Judge Sides With City Over NBBL in Preliminary Procedural Question

In the opening round of the court case against the Prospect Park West bike lane, the city says that the judge sided with its lawyers on the procedural question at stake in today’s hearing. Said a spokesperson for the city’s Law Department, which is representing the defense in the case:

Today’s court appearance mainly covered scheduling issues. At the appearance, the petitioners made an application to the Court requesting permission to engage in discovery (i.e. requests for documents and questioning witnesses under oath) before the Court considers the merits of the case (i.e. the petitioners’ Article 78 petition and DOT’s response). Discovery is typically not permitted in an Article 78 proceeding like this one. The petitioners’ application was denied; however, the Court will again consider the application when it considers the case merits on June 22. (Note: The June 22 hearing was previously scheduled for June 15 and was moved back today.)

In other words, while no final decisions were made, and the opponents of the bike lane could be granted discovery next month, the city says it won the first round. Legal eagle Streetsblog readers are invited to interpret further in the comments.

Said city attorney Mark Muschenheim, “We are pleased that the Court agreed with us on this procedural issue today. We are confident that the Court will give similar careful consideration to the merits of the case when they are argued on June 22.”

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

JSK Counters Markowitz Affidavit; No Decision on PPW Bike Lane Case Today

|
Transportation Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan has submitted an affidavit countering Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz’s assertion that the Prospect Park West bike lane was installed as a trial. The rest of the news coming from today’s hearing in Brooklyn Supreme Court once again centers on procedural maneuvering. There was no decision on the Prospect Park West […]

NBBL Subpoenas Not Yet Sanctioned By the Court, But Embraced By the Post

|
Two hours after Streetsblog published a post on Monday about the City University of New York’s refusal to disclose former DOT Commissioner Iris Weinshall’s correspondence about the Prospect Park West redesign, bike lane opponents spun up their publicity machine and spat out a press release from their PR firm, LCG Communications [PDF]. The release informed […]

Sotomayor’s Eminent Domain Stance: What Does It Mean for Cities?

|
Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor is dominating the conversation in Washington as analysts begin  to dig into her past rulings. And while she has yet to weigh in on abortion, the judge has spoken loud and clear on an issue of interest to livable streets advocates: eminent domain. Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor (Photo: Gothamist) […]