Car-Sharing and the Case for a “Low-Car Diet”

Anyone who makes any effort to live more sustainably has been there — facing the accusation that what you’re doing isn’t enough. That you’re compromising, and that your willingness to deviate from a purist approach invalidates your efforts. Sometimes these accusations come from within. And sometimes they make you want to give up. It’s the old problem of letting the perfect be the enemy of the good.

But the burden of living a sustainable life wholly without blemish, whatever that means, is in itself unsustainable — at least for a person within arm’s reach of mainstream American society. (Take a look at the very funny trailer for the upcoming documentary about the year Colin Beavan and his family spent when he decided to become No Impact Man.)

Which brings us to today’s post from the Streetsblog Network, from member blog BikePGH in Pittsburgh. BikePGH, which is a multifaceted organization promoting bicycling as transportation in that city, is going to have a table at an upcoming "Low-Car Diet" event hosted by Zipcar. The group’s project manager, Lou Fineberg, is already anticipating criticism, based on past experience. But he’s ready to face those who think "that BikePGH should stand on behalf of NO CARS not Low-Cars":

636495002_ae5aa67dc7.jpgPhoto by RcktManIL via Flickr.

Just for the record…advocating for NO CARS is pretty much the equivalent of advocating for NO BIKES. Is it really anyone’s business to demand what mode of transportation others use or don’t use? The U.S. was founded on the principle of freedom. Start taking away people’s freedom — their cars (thank you President Eisenhower and Jack Kerouac!), and people get all revolutionary…. I can just imagine a NO CAR movement forming and the militias that would arise to protect motorists’ rights…this is one battle that can be easily avoided.

One excellent way to avoid a motorist uprising and slowly wean ourselves from oil and cars much larger and faster than we need for urban use is to employ and support Zipcar and other car-share/ride-share options. Zipcar and services like it make the economic impact of driving hit home because each time we choose to drive we’re charged for it, and it makes most of us think two or three times before we decide to use a car, which helps keep more cars PARKED.

The routine, intermittent, often exorbitant car expenses we’ve come to take for granted aren’t so much associated with driving as they are with the car itself; and here in lies an important distinction. Currently car owners pay to keep cars. They do not pay to drive, it’s the rest of us that pay each time one of us chooses to drive in the form a poorer air quality and time lost associated with traffic congestion. Time and clean air are two of the most precious things people have on earth and the automobile has an interesting way of depleting us of both. We should be paying to drive instead of keeping cars because it’s the driving that costs society most.

Car share also provides an amazing opportunity to avoid the “second largest” financial burden the vast majority of Americans will likely come across in our lives — owning a car. That has HUGE implications for local economies because most of the money spent to operate a car goes to distant lands where they manufacture cars and produce oil. Car share is one of the best ways to invite addicted motorists to think differently about transportation without infringing upon people’s freedom to use a car.

The success of bicycle advocacy will be at best limited if we go at it alone, but when we develop strong partnerships with others that promote alternatives to single-passenger owner-occupied vehicles we dramatically increase support for mutual objectives — to make our streets safer and less congested. This is no longer a fringe perspective. In fact thoughts like these echo similar ones being expressed by Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood. In a recent post on his blog LaHood makes clear “we must implement policies and programs that reduce vehicle miles driven.” As bicycle advocates this is an opportunity to squarely put our agenda in the mainstream.

More from around the network: St. Louis Urban Workshop on how investing in transit could save that city millions of dollars; Cycling Solution meets David Byrne in Budapest and talks biking; and Green Wheels has some bad news for bike lanes in Humboldt, CA.

  • Sarah and others involved. Nice piece, thanks.

    We would very much like to publish a mildly edited and slightly reorganized version of it in World Streets — . But we need permission of all involved of course.

    Come on over to World Streets. It’s World Carshare month. (If you want to see only the articles on carsharing, click here. .)

    And some of you with a particular interest in the subject may wish to check out the World Carshare Consortium at – supporting carsharing world wide since 1997. No better place to start.

    Carsharing: The last nail in the coffin of Old Mobility.

  • I couldn’t agree more. Our family manages without owning a car in Budapest, but doing this depends to a large extent on the support we have from other modes of transport: excellent local mass transit, affordable taxis and great rail and bus links for excursions outside the city. I do most of my short trips by bike, but there are a variety of situations when something else is called for. It would be great if a car-sharing system opened in Budapest — it seems like a useful service and could be just the thing to get many people to give up their cars.

    As the blog said, advocates of transport cycling need to embrace alternatives like car sharing, public transport, smart spatial planning, etc, etc because they all work in concert to help people give up car ownership.


Another Step in Reducing Auto Dependence

If you’re a person who is accustomed to getting around the place you live without a car, you’ve probably spent at least some time trying to sell your auto-dependent friends on the concept. Maybe you’ve even gone so far as to map out a route for them so that they wouldn’t get frustrated. And sometimes […]

How Much Do Bicyclists Really Slow Down Drivers?

What’s really slowing these cars down? Probably not bikes. Photo by richardmasoner via Flickr. What is it about bicycles that drives some motorists so crazy? Anyone who’s ever ridden a bike more than a handful of times in this country has experienced it. The honking, the rude remarks, the vehicles speeding past with drivers shouting […]

Warning: Driving Could Be Hazardous to Your Health

Last week, the European Parliament proposed that car advertisements throughout the EU include tobacco-style health warnings about the environmental impact of automobiles. The New York Times reported: Under the plan, 20 percent of the space or time of any auto ad would have to be set aside for information on a car’s fuel consumption and […]

Your Eyes on Your Streets: Space Hogs

Our first user-generated slide show, on bike traffic, was a lot of fun. (See it here.) This time out, we’re looking for pictures that show cars — the most inefficient form of transportation — hogging public space. Reader Evan Goldin has already sent along a few, including the image at right, which he snapped with […]

Of Red Lights, Helmets, and Bike Lanes

From Streetsblog San Francisco contributor Chris Carlsson:  The Oregon Legislature has flushed an effort to bring the Idaho rolling stop law to that state. It’s a bit of a surprise, given both the simple and proven efficacy of allowing cyclists to make rolling stops, as well as Oregon’s big reputation as a bastion of cycling […]