to the north, Sixth Avenue to the east, Canal Street to the south and the Hudson River to the west. It is home to over 50,000 people during the daytime, with 2,500 residents. The plan, developed by a team led by Mathews Nielsen Landscape Architects, Rogers Marvel Architects, Billings Jackson Design, ARUP and Open, would be funded through BID assessments and public dollars.

This is not a parking lot; it's a crosswalk on Varick Street. Photo: Doug Gordon

The BID’s recommendations aim to transform the neighborhood’s streets, but traffic will continue to plague the area until policymakers address the underlying reason why many drivers find idling in Lower Manhattan traffic worthwhile — the free ride going westbound across the island.

The BID’s plan notes that tunnel traffic is a major problem in the neighborhood. Varick Street, it notes, “is choked by cars accessing the Holland Tunnel, which makes it hard for pedestrians to cross and interferes with local deliveries.”

Community Board 2 was the first community board in the city to pass a resolution in favor of congestion pricing, and has remained engaged on the issue, hosting a forum on bridge tolls in May. In an email, the BID said it is “not involved” in discussions related to road pricing to reduce congestion.

Even though the topic of fair tolls remains on the back burner, a slate of pedestrian, bicycle and park improvements are a good start to making streets around the Holland Tunnel less threatening for people who live and work in the neighborhood.

  • I used to work around here. These would be much welcomed improvements!

  • J

    This plan is a strong step forward, with many things to commend. However, it is also very timid in a few of it’s recommendations for transportation. The plan for Spring Street, for one, is a step backwards, in terms of transportation. Expanding the the wide existing lane on Spring Street to two lanes will encourage more speeding and reckless driving. Spring Street is already a major bike corridor. The plan improves this by recommending a Spring Street connection to the Hudson River Greenway (there is no present connection). However, instead of adding a second lane for automobiles, we should use the excess space for bike facilities that also connect to the greenway.

    In addition, the plan for Varick Street calls for removing one of the three lanes of traffic that are not headed to the tunnel. This is logical, since the non-tunnel lanes are only lightly used. However, the plan uses the 10 feet of freed up space in the following manner: 5 feet go to a planted median (not wide enough for a ped refuge) and 5 feet are split between the two remaining non-tunnel lanes to make them wider. Is this really the best use of extremely limited space?

  • harv

    so I found this article on Streesblog. I just wanted to express my horrible displeasure for the pedestrian nonsense that’s been going on from Holland tunnel. for the past seven years. The pedestrian monitors make traffic worse. The traffic calming islands planters medians and all that other nonsense just make traffic worse and cause us, that means cars, to spend more time on the streets struggling to get into the tunnel. If you want to traffic on let it move through your neighborhood faster and stop trying to make four lanes of traffic reduced to one and then to two in order to get into the tunnel. Making driving frustrating and anger inducing experience is not healthy for anybody. Give me back my street. give me back four lanes of traffic without barriers, and I will be in the tunnel and out of your neighborhood before you can spit on me. Traffic calming is bullshit

  • Michael Knight

    “and cause us, that means cars…”

    Wow, you are one of those new talking, self-driving cars?


Canal Street Report Recommends Wider Sidewalks, Smarter Parking

Canal Street, to put it mildly, is due for a makeover. The street is clogged with traffic from the Holland Tunnel and the un-tolled Manhattan Bridge. Pedestrians jostle for space on the packed sidewalks, and they’re especially at risk of getting hit by a car, according to the city’s Pedestrian Safety Study. Fortunately, the funds […]

CB 2 Committee Signs Off on Slate of SoHo Pedestrian Improvements

The transportation committee of Manhattan Community Board 2 this week unanimously recommended that DOT implement two projects that would bring a menu of pedestrian safety improvements to SoHo, including a number of intersections near the Holland Tunnel. At the intersection of Canal Street and Hudson Street, DOT plans to add median islands and bump-outs to […]