State Senate Fails to Act After Assembly Approves Speed Camera Expansion

The bill didn't make it out of late-night negotiations in the Senate as the Albany legislative session came to an end. No Republicans are listed as sponsors of the bill.

Senate Republicans Marty Golden and Andrew Lanza.
Senate Republicans Marty Golden and Andrew Lanza.

The State Senate adjourned its 2017 session last night without taking action on a bill to expand the use of speed cameras near schools.

Legislation supported by Mayor de Blasio and safe streets advocates would have allowed for speed cameras in 50 additional school zones each year for the next three years, more than doubling the 140 school zones in the city that currently have automated speed enforcement.

Earlier in the day, the Assembly passed the bill by an 85-31 margin, but Senate leadership, meeting behind closed doors late into the night, declined to bring it to the floor for a vote.

Speeding is the leading cause of traffic fatalities in New York City, according to a report released earlier this month by DOT [PDF]. Current law allows the city to deploy automated speed cameras in 140 school zones during school hours, leaving most locations in the city unprotected at most times. Eight-five percent of traffic fatalities and injuries occur in locations or during times of the day where automated enforcement is not permitted.

Meanwhile, cameras have reduced the incidence of speeding by 63 percent at locations where they’ve been installed.

While Albany debated the bill, Transportation Alternatives recorded driver speeds during school hours outside schools without cameras. At one school in Bay Ridge, they found 92 percent of motorists exceeding the speed limit.

“This is a life and death issue,” said TransAlt Deputy Director Caroline Samponaro. “The fact that it got trapped late night in negotiations on the Senate side, knowing that the Assembly had voted for it — there’s really no good excuse or reason for that, and it’s regular New Yorkers, New York City kids, who are going to suffer the consequences.”

Eight-five percent of crashes resulting in injuries or deaths occurred in areas where speed cameras are not permitted. Image: DOT
Eight-five percent of crashes resulting in injuries or deaths occurred in areas where speed cameras are not permitted. Image: DOT

The Senate is controlled by Republicans and the Independent Democratic Conference. Jose Peralta of Queens, a member of the IDC, sponsored the Senate bill, but the Republican support necessary for passage never materialized. Staten Island GOP rep Andrew Lanza last month called for an end to the whole speed camera program, and Brooklyn’s Marty Golden, the senior Republican representing a New York City district, is not listed as a sponsor.

Several provisions were weakened in response to GOP requests, including a reduction in the number of school zones where cameras would be authorized, from 750 to 290. No one knows what happened behind closed doors last night among the Republicans and the IDC except the legislators themselves, but those concessions apparently didn’t move Golden, Majority Leader John Flanagan, and the rest of their conference to act.

Speaking last night on the Senate floor, Senator Jeff Klein, who leads the IDC, called on legislators to come back for a special session to pass the bill. “It’s something as simple as making sure people don’t speed around schools — you would think that’s a no-brainer,” Klein said.

  • Jeff

    Awesome. I’m gonna rent a car and drive 36 mph in a school zone to celebrate, because apparently we live in a society in which the ability to do so is valued above kids’ ability to walk to school safely. You know what they say–if you can’t beat ’em, join ’em!

  • gneiss

    Cowards. Declining to take action means they don’t want to go on the record as being in opposition.

  • martinjsxx

    Drive 25 mph in NYC with a police car behind you and they will tailgate you like any other driver would.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Safety of NYC Streets Again Depends on State Senator Marty Golden

|
The Assembly yesterday passed legislation that would expand NYC’s speed camera program by 120 cameras, bringing the total to 140. The bill, which also allows speed cameras in Nassau and Suffolk counties, was referred to the Senate rules committee this morning, bypassing the transportation committee. Rules is the last stop before a bill moves to the floor […]

Cuomo Signs Speed Cam Bill Into Law

|
Governor Andrew Cuomo has signed the speed camera bill into law, enabling New York City to use automated enforcement technology to deter speeding in school zones. The law lets the city operate 20 mobile speed enforcement cameras in school speed zones when school or after-school activities are in session, plus a short buffer of time […]

Van Bramer + 24 Council Members Call on Albany to Allow More Speed Cams

|
City Council Majority Leader Jimmy Van Bramer, 24 of his colleagues, and Public Advocate Letitia James are calling on the state legislature to expand NYC’s life-saving automated speed enforcement program. Assembly Bill 9861, sponsored by Deborah Glick, would allow New York City to expand its speed camera program to every school in the five boroughs. It would […]

Teachers Union Wants Speed Cameras at #EverySchool

|
The United Federation of Teachers, which represents the teachers and para-educators of the New York City public school system, wants Albany to let NYC install life-saving speeding enforcement cameras at all its schools. Current state law limits NYC to 140 speed cams that must be placed near school zones and operate during school activities. That means 93 percent of schools […]