Shining a Light on Albany’s Bus Camera Vote

bus_lane.jpgA source sends along this roll call of the State Assembly transportation committee’s vote on bus-mounted enforcement cameras. The names come from the official record; whether the record accurately reflects who raised a hand and who didn’t is not certain, for reasons explained below. Note that the vote was on whether to table the bill, so "Yes" actually means "No" to better bus lane enforcement. You can match names to districts here.

YES: (14)
Gantt, Lafayette, Weisenberg, Hoyt, Perry, DelMonte, Latimer, Lupardo, Alessi, Gabryszak, Hyer-Spencer, Titone, Schimel, Spano.

NO: (11)
Cusick, Millman, R. Diaz, Maisel, McDonough, Thiele, Bacalles, Errigo, Reilich, Giglio, Tobacco.

Among the "Yes" column, Lafayette, Perry, Hyer-Spencer, and Titone represent districts in the five boroughs.

Multiple sources told Streetsblog that the vote was held soon after committee chair David Gantt called the meeting, at around two in the afternoon. They described a rushed scene in which advocates and legislators were scrambling to make it to the room where the meeting was held. The location of committee meetings is not known, even to legislators, until the chair announces it.

Not everyone on the committee made it in time for the vote. According to parliamentary rules, the votes of absent members are automatically counted as "Yes" votes. There is some time between the committee vote — in this case, a show of hands — and the official recording of the roll call. During this gap, one source told us, legislators can change how their vote is recorded, but the tally of the committee vote cannot be altered.

That clears things up, right?

Readers emailing their Assembly reps to voice displeasure with Albany’s opacity might consider copying their messages to Speaker Sheldon Silver.

Photo: julieleone/Flickr

  • Davis

    I’m not sure what the hell is going on up in Albany but it definitely isn’t democracy and it definitely isn’t benefiting the people of New York City.

    That is for sure.

  • Larry Littlefield

    You can’t dismiss the possibility that legislators voting “no” received permission to do so after it was determined the vote would go “yes,” and that such members are actually opposed due to the opposition of some special interest. I don’t believe anything up there other than the results as they affect me.

  • When even an openly gay legislator like Matthew Titone can’t vote for a bill that he *sponsored*, you know the system’s broken.

    Of course, he, O’Donnell, Glick, and Kellner were of no help with congestion pricing, either.

    Although it’s Pride Month, I can’t say I feel much pride in our LGBT representation up in Albany.

  • da

    Maybe Gantt will come around on this issue once he figures out how to steer the contract to some of his cronies.

  • I think I’ve just lost all faith in government.

  • Larry Littlefield

    “I think I’ve just lost all faith in government.”

    It’s about time.

    In any event, in a further irony I believe some of the dedicated MTA taxes, collected only in the Metropolitan Transportation District downstate, have been used to pay for transit systems upstate, including Rochester.

  • Spud Spudly

    WHAAAA?!?!?! That is insane. The location of the meeting isn’t even known in advance? And then late legislators can change how their vote is recorded but not how it’s tallied???

    Just shoot me already.

  • Streetsman


    Why in God’s name are they voting against this when it comes endorsed by the City Council? I am livid I could just slap them! Why are they blocking our efforts to improve our local transit system?!

    I want to drive up to this jerk’s district and tear out all the traffic lights and tell him that we here in New York City don’t think that traffic lights are a good idea for their streets. If it causes congestion, tough luck. Oh, unless you get your traffic lights from my buddy here.

  • Paul

    This country is effed up. Maybe we need a little more iron fists.

  • Anonymouse

    “Maybe we need a little more iron fists.” No, from the sounds of it, we need actual democratic proceedings, not an attempt to subvert democracy. Albany sounds like the Soviet bureaucracy.


How David Gantt Sent Bus Cameras to Defeat in Albany

After state lawmakers dealt a setback to the city's Bus Rapid Transit plans, Streetsblog looked into how Assembly transportation committee chairman David Gantt was able to bring down a bill that reportedly enjoyed majority support among his members and won approval in the New York City Council by a 40 to 7 vote.

Silver Fails to Stop Bus Lane Camera Bill in Assembly [Updated]

Update 10:06 p.m.: The story has been updated to reflect the final official vote tally in the Assembly of 79-60. Tonight, the Senate passed its companion bill with an unofficial vote tally of 51 in favor and 8 opposed. The bill to preserve and expand the use of NYC’s bus lane enforcement cameras squeaked by in a rare contested vote in the Assembly […]

Silver Gives Gantt Two More Years Atop Transpo Committee

Sheldon Silver and David Gantt On Thursday, Sheldon Silver re-appointed Rochester’s David Gantt to chair the Assembly Transportation Committee (Excel spreadsheet via Daily Politics). Gantt is the chairman who engineered the defeat of bus lane enforcement cameras last June, when six co-sponsors of the bill wound up voting against it in his committee. With the […]

Quinn and Vacca Urge City Council Support for Bus Cameras

New York City’s plans for dedicated bus lanes, as proposed for the Nostrand Avenue corridor in Brooklyn, depend on Albany’s willingness to allow camera enforcement. Image: NYCDOT City Council Speaker Christine Quinn and transportation committee chair Jimmy Vacca gave better service for New York City bus riders a boost yesterday, speaking in favor of bus […]

David Gantt, Longtime Foe of Red-Light Cams, Changes Tune

One of Albany’s chief foes of automated traffic enforcement appears to have softened his opposition to red-light cameras, but allegations of patronage may taint his turnaround. For years, State Assembly Member David Gantt, a Rochester Democrat, has used his position as chair of the transportation committee to block the expansion of red-light cameras in New […]