Wild, Wild West Side Has Its Own Vigilante Traffic Cop

You’ve got to already be a little bit crazy to choose to drive into Midtown for work each day (as the record-breaking ridership numbers on the PATH train attest). Sitting in traffic, dodging the even crazier driver next to you — perhaps the only thing worse than driving near the Lincoln Tunnel is trying to walk safely along those traffic-clogged streets.

Last Thursday, evening rush hour congestion caused one tunnel-bound commuter to finally snap. This driver, captured on video by Animal New York, decided she’d waited long enough to get out of Manhattan and took actions into her own hands. She got out of her car, walked into the middle of Eleventh Avenue and W. 43rd Street, and did her best impression of a traffic cop. One key difference: She waved cars through in just one direction — hers.

It’s impressive as a work of urban anthropology — look at that deference other drivers show to the trappings of authority — but even more so as a case study in psychology. This is your brain on traffic.

The city has the power to make this neighborhood, which is becoming an increasingly residential community, a little less exhaust-addled. The Lincoln Tunnel is already tolled (and last year’s sizable toll hike helped drive people toward transit), but there’s another way to do it, through parking policy. Every time the city lets a little piece of Midtown and the West Side get  gobbled up by automobile storage, it becomes that much more appealing and affordable for drivers to try and squeeze through the Lincoln Tunnel (and during the evening, when there is no Lincoln Tunnel bus lane, that much slower for transit riders thrown into mixed traffic).

In just the first five months of 2008, before the real estate market fell apart, the city approved special permits for 500 new parking spaces in Hell’s Kitchen alone. Now, the city wants to allow more parking to be built in the Theater District. If nothing else, it’s a good way of encouraging more vigilante traffic cops.

  • Guest

    I think you should take a closer look…

    Yes, the City has allowed new parking spaces in some of the development.  Yet a whole lot of that development has been built on parking lots (much of which had stacked parking).

    Perhaps you could balance the picture by letting us know how much parking has been eliminated as well as how much has been created so we can understand the net change?

  • Ever since the DOT added the new bike lane on 9th Avenue traffic around that part of midtown has been a freakin’ nightmare. I totally understand the need to make biking safe in New York. I understand the need to encourage more people to commute by bike. I understand the benefits of discouraging people from driving into Manhattan. But come on folks, do we want a city where every single avenue is impassable during the rush hours? When you put bike lanes and take away traffic lanes on just about every single avenue used to approach the entrance to the Lincoln Tunnel this is the result. You can’t say that this doesn’t impact response time of police, fire and EMT vehicles in emergencies. We need to have a sane policy that recognizes that our streets need to be shared between pedestrians, bicyclists and motorists. You’re never going to make Midtown private vehicle free. So how about facilitating the efficient movement of vehicles on some avenues while others are better suited for bikes? 

  • Also, your argument that additional parking is to blame for this kind of traffic jam is completely discredited. At the same time the city was requiring more parking garage spots to be added in the area they were taking away more street surface parking. 

  • Station44025

    I remember back before the bike lanes when it was easy to drive into the tunnels during rush hour.  Wait, no I don’t.  That never happened.


Park Slope Cop Brings About Sidewalk Cycling, Then Tickets It

We at Streetsblog aren’t big fans of sidewalk bike riding. As we’ve said before, if the police truly must take time away from targeting the most dangerous traffic crimes, like motorist speeding and failure-to-yield, sidewalk riding is the kind of infraction for them to worry about. Pedestrian space is scarce enough in New York City. […]

“Don’t Block the Box” Bill Clears Albany

With 2800 agents able to enforce rules against blocking the box, drivers may soon take these signs seriously. A bill intended to step up enforcement against drivers who block the box made it through the state legislature last Thursday. While the measure is not expected to play a major role in traffic reduction, it should […]

Citizens Hammer NYPD Commissioner Kelly on Street Safety

Police Commissioner Ray Kelly at Baruch College last week The following report was submitted by Carol Wood, a Murray Hill resident, along with Emilia Crotty, Bicycle Education Program Associate for Bike New York. Both are members of the NYC Bicycling Coalition. Last Thursday evening, March 20, nearly 200 East Siders turned out for a "Town […]