BRT Imposes Order on Mexico City Streets, Speeding and Greening Commutes

A new articulated Metrobús sits in front of Mexico City's Monumento a la Revolucion. Photo: Noah Kazis

This is the second in a series of reports about sustainable transportation policies in Mexico City. Last week, Streetsblog participated in a tour of the city led by the Institute for Transportation and Development Policy and funded by the Rockefeller Foundation. A previous installment covered pedestrian improvements in the city and a third will discuss its bicycle planning.

After a precipitous collapse, buses are on the rebound in Mexico City.

When the city’s public bus system fell apart during the political and economic turmoil of the 80s and 90s, Mexico City residents were left to rely on a fleet of private microbuses that was extensive but slow, dangerous, and heavily polluting. Now, the city is quickly building out a bus rapid transit system called Metrobús that’s making surface transit fast, safe, and healthy. “It’s the most important initiative in the city in the last 25 years,” says Mayor Marcelo Ebrard.

On the Avenida de Insurgentes, where the first Metrobús line opened in 2006, the distinctive red buses pass by in continuous streams, even when it’s not rush hour. At midday, the gap between one bus and the next was rarely longer than the time it takes to load and unload passengers at the previous station or to wait at a red light. Each bus was full. Clearly, demand is high, perhaps higher than the system can handle.

A bus pulls up to the elevated station in a dedicated lane. Another bus followed immediately behind this one. Photo: Noah Kazis

Each of the three Metrobús lines offers a full set of bus rapid transit features. Riders cross to the median of a wide avenue, where buses run in each direction on physically separated lanes. A ramp leads up to an enclosed station, where you tap a smart card against the turnstile to enter.

Once the bus arrives, its wide doors open down the length of the vehicle, passengers quickly exit and enter, and the bus pulls away. The long, straight avenue and stations in the median mean the driver rarely has to even turn the wheel; it’s a very smooth trip for a bus.

On most lines, bus rapid transit cut travel times in half compared to private microbuses. Image: Metrobús

The results speak both to the efficiency of the operation and the chaos that generally reigns on Mexico City streets. On Insurgentes, giving three lanes of traffic to Metrobús operations actually improved speeds for both transit and private automobiles. Speeds rose from an average of only 12 kilometers per hour for mixed traffic to 17 kph for cars and 20 kph for buses, according to Metrobús official Gonzalo Garcia Miaja. A trip down the full 30 kilometer corridor used to take 140 minutes. Now, it takes only 85 — and Insurgentes saw the smallest improvement in travel times of any Metrobus line. Property values are up along the route, according to Walter Hook, the CEO of the Institute for Transportation and Development Policy.

A centralized microbus station near Mexico City's Bosque Chapultepec. Most microbuses pick up passengers who hail them along the street. Photo: Noah Kazis

The trick was taking the private microbuses, which snarl traffic by darting back and forth across the street in search of one more fare, off the road. With all buses sticking to one lane, traffic moves more smoothly for everyone. It also moves more safely. “The microbus rides like he wants,” said Miaja. “They are literally killing themselves to get more passengers.” Traffic crashes and injuries are down significantly along Metrobús corridors, he said, though they’re far from zero.

Between the 1980s and 1990s, mode share for high-capacity buses plummeted, while microbuses filled the gap. One year after the first Metrobús line opened, the new bus rapid transit system was started to bring back good bus service. Image: Metrobús

The ubiquity of microbuses on Mexico City streets dates back to the mid-1980s. Before then, the city had a publicly run system of buses. Buffeted on one side by a left-wing union that sided with the Zapatista uprising of 1994 and on the other by the wave of privatization that swept through the country under President Carlos Salinas, the system fell apart. In 1986, 42 percent of trips in Mexico City took place on a high-capacity bus; by 1994, that number had plummeted to just 10 percent. Microbuses picked up all the slack and more.

Moving from microbus to Metrobús has also proved important for air quality, a critical issue in a city that had some of the worst smog in the world. According to Miaja, the newest models being put out on the street by Metrobús are 95 percent cleaner than buses being sold in 1993, the year the very newest microbuses on the road were produced.

Air pollution is easing up in Mexico City now, thanks not only to better transportation options but improved automotive technologies, heavy industry’s departure from the city, and tough policies like Hoy No Circula, which forbids each car to drive one day a week. The ring of mountains that surround Mexico City are still cloaked in a grey-blue haze, but the heavy, eye-stinging smog that many travelers remember is, increasingly, a thing of the past.

A map of the Metrobús system, including the fourth line set to open this year.

Even with extensive infrastructure, however, the system is now approaching its limits. The Insurgentes line is essentially at capacity; though Mayor Ebrard announced the addition of some newer, larger buses for the system just last week, the only way to significantly add service along the route, according to ITDP’s Annie Weinstock, would be to build new passing lanes in each direction, allowing express service.

When the fourth Metrobús line opens this year, the city expects to have 201 million passengers riding the system a year. The ridership is enormous but adds up to less than three of Mexico City’s eleven subway lines.

The constraints inherent in surface transit are clear. The buses must wait at red lights to allow traffic and pedestrians to cross the street, slowing trips. “You can’t do transit signal priority,” said Weinstock, referring to systems which extend green lights for approaching buses. “You would never have cross traffic.” At one point on our tour, a street protest blocked the Metrobús line in one direction; our group was forced to walk.

Mexico City's extensive subway system is also expanding, with a twelfth line opening this year. Photo: Noah Kazis

Mexico City is not standing still, continuing to expand its transit system both below ground and on the street. A twelfth subway line will open this summer, as will a fourth Metrobús line. In 2010, the city launched a new public bus service, named Ecobus for using clean fuels, which runs in mixed traffic.

Ebrard identified the relatively low cost of Metrobús operations as an advantage over further subway construction. At a five peso fare, equal to about 40 cents, the system turns an operating profit. Private operators — collectives made up of the minibus drivers who formerly drove each route — get all fare revenues, which then pay for their labor, fuel, maintenance, and most of the buses themselves, explained Miaja. The government only pays for the street and station infrastructure. In contrast, the city subsidizes its Metro system at a cost of about US$300 million a year.

The newest Metrobús line, opening this year, will have less extensive infrastructure. The two lanes on the right will be dedicated to buses, with a small bus shelter visible in a median in the street. One lane of through traffic will remain, visible in the top left. Photo: Noah Kazis

The new Metrobús line set to open will function slightly differently than the first three. Rather than offering the full bus rapid transit package, the new line will dispense with large stations and off-board fare payment while keeping the physically separated bus lanes. Because the line runs through Mexico City’s historic downtown, finding the space for the more intense infrastructure and squaring it with historic preservation laws proved unfeasible. At one point, Line 4 will run as a two-way bus mall, without any private car access. It will also improve transit access to the airport; right now, only one terminal is directly accessible from the subway.

The fourth line of the Metrobús will run just blocks away from the Calle Regina, a pedestrianized street downtown that Streetsblog described in a previous post. In both cases, street space was being used less for vehicle throughput than as unauthorized market space. “The streets were absolutely immobilized with street vendors,” said Hook. By our visit, the vendors had been cleared and construction was underway on the bus infrastructure.

On Mexico City streets, evidently, conflict isn’t only between different modes competing for scarce real estate. As important is the battle between the formal and informal sectors of the economy. Squatting vendors and private minibuses vie for street space with the customers of bricks-and-mortar merchants and systematized public transit. In clearing the first group to make way for the second, Mexico City is simultaneously improving mobility and sustainability while extending government control over new spaces.

Mexico City Mayor Marcelo Ebrard, in the yellow tie, speaks aboard a new articulated bus. Photo: Noah Kazis

Even if the Metrobús business model of displacing microbus drivers and then hiring them as BRT operating companies is not applicable in most American cities, Mayor Ebrard urged United States cities to copy the technological example of Metrobús, and to have the political will to invest street space in high quality bus service.

“Perseverance. You are right,” Ebrard told his American counterparts. “You are going to have resistance, but you are going to win this battle. I guarantee it.”

  • The mode use chart is interesting in that it shows how the trolley-bus network has sadly shrunk. Theres less and less of them every year.  Theyre run by a private company I believe.

    And yes, the metrobus is always packed. Always.

  • Ben from Bed Stuy

    Mexico City is an amazing, vibrant metropolis, with a Gazillion or so residents. I can’t wait for a return visit and see how this great city is re-inventing itself so its many citizens can move around more easily and safely. Viva Mexico!

  • Anonymous

    I’m a native of Mexico City and I used to take the microbuses on Insurgentes Avenue. Yes, it was utter chaos, but you could always get into one of the microbuses, and often even find a seat. Now with the metrobus it’s nearly impossible. It may be faster, cleaner, etc., but what use is that to riders if they can’t even ride it? I remember one time when I got into a metrobus station and waited for a dozen buses to pass, all of them so packed that it was impossible to get in. I gave up (having already paid my fare) and took a taxi. When you do manage to squeeze in, it is hardly a pleasant experience unless you fancy being a sardine in a can.

    I don’t say go back to the microbuses; the metrobus is very promising but it absolutely needs more capacity. A *lot* more capacity. Even without adding a passing lane, they might be able to trade off some speed for capacity while still being reasonably fast.

    A more minor design complaint that I have is that it is often impossible to see the signs with the name of the station from within the bus when the bus is stopped at the station.

  • Anonymous

    Surprise! With the collapse of Transmilenio BRT in Bogota now complete, we can expect a full-on BRT propaganda assault from ITDP/EMBARQ/Streetsblog/Streetfilms/etc. Great stuff.

    Don’t talk to any people who are actually forced to ride the bus, and don’t ever suggest that light rail and cycletracks were the obvious solution for the City. ITDP doesn’t go for that much.

    The idea that adding buses and lines will decrease sardine-like crowding is the same as thinking that adding highway capacity will decrease auto traffic problems in the long run — induced demand tells us otherwise. So why would we uncritically repeat everything Metrobus officials and the ITDP say?

    And buses have never moved people out of their cars, which is why the auto industry loves and financially supports ‘think tanks’ and PR firms like ITDP/EMBARQ/etc. 

    The Metrobus riots are coming, just as surely as the Transmilenio riots arrived in Bogota two weeks ago. Hopefully Streetsblog won’t act shocked when the first pictures of tear gas in the streets of Mexico City start arriving on our doorsteps.

  • I was shocked when I first rode Mexico City’s subway.  Getting to the trains is like going through a labyrinth, and the trains were often more packed than anything I’ve ever seen.  That said, the price of a ride was about 30 cents and it went just about everywhere. 

    I don’t think there was an alternative means of transit for most of the riders; if they’d all been in cars the streets wouldn’t have had enough capacity.

  • Spgera Tol

    Mexico city is a polluted shithole, I went to a nightclub and it was a real ripoff and prostitutes are ugly I prefer to jerk myself


With a Boost From Bike-Share, Cycling Surges on Mexico City’s Mean Streets

This is the third in a series of reports about sustainable transportation policies in Mexico City. Last week, Streetsblog participated in a tour of the city led by the Institute for Transportation and Development Policy and funded by the Rockefeller Foundation. Previous installments covered pedestrian improvements and the city’s new bus rapid transit system. Mexico City never […]

Looking Ahead to the Year in Transit Expansion

After significant transit construction in the United States in 2014, the next year will see another impressive round of groundbreakings and new openings. That’s according to Yonah Freemark at the Transport Politic, who has catalogued major transit expansion projects throughout the U.S. and Canada for the last six years. In 2015, we’ll see major light rail projects begin […]

The Importance of Mobility for the World’s Women

Today on the Streetsblog Network, some thoughts on women and transportation coming out of the current annual meeting of the Clinton Global Initiative, courtesy of The City Fix. Writing about yesterday’s panel discussion on investing in the well-being of women and girls, Erica Schlaikjer says: Much depends on her ability to move about freely. Photo […]

MTA Teams Up With City DOTs. Which Transit Agency Will Join Next?

Announcing @MTA as our first transit member! Innovative street design is essential for good transit service. — NACTO (@NACTO) August 22, 2016 Last week, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority joined the National Association of City Transportation Officials, the federation of local DOTs whose policy guidance and street design manuals are popularizing a more multi-modal approach to urban transportation […]