City Will Need More Than Signs to Get Drivers to Follow 25 MPH Speed Limit

DOT will conduct a weeks-long publicity campaign and post thousands of signs to alert motorists to the city’s new 25 mph speed limit, Transportation Commissioner Polly Trottenberg told City Council members today.

The council will soon pass legislation to enact the lower speed limit, which was enabled by Albany earlier this year. In testimony before the transportation committee this morning (video link here), Trottenberg also said that while pedestrian and motor vehicle occupant deaths are down this year, drivers have killed twice as many cyclists compared to this point in 2013.

Beginning November 7, the default speed limit in New York City will be lowered from 30 to 25 mph. On October 13, Trottenberg said, DOT will launch a “25 Days to 25 MPH” education program. Flyers will be distributed at high crash locations, reminders will be printed on muni meter receipts, and signs posted at public parking facilities. In addition DOT will install and replace speed limit signs on streets, at highway exits, and at other locations, including airport car rental lots.

But as council members and advocates at the hearing pointed out, it will take more than signage to slow motorists down. “The truth is enforcement is needed,” said Council Member Jimmy Van Bramer. “The enforcement piece is ultimately what will change the culture and behavior of drivers.”

Trottenberg said she has met with NYPD Chief of Transportation Thomas Chan, and told council members DOT will work “hand in glove” with NYPD. No one from NYPD testified at today’s hearing.

Pedestrian fatalities are down 22 percent compared to last year, and overall traffic deaths have decreased by 7 percent, Trottenberg said. But drivers have killed 17 people on bikes this year, a 100 percent increase from 2013. Chair Ydanis Rodriguez said the transportation committee’s next hearing will focus on cyclist safety.

Paul White, executive director of Transportation Alternatives, called on Mayor de Blasio to budget for physical improvements on high-traffic streets, known as arterials, by 2017. Arterials make up 10 percent of the city’s roads, but crashes on those streets account for more than half of pedestrian and cyclist deaths.

As was pointed out several times during the hearing, data show that lowering driver speeds mitigates the severity of collisions and saves lives. Yet at one point discussion turned to whether safety should take precedence over driver convenience.

“I am all for trying to slow people down,” said Council Member Mark Weprin, of Queens, “but there’s definitely areas in my district where people are going to go crazy when they hear it’s 25 miles an hour.”

Weprin said he has been “inundated” with complaints from drivers in his district who have received speed camera tickets — triggered only when a motorist is speeding by 11 mph or more near a school during school hours. Among those ticketed, Weprin said, was his 80-year-old father-in-law. Weprin said some people “drive a lot,” and said it’s difficult to drive 25 mph on some streets, like Union Turnpike and the Long Island Expressway service road, because most drivers are speeding. When speed limits are lowered, said Weprin, “The number of complaints will increase.”

Weprin questioned the placement of speed cameras near certain schools. He asked that DOT consider higher speed limits on streets with less motor vehicle or pedestrian traffic, including parts of Northern Boulevard, one of the most dangerous streets in the city for pedestrians.

“It’s a big city and not all neighborhoods are the same,” said Weprin. “I don’t want to be too pie in the sky about this, but we’re going to take law abiding citizens and turn them into law breakers.”

Trottenberg agreed that neighborhoods are different, and said some streets mentioned by Weprin would not have the new speed limit. “Going 41 miles per hour in front of a school, I think that’s something we want to discourage,” she said.

Council Member Margaret Chin, who represents lower Manhattan, asked that DOT consider lowering the speed limit on South Street and parts of West Street, which have high pedestrian volumes. Trottenberg and DOT Deputy Commissioner Ryan Russo said it would take about a year to determine which streets would have higher or lower speed limits, based on criteria that will include crash data.

  • qrt145

    Populism was when the limit was increased from 25 to 30 mph 50 years ago. But you are right that without enforcement or design changes, the new speed limit doesn’t mean much.

  • angry driver

    I’ve tried the speed limit on eastern parkway in Brooklyn and literally hit every damn light thats ridiculous what they need to do is teach the damn pedestrians how to cross the street the proper way and not just dart out in the sstreet like they have bumpers and maybe it will be less likely for them to get hit y penalize the drives for some simple ass pedestrians …

  • jessicabeth evans

    honestly speed limits are such a pain i should be able to drive as fast as possible and if i hit someone too bad it’s my fault i go to federal prison and develop a shallow relationship with a an inmate named bernice who happens to have a beard and then when i finally leave prison i can visit her and then slowly drift away as she finds a new partner.

    Honestly the speed limits in the magna wvc area are awful i should be able to drive faster than 40 mph when nobody is out and about during the day the truth tea has been spilt on udot

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Lentol Wants 20 MPH Speed Limits on Big, Dangerous Brooklyn Streets

|
This afternoon, Assembly Member Joseph Lentol announced that he’s sent a letter to Transportation Commissioner Polly Trottenberg asking for 20 mph speed limits on the busiest, deadliest roads in his district. “There are three main streets within my district that are notorious for speeders – McGuinness Boulevard, Kent Avenue, and Park Avenue,” Lentol wrote in […]