Promising Aid, Lawmakers Ask MTA Not to Raise Fares

Following weeks of relative silence on the issue, state legislators have written a letter to the MTA asking it to postpone a planned fare hike in order to give Albany time to work up a funding increase.

Lawmakers and transit advocates made the announcement today at City Hall.

City Room reports:

If the authority holds off until next April, it would give Gov.
Eliot Spitzer and the Legislature “a chance to provide additional funds
needed in order to avoid a fare increase,” the lawmakers and advocates
wrote in their letter.

“Fare increases are a last resort,” said Assemblyman Richard L.
Brodsky, a Westchester Democrat. “After 12 years of neglect under the
Pataki administration, we want to work with the M.T.A., the city and
state governments to change the failed policies of the past.”

The letter said: “There are many strong reasons for increasing
government aid to the M.T.A. There has been no permanent new state
operating aid to M.T.A. New York City Transit in at least a dozen

The letter was signed by New York City Comptroller William C.
Thompson Jr. and 22 Assembly members: Adam Bradley, James F. Brennan,
Richard L. Brodsky, Kevin A. Cahill, William Colton, Ruben Diaz Jr.,
Richard N. Gottfried, Michael N. Gianaris, Carl E. Heastie, Hakeem S.
Jeffries, Janele Hyre-Spencer, Micah Z. Kellner, David G. McDonough,
Joan L. Millman, Mike Spano, Catherine T. Nolan, Daniel J. O’Donnell,
N. Nick Perry, Linda B. Rosenthal, Robert K. Sweeney, Harvey Weisenberg
and Keith L. T. Wright.

Whether legislators can stop focusing on one another long enough to advance a substantive public policy initiative (with or without the use of medication) remains to be seen.

  • Larry Littlefield

    One of the failed policies of the past was deferring fare increases (in fact cutting fares given discounts) for years as costs rose, borrowing the difference, followed by a massive, massive increase.

    The Assemblymembers need not worry. There is ample need for far more state funding than the MTA is likely to get, over and above the fare increase and even any “congestion fee.” Particularly if another failed policy of the past, a pension enhancement, is repeated.

    By the way the policies of the past didn’t fail for everyone. Those who cashed in and moved out made out pretty well. And they are the ones who mattered to all memembers of the NY State Legislature. These folks just want to deflect accountability for what they have done.


State Senate on Transit Funding Meltdown: It Wasn’t Us

After omitting bridge tolls from last spring’s transit funding package, then raiding the "piggy bank" to the tune of $143 million, Albany’s neglect of the MTA has left millions of transit-dependent New Yorkers in the lurch. Yet lawmakers have shown no inclination to get to work patching the agency’s ever-widening budget hole, much less coming […]

Twenty-One NYC Reps Back Brodsky’s Student Fare Falsehood

On Friday we noted that Assembly Member Richard Brodsky’s latest anti-transit argument — that "the actual cost of free and discounted student fares is close to zero" — doesn’t hold water. A letter from Brodsky addressed to MTA CEO Jay Walder calls for reinstating student MetroCards, laying blame for the program’s potential elimination at the […]

MTA Budget Proposes Severe Service Cuts, Perpetual Fare Hikes

Elliot "Lee" Sander As expected, the proposed 2009 MTA budget is rife with grim news. In addition to various cutbacks at the administrative level, the budget and 2009-2012 financial plan — minus an infusion of aid from the city, state or federal government — will have a direct impact on transit customers in the form […]

Transit Operating Aid Bill Doesn’t Fly With Major D.C. Transit Group

A burgeoning congressional push to let urban transit agencies tap federal funds for operating their systems is not sitting well with the transit industry’s largest D.C. lobbying group, the American Public Transportation Association (APTA). A rail car from New York City’s transit authority, one of APTA’s biggest members. (Photo: TreeHugger) Paul Dean, APTA’s government relations […]