34th Street Has Changed Before, And It Can Change Again

Around 1928, streetcar tracks ran down Broadway and 34th Street. When they were ##http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive/pdf?res=F30912FE355F167B93C0A9178FD85F428385F9##ripped out of 34th Street in 1936##, it was a major event attended by Governor Al Smith and Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia. Photo: ##http://digitalgallery.nypl.org/nypldigital/dgkeysearchdetail.cfm?trg=1&strucID=407204&imageID=717406F&total=388&num=20&word=34th%20Street&s=1&notword=&d=&c=&f=&k=0&lWord=&lField=&sScope=&sLevel=&sLabel=&imgs=20&pos=40&e=w##New York Public Library.##

In the media hyperventilating over plans for 34th Street that led up to last night’s cancellation of the pedestrian plaza between Fifth and Sixth Avenues, the biggest constant was the fear of change. An editorial in the Observer on Tuesday summed up the strange preference for the status quo: “From river to river, 34th Street moves cars, trucks, buses and pedestrians as efficiently and quickly as humanly possible in one of the world’s most crowded pieces of real estate.”

There was no indication that improvement is achievable, nor any understanding that the least efficient modes on 34th Street — private cars and taxis — slow down the far greater number of people who take the bus, and make the street more dangerous and unpleasant for the even greater number of people on foot.

What the naysayers never seem to acknowledge is that 34th Street has changed and changed again over the course of New York City’s history. To argue that 34th Street should never change again is to argue that at some point in the mid-20th Century, the city’s planners hit on a solution that was perfect for all eternity.

Since then we’ve learned a lot about how traffic works. We know that traffic volumes are not constant, and that when streets change, drivers adjust their decisions and their behavior. We know that on 34th Street and other major crosstown streets in Manhattan, traffic is strangling transit service, slowing buses to walking speeds. And we know that other cities have successfully created transit malls in their central shopping and business districts.

So we’re posting some photos of what 34th Street once looked like, not because we want to return to the good old days, but to show that there’s nothing sacred about the current design of the city’s streets.

Looking back, it’s clear that at least until painted bus lanes were installed along 34th Street in 2008, the current configuration of the street gives more space to the automobile than any before it. In 1911, for example, the city took seven and a half feet from each sidewalk on 34th Street in order to widen the street. 34th Street has changed a lot, and it will have to change again to work well for New York City in the 21st Century.

In 1931, elevated railroad tracks shadowed the east end of 34th Street, taking New Yorkers to the ferry terminal. Photo: ##http://digitalgallery.nypl.org/nypldigital/dgkeysearchdetail.cfm?trg=1&strucID=401907&imageID=712109F&total=388&num=100&word=34th%20Street&s=1&notword=&d=&c=&f=&k=0&lWord=&lField=&sScope=&sLevel=&sLabel=&imgs=20&pos=115&e=w##New York Public Library.##
A clearer look at how much of the width of 34th Street went to streetcar tracks. Photo: ##http://digitalgallery.nypl.org/nypldigital/dgkeysearchdetail.cfm?trg=1&strucID=401945&imageID=712147F&total=388&num=260&word=34th%20Street&s=1&notword=&d=&c=&f=&k=0&lWord=&lField=&sScope=&sLevel=&sLabel=&imgs=20&pos=273&e=w##New York Public Library.##
In the 1890s, Herald Square was dominated by the el, with horse-drawn trolleys ferrying passengers along 34th Street. Photo: ##http://digitalgallery.nypl.org/nypldigital/dgkeysearchdetail.cfm?trg=1&strucID=409947&imageID=720146F&total=388&num=0&word=34th%20Street&s=1&notword=&d=&c=&f=&k=0&lWord=&lField=&sScope=&sLevel=&sLabel=&imgs=20&pos=1&e=w##New York Public Library.##
Pedestrians on 34th Street no longer have to worry about Greyhound buses crossing the sidewalk north of the old Penn Station. Photo: ##http://digitalgallery.nypl.org/nypldigital/dgkeysearchdetail.cfm?trg=1&strucID=401970&imageID=712172F&total=388&num=0&word=34th%20Street&s=1&notword=&d=&c=&f=&k=0&lWord=&lField=&sScope=&sLevel=&sLabel=&imgs=20&pos=12&e=w##New York Public Library.##
  • Bolwerk

    It’s funny reading about the celebrations of motorbuses replacing streetcars. It’s like celebrating having your office moved another 20 minutes from home.

  • zach

    I suppose those in the celebrations imagined what it said: replacing streetcars with buses. Instead the streetcars got replaced with cars and an occasional bus.

  • LazyReader

    Cars have been around for a hundred years. Automobile use usurped transit as the principal source of transportation as early as the 1920’s. Transit use peaked in the 40’s. At it’s inception cars we’re exclusive toys to the rich. No one complained when rich people we’re the only one to own car and have them on the streets. Now that everyone has cars, its a different story. I bet they don’t even spell hypocrite with an “H”.

  • Jay

    Passengers had good reason to celebrate replacing streetcars with buses at that historical moment. Those streetcars are not the modern operations we run today, and they suffered a lot of problems from running in mixed traffic that buses mitigate.

    Look at the pictures (or talk to people who have lived in Toronto, where they have only slowly been able to resolve some of these problems). You’ll start to understand some of the real concerns. First, look at where passengers boarded and alighted the vehicles: in the middle of the street, with no protection from vehicular traffic.

    Also, limited to fixed rails, they got stuck behind every left-turning vehicle waiting for a gap in traffic. Buses can change lanes and continue on the route with much less delay.

    Finally, consider that they were replacing older, noisy vehicles with spanking new, shiny, rubber-tire vehicles. The attractiveness should seem obvious.

    Can you make an argument that the change was short-sighted by focusing on the immediate operational issues, instead of the long-term operation of the overall street and broader transportation network? Sure, and it’s very easy for us in retrospect.

    But you can’t reasonably argue that they had no reason to view replacing streetcars with buses as an improvement at their point in time.

  • Jace

    LazyReader, not everyone owns a car, especially in NYC. Don’t be a “lazy thinker” as well. Cars are not going to be a viable form of transportation if energy prices keep rising as they are predicted to do. The free market will decide private motoring will go the way of the dodo.

  • Jace, I’m pretty sure that LazyReader is Randal O’Toole. It would take a lot to convince him of anything, but it’s good to counter his propaganda. Thanks for fighting on.

  • Jay

    To effectively fight for better transit, having strong arguments that address all the concerns is really important.

    This post is interesting, but it seems to suggest the only issue is passenger transportation. I think a lot of the concerns that actually surfaced involved deliveries.

    If you can address those, you’ll have a better case.

  • Bolwerk

    Reducing POV use improves the ability to receive deliveries, and I have yet to see any proposal that harms the ability of any building in midtown to receive deliveries. Even the pedestrian plaza only means they’ll require more footwork.

    (Why would a plaza preclude the ability to receive door-front deliveries anyway? A smartly done pedestrian plaza would still allow large deliveries of things like furniture and large appliances to be delivered by permit. It’s unfortunate if the DOT isn’t considering that.)

  • MartinOne

    I live on 34th. Neighbors opposed to the malling tend to be vocal and old. Others aren’t paying much attention.

    Deliveries: I would hate it if the city took away Fresh Direct access to Sanka and Depends. But in this regard, I have faith that FD would find me.

    Bad for Business: How many of you merchants on 34th have autos pull up by the curb and drop off customers or load up their trunks? Maybe think about taking advantage of increased foot traffic and bus access.

    Diversion of traffic to 33rd and 35th: These are already way congested. IMO, traffic increases to a point, after which it becomes so crowded that nobody travels there anymore (thanks, Casey S.) So a slight shift in usage + walking and buses = no change

    Emergency (hospital) vehicles: This is an empirical question, but it sure seems like ambulances could share bus lanes, and the result would be a quicker trip.

    Property Value: For residents, 34th and environs offers no intrinsic attributes other than access to more desirable destinations. This is a substantial attraction. Faster and more pleasant access to increasingly attractive far-west midtown would be very nice.

  • Here’s a solution I’m sure would make the Post happy –

    Mid Manhattan Expressway http://www.flickr.com/photos/vanshnookenraggen/3311102680/


DOT Plans to Bring NYC’s First Separated Busway to 34th Street

What the 34th Street transitway might look like between Fifth and Sixth Avenues. Image: NYCDOT When DOT Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan hinted last Tuesday that bolder ideas were on the way for bus rapid transit in New York City, she apparently meant "next week." The DOT website now displays an updated plan for the next phase […]

A Transit Miracle on 34th Street

NYC DOT is proposing to turn Manhattan’s 34th Street into a river-to-river "transitway." In what she half-jokingly called "probably the first-ever co-presentation" between their two agencies, Department of Transportation Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan stood with New York City Transit President Howard Roberts earlier this week to unveil the city’s current Bus Rapid Transit program in its […]

Tonight: Speak Up for the 34th Street Transitway

The big event for the week of Thanksgiving (and the only calendar item we’re highlighting) is the public forum on the 34th Street Transitway put on by Community Board 5 tonight. It’s a critical moment to speak up for prioritizing walking and transit on one of NYC’s busiest, most iconic streets. Passengers on 34th Street […]

Dysfunction Rules at CB 6 Discussion of Select Bus Service

Manhattan CB 6 could have used this reminder of who actually uses 34th Street. Graphic: NYCDOT Last night’s meeting of Manhattan Community Board 6’s transportation committee was a reminder of how opaque and undemocratic New York City’s public review process can be, at its worst. Between a mismanaged meeting that descended into chaos and a parade […]