Safety First? True Once, but U.S. Now Lags in Road Deaths

times-graph_1.jpg

Fatalities per billion kilometers driven from 1970 to 2005 for selected countries

Every once in a while you can find something other than a car for sale in the New York Times’ Sunday Automobiles section. This weekend, Tanya Mohn points out that in 1970 the United States ranked first in road safety worldwide. Today, the U.S. is one of the most dangerous places to drive in the industrialized world. That would help explain the Weekly Carnage.

"Here we are, probably the richest country in the world," said Barbara L. Harsha, executive director of the Governors Highway Safety Association, which represents state highway safety offices. "Why are other countries doing a better job than we are?"


Safety experts said the reasons were many. One, they said, was inadequate driver training.
Some countries require that teenagers have 100 hours behind the wheel before they receive a license, compared to about 6 in the United States.

But expert after expert said the real problem was one of culture. With personal freedom being a cornerstone of the United States, many states are loath to pass legislation that curtails them, even when it comes to road safety. So while the governments of other countries can easily pass laws to make driving safer, like a national ban on hand-held cellphone use, those laws here are left up to the states to impose, and that is often not so easy.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The Weekly Carnage

|
This week, New York State authorities launched a probe into the gap between Long Island Rail Road and Metro-North trains and platforms. After that, the National Transportation Safety Board launched its own probe, which like the state’s follows the tragic death of a Minnesota teenager who fell through such a gap boarding an L.I.R.R. train on Aug. 5. These probes […]

The Weekly Carnage

|
Fatal Crashes (14 Killed This Week; 458 Killed This Year) Photo: G.N. Miller/New York Post Manhattan: DWI Driver Kills Delivery Worker (NY Post, Newsday) Yonkers, N.Y.: Driveway Death as Car Rolls Over Owner (Journal News, Newsday) Related: Car May Have Been Out of Gear (Journal News)  Bedford Hills, N.Y.: Driver, 20, Charged After His Brother Dies (Journal News) Newark: Pedestrian Killed (NJ.com) […]

The Weekly Carnage

|
Chad Rachman / S.I. Advance Police view Honda in which Michelle Arout, 17, died in Veterans Road drag race. Fatal Crashes (15 Killed This Week; 369 Killed This Year) Staten Island: Passenger Dead After 90 mph Teen Crash (Daily News) Related: Police Finger Speed-Gas Canister as Pals Mourn (NY Times) Related: Teen’s Death Too Much […]

The Weekly Carnage

|
Woman Pinned Under SUV Saved by UES Passers-By (Daily News) Hartford Man Killed By His Own Vehicle (Hartford Courtant) N.J. State Trooper Runs Stop Sign, Killing 2 Sisters (Star-Ledger) Husband Killed, Wife Injured in Crash on L.I.E. (Newsday) 2 Early Morning Crashes Send 9 to Hospital (Star-Ledger) 1996 Hit-and-Run Driver Arrested After Car Chase (Star-Ledger) Father Accused of […]

The Weekly Carnage

|
Fatal Crashes (10 this week; 640 this year) Midtown: Cyclist doored, killed by truck (Streetsblog) Queens: Youth with suspended license, two dead, above (News) Related: Sports car was college gift, below (Post) Bergen County, N.J.: Relief turns to horror, two dead (Post) Related: American Ballet Theater mourns death of leading dancer (Post) Setauket, L.I.: Two […]