On Progressive Transportation, Bill de Blasio Has Some Catching Up to Do

Tomorrow evening, Public Advocate Bill de Blasio will deliver the keynote address at the Transportation Alternatives summer benefit. When de Blasio’s name was announced as a headliner, it was somewhat surprising. As a City Council member, he was an early backer of making Prospect Park car-free. But as a citywide office holder and presumed 2013 mayoral hopeful, de Blasio has not made street safety or sustainable transportation a priority.

As Public Advocate, de Blasio commands a citywide bully pulpit and can highlight just about any issue he cares to. The position was created to serve as an “ombudsperson” — someone who listens to the public and speaks up for their interests.

Pedestrian safety and traffic congestion are the top two concerns of New Yorkers, according to a 2008 survey by the Citizens Committee for New York City. And, as Gene Russianoff of the Straphangers Campaign told Streetsblog after de Blasio was elected in 2009, the public advocate could use his office “to press for picking up the pace and scope of Bus Rapid Transit routes.”

But de Blasio has not had much to say on these issues. When he has spoken up about livable streets, he has tended to sympathize with opponents of current NYC DOT initiatives to improve bus service and bike safety.

Instead of asking the city to pick up the pace of bus improvements, he asked for more bureaucratic delay before DOT went forward with the 34th Street Transitway (de Blasio’s suggestion came just before the city announced that there would be no separated busway in the project). Most recently, he applauded the decision not to stripe a bike lane on Bay Ridge Parkway that was voted down by the local Community Board: “This was an important step forward that shows a willingness to respect the input of residents and community leaders.” In contrast, de Blasio has not come out and said he supports the Prospect Park West bike lane, which was requested and approved by the local community board in his old district.

Past citywide office holders have raised the profile of street safety and sustainability issues. Former city comptroller Alan Hevesi called attention to rampant traffic violations with a 2000 report estimating that motorists run red lights more than a million times each day in New York City. De Blasio’s predecessor as public advocate, Betsy Gotbaum, who was widely considered a meek presence in the office, pointed out the folly of including so much parking in the city’s plans for the Far West Side of Manhattan.

De Blasio has not yet announced a mayoral run, but the Times reported last week that he raised nearly $700,000 in the first half of this year (less than Christine Quinn, about the same as Scott Stringer, more than Bill Thompson). As a big-city mayoral contender, de Blasio would have some catching up to do before he could plausibly claim to be a progressive candidate on transportation issues. The bar is high these days: Rahm Emanuel campaigned for mayor of Chicago with a strong commitment to expanding transit and bike infrastructure in his platform — promises that he is now delivering on.

Here is an overview of de Blasio’s record when it comes to transit, street safety, and public space issues.

  • Car-Free Prospect Park: As a council member, de Blasio helped win more car-free hours in the park, and supported a car-free summer trial.
  • Congestion pricing, bridge tolls, and MTA funding: De Blasio voted against congestion pricing as a council member in 2008. He then supported Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver’s plan to add bridge tolls pegged to the subway fare on currently free bridges.
  • The 34th Street Transitway and street redesigns in general: This March, de Blasio released a letter to NYC DOT in which he called for an environmental impact assessment of the proposed separated busway on 34th Street. De Blasio questioned DOT’s evaluation of several street redesigns, including the Ninth Avenue bike lane and Select Bus Service on the Bx12 route, calling for greater attention to be paid to traffic impacts in both cases. “In addition,” he wrote, “evaluations of Times Square and Herald Square Pedestrian Plazas, Broadway Boulevard, and Prospect Park West bike lanes all universally supported the DOT’s proposals, no matter the impact they had on surrounding areas.” The letter was then quoted in the New York Post.
  • Bike lanes: As a council member, de Blasio supported the 9th Street bike lane in Park Slope. As public advocate, he commended DOT for abandoning a plan to stripe a bike lane on Bay Ridge Parkway that would not have removed any parking spaces or travel lanes. The plan was opposed by local electeds and Brooklyn CB 10. He has not taken a position on the Prospect Park West bike lane, which is in his old council district.
  • Parking: De Blasio has a form on his website for constituents to tell him about defunct no-parking zones or broken fire hydrants that can be converted to curb parking.

Noah Kazis contributed to this post.

  • Hugh C Taylor

    Bill are you doing anything to help pedestrians and bicyclists? And, which is it Bill? Does the community board have the say on bicycle and pedestrian changes or not? You opposed the Bay Ridge Parkway bike lane because it was opposed by CB 10. But you don’t support the PPW lane which is supported by CB 7. You want the Times Square and Herald Square pedestrian improvements studied more, though those projects are supported by the local CB and business leaders. You question DOT studies, but you don’t ask DOT to collect additional information that answers your concerns.

  • Malamars


    Bill had the chance to really SUPER push car-free PP back then.  He was luke-warm.  But his problem is about everything transportation is he is “luke-warm”.  He needs to take some bold steps.  I’d love to hear more from him and open to supporting a possible mayoral run, but right now even though I have problems with Quinn, I think she is better by default because Bill really blew it over-criticizing the DOT and that dopey vote against Congestion Pricing.  

  • Anonymous

    It’s obvious that the “conventional wisdom” among politicians is that drivers should be feared more than non-drivers on transportation issues, or that pro-auto is populist.  I find this surprising given the large number of people who don’t have cars and who do walk, ride, and use public transportation in NYC, but what do I know.  Brad Lander seems to be the only pol actually embracing and staking a claim on the future at this point.  Bloomberg put some shots on goal, but everyone else seems to be stalling and hedging.

  • Bill of Goods (and bads)

    Funny, the Public Advocate didn’t seem to have any problem with the ESDC and Forest City Ratner not showing “a willingness to respect the input of residents and community leaders” when it came to steamrolling the Atlantic Yards project through the middle of Brooklyn without any City Council or Community Board input whatsoever.

  • Mark Walker

    This is the difference between being a real Public Advocate and merely using the office as a platform to run for mayor.

  • Shemp

    Minor pol going nowhere – who cares? 

  • Constituent

    Wrong. BDB is your next mayor.

  • Larry Littlefield

    What would a public advocate be?

    There are advocates for producers of public services, the unions and contractors, who want to be paid more for less.

    There are advocates for wealthy and corporate taxpayers who don’t want to pay for public services.

    There are no advocates for consumers of public services.  But becomming one is no way to collect campaign contributions.

    Just once, I’d like to see someone ask “is this what we deserve in exchange for just about the highest taxes as a share of personal income in the U.S.?”  Instead of demanding that the tax burden be reduced by cutting services, or taxes be increased or else less in services will be provided.

  • Park Sloper

    Bill and his office were very helpful in a behind-the-scenes kind of way on the 9th Street bike lane fight which, in many ways, was a smaller version of the madness now underway on PPW.

    State Senator Eric Adams was really coming out against the 9th Street bike lane and Bill took him aside, talked to him, and got him to stop advocating against the project. That was extremely helpful. I appreciated the quiet, effective approach that Bill took in this case. He wasn’t just out for the headlines.

  • Doug McCracken

    Is this a typo? Transportation Alternatives is showcasing DiBlasio and not Brad Lander? DiBlasio should be heckled. He’s part of the problem. He’s playing political games with street safety while real people are being killed and injured. What is Trans Alts thinking here? They kiss DiBlasio’s ring and he’s nice to them when he is mayor? That’s a formula for bicyclists to get ignored. The squeaky wheel gets the grease. Drivers are screaming louder than bicyclists. They are getting listened to.

  • Anonymous

    I’ll reserve judgment on the guy, even if TA courting him shows they’re running scared about Life After Bloomberg/JSK.

  • Anonymous

    Maybe they can get him on-the-record about something positive before the campaign heats up. Lander is already a hero.

  • Anonymous

    Maybe they can get him on-the-record about something positive before the campaign heats up. Lander is already a hero.

  • Jjustive

    Wow.  So the guy is not a knee jerk liberal. He actually thinks.  Pedesrians need protection from bicylists. The solution to every traffic issue is not tortuing people who must drive.  I have neaver heard of anyone ever being killed or injured by a car that was stopped at a red light.  Most pedestians who are hurt are crossing against the signal, or not in the crosswalk or not paying attention to what is happening around them.  It has nothing to do with speeding.


How Bill de Blasio and John Liu Can Stand Up for Transit Riders

Contrary to popular belief, the mayor isn’t the only elected official with a say in New York City transportation policy. So in this installment of Streetsblog’s series on Michael Bloomberg’s third term, we’re switching things up a bit. We asked New York’s most experienced transit advocate, Gene Russianoff of the Straphangers Campaign, how Comptroller-elect John […]

Bratton: NYPD Will Devote “Intensive Focus” to Traffic Violence

At a press conference this afternoon for the ceremonial swearing in of Bill Bratton as police commissioner, Mayor Bill de Blasio took the microphone to express his administration’s commitment to its Vision Zero goal of eliminating traffic fatalities within ten years. Bratton followed up with more remarks about how the department will prioritize street safety, saying NYPD […]