With No Separated Busway on 34th Street, What’s Next for BRT in NYC?

A physically separated busway won't be coming to 34th Street. Will New York City bus riders ever get one? Image: NYC DOT

The walkback of the city’s plans for 34th Street from a physically separated transitway to a package of painted lanes and bus bulbs was unquestionably a defeat for bus riders on the extremely congested street. While features like off-board fare payment, scheduled to go into effect this summer, will provide a speed boost to buses, riders won’t be able to go crosstown as quickly as if they had lanes free from encroachment.

What does the city’s decision on 34th Street mean for the future of bus rapid transit across the rest of the city, however? We spoke with two transit advocates to find out.

It seems likely that without physical separation on 34th Street, there won’t be physical separation on any bus lanes implemented before the end of the Bloomberg Administration. (The remaining routes in the city’s first phase of BRT rollout — on the Nostrand Avenue corridor in Brooklyn and Hylan Boulevard in Staten Island — are scheduled to debut in the next two years and do not include physically separated lanes.) Preliminary plans for the 34th Street route were first presented to the public in April 2008, a full three years ago, and the planning process for the project is scheduled to continue through the end of 2011. At that rate, any physically separated bus project would be at least partially under the authority of a new mayor and new DOT.

“A number of the environmental and transportation groups are starting to recognize that the next administration after Bloomberg is going to have to answer to us on where they stand on these issues that have been wildly popular for New Yorkers,” said Kate Slevin of the Tri-State Transportation Campaign.

Though a new physically separated busway is unlikely to be constructed in the next three years, said Joan Byron of the Pratt Center for Community Development, “Planning can happen and dialogue with stakeholders can happen that make it a lot more likely that the next phase is gets built and has those features.” Byron said she hopes that the BRT team at DOT can assemble a coalition along its next routes that can politically lock in full-featured bus improvements. “There are workers and residents and employers in the outer boroughs who would love to have this problem of a Select Bus route running by their door,” she said.

DOT’s plans for 34th Street were scaled back at least in part because of the opposition of powerful Midtown landowners, including Macy’s. Both Slevin and Byron argued that the politics of 34th Street, dominated by large and often iconic institutions, aren’t likely to be replicated on most other routes. “34th Street is a higher profile street than many of the other streets in, say, the outer boroughs,” argued Slevin.

“It’s such a unique case,” agreed Byron. she pointed out that not only does 34th Street have a different set of stakeholders than the proposed routes for the BRT program’s second phase, it’s a physically different kind of street. “It’s a short route,” she said. On a longer route, the total time savings from physical separation are larger, making the case for separation easier to make. Additionally, Byron argued, “there are probably few long routes where you can continuously have physical separation.” Future routes, she predicted, will be more likely to move back and forth from separated to unseparated lanes as the street width, traffic patterns, and adjoining land uses shift, providing DOT with more flexibility in its planning.

While both Slevin and Byron were optimistic that the BRT program will continue to move forward and New York’s bus riders will someday get physically separated lanes, Slevin underlined the fact that such victories aren’t inevitable. Said Slevin, “Bus riders and other people in New York who support improved bus service need to be more vocal. People need to speak out.”

  • Let’s organize bus riders to monitor the 34th street after the redesign. Whenever a private vehicle is blocking a bus in the bus lane, we’ll come out with signs, chants, and drums, and make it so loud and unpleasant that the driver moves. When the police come to try to stop us, we’ll shift tactics and insist that the police clear the lane.

  • People need to read the link re. Macy’s opposition. It’s ridiculous. Thanksgiving Day balloons trump all? Really?

  • 34th street didn’t go perfectly, but i really hope the other routes do. It’d be such a huge save and congestion eliminator in the outer boroughs, especially where you have long wide streets of asphalt…. Queens Blvd, Woodhaven Blvd, even Atlantic Avenue into Queens perhaps?

  • how about separated bike lanes for 34th Street?

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The New York City Bus Lane Blues: Paint Is Not Enough

|
Separated bus lanes. Elected officials are calling for them. The next version of enhanced bus service on 34th Street may include them. Why does New York City need them? Well, take a look at how the city’s current crop of bus lanes are working out for riders. Streetfilms’ Robin Urban Smith went on a couple […]

Tonight: Give DOT Your Ideas for the Future of 34th Street

|
Will NYPD cruisers and other bus lane blockers steer clear of the next transit improvement on 34th Street? Photo: Chris O’Leary. Last September DOT and the MTA launched the 34th Street bus lane, New York City’s second Select Bus Service route. You could say it’s had some growing pains. Bus riders aren’t getting the speedy, […]

A Transit Miracle on 34th Street

|
NYC DOT is proposing to turn Manhattan’s 34th Street into a river-to-river "transitway." In what she half-jokingly called "probably the first-ever co-presentation" between their two agencies, Department of Transportation Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan stood with New York City Transit President Howard Roberts earlier this week to unveil the city’s current Bus Rapid Transit program in its […]

34th Street Select Bus Service Launches This Sunday

|
It’s no physically separated transitway, but bus riders can still get excited about the launch of Select Bus Service along 34th Street this Sunday. Additional SBS features should significantly speed trips along.34th Street, which already has dedicated lanes for the heavy crosstown bus traffic. By taking care of fare payment before riders board and allowing […]

City Scraps Pedestrian Plaza Option for 34th Street Transitway

|
Pedestrians who navigate Midtown’s crowded sidewalks won’t get as much as they could have from the proposed 34th Street Transitway. The Times reported last night that NYC DOT will not pursue plans for a pedestrian plaza between Fifth Avenue and Sixth Avenue as part of the project. The plaza was the focus of serialized attacks […]

DOT Announces Five Bus Rapid Transit Corridors

|
Sketches from an internal BRT Study depicting the three general types of stations: A) Major Station: Includes extended canopy with windscreens and seating. Icon and full platform pavement treatment. B) Standard Station: Shelter with Icon and full platform pavement treatment. C) Minimum Station: For locations with narrow sidewalks: Icon and platform edge strip only. Bigger image […]