Relief for Riders on Brooklyn’s Busiest Bus Route as B46 SBS Debuts

B46_SBS
Riders boarding the B46 SBS at the connection from the 3 and 4 trains no longer have to wait for everyone to dip a Metrocard. Photo: David Meyer

The B46 on Utica Avenue is Brooklyn’s busiest bus route, with more than 44,000 trips each weekday. Like other high-volume NYC bus routes, the B46 has also been susceptible to paralyzing traffic congestion and a boarding process that takes ages, as each passenger dips a Metrocard at the front of the bus. But B46 riders got some relief from slow, unreliable service this weekend with the launch of Select Bus Service.

With camera-enforced bus lanes, off-board fare collection, fewer stops, and priority for buses at traffic signals, NYC DOT and the MTA implemented a suite of improvements similar to the nearby B44, where travel times improved 15-30 percent after the debut of SBS.

Dedicated bus lanes were implemented on Utica Avenue in 2014 and 2015. Image: DOT
Bus lanes were implemented on Utica Avenue in 2014 and 2015, but camera enforcement didn’t begin until this month. Image: DOT

Where it runs through East Flatbush, the B46 serves some of the densest neighborhoods in the city outside of convenient walking access to the subway. (Last year, Mayor de Blasio suggested extending the subway from Eastern Parkway down Utica Avenue.)

DOT implemented bus lanes and transit signal priority on Utica in 2014 and 2015. On Sunday, off-board payment, bus stop consolidation, and camera enforcement of the bus lanes took effect, though drivers who violate the bus lanes will receive warnings instead of fines for the first 60 days. Bus bulbs — which enable passengers to board without the bus driver pulling in and out of traffic — will be installed next year.

On the evening commute yesterday, Elizabeth Bruno, who takes the B46 one stop between her home and the Utica Avenue subway station on Eastern Parkway, said she has noticed improvements even though riders are still adjusting to the service. “Because it’s new, I think, it takes a little while for people to get accustomed to, but once they get accustomed to [it], I think it will be fine,” Bruno said. “The Select is moving really faster because you don’t stop at every stop.”

“With the Select, it has gotten a little better,” said Yvette Glover, who rides the B46 every day from Eastern Parkway to Broadway and Myrtle. “I believe it’s a good thing.”

The B46 SBS runs from DeKalb Avenue to Kings Plaza, replacing the old B46 Limited that ran the length of the route but made express stops between DeKalb Avenue and Avenue H. The local B46, which previously stopped at DeKalb Avenue, will now make local stops from Kings Plaza all the way to the Williamsburg terminus.

Despite its very high ridership, the new B46 doesn’t have the articulated buses with three doors that have helped reduce crowding and speed boarding on other SBS routes. Nor will the bus lanes be in effect at all times. DOT originally proposed 24-hour bus lanes, but enforcement was cut to 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. in response to “community feedback,” according to an agency presentation — and gripes from local elected officials.

Capital improvements in 2017 will bring safety measures -- like the concrete islands on Eastern Parkway picture here -- to points along the B46 route. Image: DOT
Capital improvements in 2017 will bring safety measures — like the concrete islands on Eastern Parkway picture here — along the B46 route. Image: DOT

As a candidate in 2013, de Blasio pledged to phase in 20 “world-class bus rapid transit” lines, which then became the somewhat less ambitious policy goal of implementing 13 SBS lines in his first term (on top of the seven routes implemented by the Bloomberg administration). The B46 is the sixth SBS route to launch in de Blasio’s two and half years as mayor, with two more scheduled to debut this fall.

In a statement this morning, the mayor lauded the improvements for bus riders and highlighted the street safety improvements — the project includes sidewalk extensions and turn bans along the route. “Back in 2013, we made a strong commitment to expand the number of communities that see the benefits of Select Bus Service,” de Blasio said. “For communities with limited subway options, SBS is a winning formula that transforms bus commutes by saving precious time while also suiting our Vision Zero goals by making sometimes dangerous streets like Utica much safer.”

  • BBnet3000

    7am to 7pm is still a hell of a lot better than the rush hour only bus lanes. Nothing like sitting in traffic on a crush-loaded bus on Fordham Road mid-day watching the bus lane full of parked cars go by at 5mph.

  • com63

    Do these buses have USB chargers? That will really make people happy. /s

  • AnoNYC

    Speaking about that, I hope they come fitted with USB type-c because almost every new phone will use that format by this time next year.

    What an embarrassment that would be.

  • AnoNYC

    Agreed. That mid-day gap is frustrating as a rider.

  • BBnet3000

    The base port is the same, you’ve got to plug in your own cable on those buses.

  • CYCLIST

    Streetsblog, your pro-bus bias is showing… all these articles about bus routes, which don’t mention cycling at all! Are cyclists second-class citizens now on Streetsblog too?

  • AnoNYC

    USB type-c is supposed to replace all prior formats. Phones are going to come with the same connection at both ends. Riders are going to have to bring an individual cable for use on the bus only most likely.

    I would also hope that they include high speed charging.

  • JudenChino

    Yah, it’ll be like how every treadmill tried having an iPod/iPhone port but invariably, whatever treadmill you use, doesn’t actually work with your iPhone. Like, nice try. But nope.

  • BBnet3000

    Oh, TIL.

  • AnoNYC

    I have a useless iPhone/iPod audio/video connector in my car I paid $50 for back in like 2010. Useless now with the new format, and I haven’t owned an iPhone since like 2011.

    Should have gone with the bluetooth instead back then.

  • Riverduckexpress

    Now that the B46 local has replaced the limited in Williamsburg its reliability is almost guaranteed to drop. Hope nobody rides the B46 local…

  • Vooch

    Dedicated bus Lanes 7am – 7pm should be the default. In Transit deserts, dedicated Bus Lanes should be 24/7. People need these buses on weekends also.

    Dedicated Bus Lanes also should not be dependent on introducing SBS. If dedicated Bus lane Is a good idea for SBS, then Why not for routes having old style local Bus Service ?

  • Should be 12:00am to 11:59pm

  • vbtwo31984

    7am-7pm is enough for Utica Ave.
    After 7pm, the car traffic drops a lot, and everyone moves a lot faster.

    During mid-day, it’s a nightmare though even with the bus lanes. There’s usually a bunch of trucks standing in the bus lane around the meat packing plant. There’s also pretty much 2 blocks completely double parked around Church Ave. I once saw a cop in a car telling everyone to move away and stop blocking the bus lane, but I’m sure it was all completely blocked again in 2 minutes.

    Haven’t noticed the light priority, but I do notice that the lights are timed extremely poorly, and people driving at the speed limit will stop every 1-2 blocks. In order to not stop, you must drive at around 35mph and that way you can hit green lights a lot more frequently. This is very poor design.

    Also, there already is a bus bulb at Ave N southbound.

  • RGD

    They have plenty of other cycling articles. Buses are simply the last mode of transport to not have had any major reforms made to them in recent years.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Utica Avenue Select Bus Service Will Roll Out This Fall

|
The B46 is the second-busiest bus route in New York City, carrying nearly 50,000 passengers each day. A subway line on Utica was planned decades ago but never built, and today bus riders on the B46 struggle with crowded conditions and slow trips. Now service is set to get faster and more reliable with the addition of bus […]

Every Bus Should Get Priority at NYC Traffic Signals

|
New York City buses serve more than two million trips on an average weekday — more than twice the ridership as Los Angeles, which has the nation’s second-largest bus system. And yet the city’s buses are also notoriously slow and unreliable. Gridlocked traffic, long boarding queues, and the succession of traffic lights bog down surface transit in NYC […]